Pros and Cons of the Mandatory Seatbelt Law Essay

Pros and Cons of the Mandatory Seatbelt Law Essay

Length: 1453 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

An enormous division currently exists between the people who believe that automobile safety should be an option and those that feel it must be a requirement. The federal government feels the morally obligated to create the safest driving environment possible. On the other end of the spectrum, opinions exist that the average driver has ability to make the choice of safety on their own. Editorials, political assemblies, debates, and conversations have arrived on the concept of click it or ticket. This idea refers to ticketing any motor vehicle driver and passenger that is not fastened by a seat belt. Arguments have been made for both sides, and have been reviewed in multiple states.

One particular article has been written, by Dr. Walter E. Williams, that discussed the negatives of click it or ticket, and has actually demoralized this idea (Williams 2003). The article is properly titled 'Click It or Ticket', and was written in the fall of 2004. His educated opinions reflect one side of the controversial argument; however also contain bias statistics and opinionated logic.

Dr. Williams has researched the programs purpose and actions and feels strongly against the policy (Williams 2003). His motive of convincing readers to side with him exists in his tone of rebellion, astonishment, and confusion. His argument lies on the basis of opinion and not practicality. On the other hand, his reasons are just and well-explained, and therefore make for a liable argument. Dr. Williams provides statistics, facts, and general observations to collectively explain his view of the click it or ticket policy (Williams 2003).

The first area of Dr. Williams? argument focuses on government responsibility, rights, and laws (Williams 2003). His ge...


... middle of paper ...


...ay of laws and reasonable policy. Dr. Williams is obviously an individual of knowledge and pride, however, his education may not provide the key his views of positive policy. Instead of viewing the governments? attempt at safety as a negative authority, he should reflect on the physical benefits instead of the intangible conflicts. Therefore, the ?Click It or Ticket? article described one way of viewing a current law of governing safety. Dr. Williams clearly disagrees, but an audience should generally view the attempt at safety as the proper acts of government as opposed to the negative. Safety is a necessity for a civil society, and click it or ticket laws allow for a safer than nothing transportation situation. This should be appreciated and will eventually quiet all critics by accurate statistics of saved lives while maintaining a reasonable spending platform.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Mandatory Minimums : Prison Sentences Imposed On Offenders By Law Essay

- Mandatory minimums, harsh prison sentences imposed on offenders by law, where discretion is limited. Offenders, most of the time nonviolent, are faced with prison terms that are meant for a drug kingpin, not a low level first or second time offender. Mandatory minimums have been proven not to be the answer in our criminal justice system and need to be changed. Mandatory Minimums has created a problem within our society where we send everyone to prison and don 't present offenders with better opportunities....   [tags: Prison, Mandatory sentencing, Crime]

Better Essays
1528 words (4.4 pages)

Mandatory Sentence : Mandatory Sentencing Essay

- Mandatory Sentence Mandatory sentencing refers to the practice of parliament setting a fixed penalty for the commission of a criminal offence. Mandatory sentencing was mainly introduced in Australia to: prevent crime, to incapacitate the offenders, to deter offenders so they don’t offend again, to create a stronger retribution and to eliminate inconsistency. There is a firm belief that the imposition of Mandatory sentencing for an offence will have a deterrent effect on the individual and will send a forcible message to the offenders....   [tags: Mandatory sentencing, Crime, Judicial discretion]

Better Essays
1349 words (3.9 pages)

Mandatory Minimum Sentences Are Not Effective Essay

- Mandatory minimum prison sentences are punishments that are set through legislation for specific offenses. They have been used throughout history for different crimes. The four traditional goals of punishment are: deterrence, incapacitation (incarceration), retribution, and rehabilitation. With the state of our national economy, cutting prison and corrections costs would be a huge savings. On the surface, it may seem that mandatory minimum sentences would serve the traditional goals of punishment....   [tags: Mandatory Minimums,Costly and Ineffective]

Better Essays
1318 words (3.8 pages)

The Importance of Wearing a Seatbelt Essay

- The Importance of Wearing a Seatbelt We have all heard the excuses before, "It's uncomfortable, I'm only going around the corner", I'd rather be thrown out of a car than be stuck in a seatbelt," and my favorite, "I'm a good driver I don't need to wear one." Well you may be a good driver but there are situations beyond your control such as bad weather, road conditions and not to mention other drivers that can affect your safety. Seat belts can mean the difference between life and death in an auto accident....   [tags: Argumentative Safety Driving Accidents Essays]

Better Essays
978 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about Mandatory Minimum Sentences For Nonviolent Offenders

- It was June 18, 1971, the day that the United States of America would change forever. It was the day that President Richard Nixon declared that the war on drugs was the number one priority in the American criminal justice system. Throughout the years following this speech congress enacted a number of laws to keep with the president 's wishes, one of which, was mandatory minimum drug sentences. Mandatory minimum drug sentences are exactly what they sound like mandatory sentences for various drug offenses....   [tags: Prison, Mandatory sentencing, United States]

Better Essays
1039 words (3 pages)

Essay about Should Wearing A Seatbelt?

- There is a massive amount of car accidents that occur every day, that consequently become fatal. In many cases, the driver and the passengers do not have on a seat belt to prevent them from being thrown out of the car or colliding with another car, causing them to be thrown against the dashboard or some other tragic accident. Some people may think, “Wearing a seatbelt isn’t cool”, “I’m only going down the street” or sometimes just irresponsibly forget to put on their seatbelt when they are inside of a vehicle....   [tags: Automobile, Tram accident, Injury, Accidents]

Better Essays
1109 words (3.2 pages)

Legalizing Marijuana: Pros and Cons Essay

- The war on drugs is a movement of prohibition and military aid being undertaken by the United States government intended to both define and reduce the illegal drug trade. In the year 2010 the U.S. government spent $15 billion on the war on drugs, at a rate of $500 per second. State and local governments spent another $25 billion as well. In 2007, $42 billion was spent on the marijuana prohibition. That is more money than the war on drugs spent on all types of drugs three years before when $40 billion was spent all together....   [tags: Drugs, Pros and Cons]

Better Essays
1595 words (4.6 pages)

Should Mandatory Vaccinations Be Mandatory? Essays

- Evaluative Summary Jessica Boyd English 104 Andre Berchiolly Northern Illinois University 31 January 2015 Vaccinations are currently a very controversial topic and seeing as though all 50 states require students to have certain vaccinations before entering school; it must be a logical reason as to why that is. However, parents or guardians are still allowed to get this requirement waived, and that is what makes the topic so controversial. Some people feel as though this requirement should not be waived, because it is not safe, but others do not have a problem with it at all....   [tags: Vaccination, Vaccine]

Better Essays
1939 words (5.5 pages)

Israel 's Mandatory Service Law Essay

- Israel’s mandatory service law requires every citizen in Israel in the age of eighteen until they are twenty one years old, legally obligated to join the army for a period of three years. After high school, the time came for me to do my duty to Israel which was compulsory service. It was a big responsibility that this is the true test that makes absolute separation between a comfortable life as a student and as preparation for real life as a full-fledged citizen. I cannot describe in words the feeling of pride when I wore the uniform....   [tags: Military, Soldier, English-language films, Battle]

Better Essays
1027 words (2.9 pages)

Reasons to wear a seatbelt Essay

- “August 2000, our family of six was on the way to a wedding. It was a rainy day, and Gregg was not familiar with the area. The car hit standing water in the high-way, and started hydro-planing. Greg lost control of the car. Then, the car went backwards down into a ditch and started sliding on its wheels sideways. After sliding for 100 feet or so, the car flipped, at least once. After flipping, the car came to rest on its wheels, and the passenger window broke out....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Free Essays
767 words (2.2 pages)