Essay on Textual Analysis of Writing Guides

Essay on Textual Analysis of Writing Guides

Length: 3500 words (10 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Let me introduce you to the main characters in the story of composition. Our hero—the protagonist—is known as “the writer,” who is supported by both the writing instructor—our hero’s mentor traditionally—and the reference guide. And of course, as is necessary in all good stories, there is the antagonist—the evil force that our hero must contend with; in this tale the “writing” will be the daunting task that is loathed and dreaded by our hero.
Where once the teaching of composition was left primarily to English teachers, there are now other sources—namely reference guides on writing—that claim to have the formula for success. There are a number of publishers who have capitalized on employing rhetorical strategies of sarcasm and humor to gain a larger share of the reference guide market. In this paper I will examine a few of these writing guides—specifically: Barron’s Painless Writing, The Complete Idiot’s Guide to Writing Well, and Research Papers for Dummies—that have become so popular, extracting how they position the writer, the instructor and the writing process, as well as considering the usefulness of these texts for English 131 student1.
It is clear that these books are appropriating similar generic features to appeal to a certain type of audience. Humor is the main component used by all, from the title that refers to the person using the book as a self-proclaimed “dummy” or “idiot”—clearly an intelligent person would not be reading the “idiot’s guide—to the cartoons and jokes that fill the pages. On the cover and back of each book, they make their claims about what the offer the student. Each guide claims to provide advice that will “help” writers to “improve” or “transform” their writing with very similar language: ...


... middle of paper ...


...ity, Montréal, Canada.http://www.masondissertation.elephanthost.com/. 2002
Miller, Richard E. As if Learning Mattered: Reforming Higher Education. Ithaca &
London: Cornell UP. 1998
Stygall, Gail. Ed. Academic Discourse: Readings for Argument and Analysis.
Mason, Ohio: Thomson Learning Custom Publishing. 2000
Rozakis, Laurie. The Complete Idiot’s Guide to Grammar & Style. Indianapolis, IN: Alpha Books. 2000.
------, The Complete Idiot’s Guide to Writing Well. Indianapolis, IN: Alpha
Books. 1997.
Strausser, Peter. Painless Writing. New York: Barron’s. 1997.
Woods, Geraldine. Research Papers for Dummies. New York: Hungry Minds, Inc. 2002
Young, Richard. "Arts, Crafts, Gifts and Knacks: Some Disharmonies in the New
Rhetoric."  Reinventing the New Rhetoric. Eds., Aviva Freedman and Ian Pringle. Ottawa: Canadian Council of Teachers of English, 1980. 53-60.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Textual Analysis Of ' The Tethered Self ' Essay

- Textual Analysis Essay of “The Tethered Self” A professor at MIT, by the name of Sherry Turkle writes about the negative effects technology has had on our society. She begins by introducing her experience at MIT during the primitive times of the computer, a time when most faculty did not see the necessity for a personal computer. Sherry’s article is eloquently written through logical, chronological structure. She goes on to illustrate the unforeseen transformation the computer has brought upon our inner personal relationships....   [tags: Mobile phone, Technology, Appeal to emotion]

Strong Essays
737 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Textual Analysis

- Overview: The text, Writing on Demand: Best Practices and Strategies for Success is designed specifically for teachers by teachers. With a quote on the cover of the text that is highlighted by a bright orange background and explicitly states that this book is “Ideal for SAT, ACT, AP, and State Assessment Exams”, the text quickly announces that its core audience is going to be teachers within the middle school to high school range. Given the aim of this text, it proves to be a highly beneficial work for aiding teachers in understanding how to adequately prepare their students for the rigors of writing on demand, be it for regular classroom assignments or standardized tests....   [tags: Teaching Writing 2014]

Strong Essays
2440 words (7 pages)

Textual Dynamics: What Context Enables the Audience to See Essay

- “disconnection occurs, the voice loses its origin, and the author enters into his own death.” Textual dynamics employs the ideas of Roland Barthes to convey messages to the audience that the words are not able to. The audiences view of texts have not been moulded by what the author would like to be seen but rather what context enables them to see. These properties are observed in all texts but can be seen largely in Sally Potter’s 1992 film “Orlando” which is able to deconstruct reality and common perceptions....   [tags: Textual dynamics, audience,]

Strong Essays
727 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about A Textual Analysis of the Opening Sequence of Gladiator

- A Textual Analysis of the Opening Sequence of Gladiator In this essay, I will explain the opening sequence of Gladiator in detail. I will describe the effects it has on the audience, and look at the way it makes them feel and the way in which events are portrayed. I will look at in depth: The themes and atmosphere, the camera techniques and how audience emotions are manipulated. At the end, I will include a conclusion giving my opinion of how the sequences used are effective for the audience....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1128 words (3.2 pages)

In-Class Essay Writing Analysis

- When I think back to the time right before we started writing our essay I realize that in order to come up with any ideas for the paper we had to chew on one thought for over ten minutes. For example when I read the sentence that we wrote about fast-paced live of professionals that reside in the city, I remember that just that one sentence took us about fifteen minutes to finally use it on our paper. It seems like we should have done some free-writing before we started this assignment. When we started to write this essay we didn’t have a clear visual on our thesis....   [tags: Writing Analysis]

Strong Essays
1455 words (4.2 pages)

Textual Analysis Is Not Enough When Researching Media Essay

- Greg Philio argues that textual analysis is not enough when researching media, on its own textual analysis fails to tell us how the text was produced as well as how it was consumed and interpreted. Philio examines this idea by stating that we fail to know the origins of the media such as where they came from and how they relate to different social interests. It also lacks the possible accounts chosen and the diversity within them as well as the impacts of external factors such as the journalists understanding and what the text actually means to different audiences (Philo, 2007)....   [tags: Research, Scientific method, Sociology]

Strong Essays
832 words (2.4 pages)

A Close Textual Analysis of Corporate Layoff Memos Essay

- All employers occasionally must deliver bad news to their employees, but few bad news situations can compete with the delicate task of announcing layoffs. In an electronic age, when layoff notices delivered via email are quickly leaked to outsiders, CEOs must take into account not only the employees who will be affected by the layoffs, but also the reporters, bloggers, and stock analysts who will undoubtedly see the emails. In an attempt to please these multiple audiences, employers—like the three CEOs who wrote the memos that are the focus of this column—often downplay the negative news or sandwich it between hopeful predictions about the future....   [tags: Business Management]

Strong Essays
1408 words (4 pages)

Analysis Of George Orwell 's Textual And Visual Worlds Essay

- The Parallels Between George Orwell’s Textual and Visual Worlds George Orwell 's 1984 is a foretelling work of textual art. It provides a means for people to develop a farsighted view of the message that Orwell portrayed throughout the story. That message portrayed was to become aware of the risk that our society runs of becoming automatons annihilated by different forms of control and people who want to acquire and use power. The story occurs in the year 1984 a state called Oceania. Oceania is one of three totalitarian superpowers in the aftermath of World War 11 Europe, along with Eurasia and Eastasia....   [tags: Nineteen Eighty-Four, Totalitarianism]

Strong Essays
1636 words (4.7 pages)

Irving Textual Analysis of "The Legend Of Sllepy Hollow" Essays

- Textual Analysis of "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow" 1.) Romantic Description: a. pg. 715 - "there is a little valley, or rather lap of land, among high hills, which is one of the quietest places in the whole world.  A small brook glides through it, with just a murmur enough to lull one to repose; and the occasional whistle of a quail, or tapping of a woodpecker, is almost the only sound that ever breaks in upon the uniform tranquility." Irving describes nature as an untouchable force.  He ignores the realism of nature and reveals only the beauty it holds.  It is the stereotypical description of Mother Nature.  Irving makes it sound so tranquil as if this place doesn’t e...   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
1707 words (4.9 pages)

Essay on Writing Analysis

- Writing Analysis Part A: Positive Descriptive Narrative: Fond Escape Finally, the weekend has arrived. Not only is it the weekend, but it is Labor Day weekend. I’ve just received word from my boyfriend that he may be coming to Mobile to visit me tomorrow if the weather permits. I softly place the telephone back into its cradle and step outside to have an afternoon lounge on the balcony of my apartment. The glass door glides open, and my bare feet brushes against the smooth concrete of the balcony....   [tags: Writing Literature English Essays Papers]

Strong Essays
1505 words (4.3 pages)