Comparing the Film Black Orpheus and the Original Greek Myth Essay

Comparing the Film Black Orpheus and the Original Greek Myth Essay

Length: 1362 words (3.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Comparing the Film Black Orpheus and the Original Greek Myth

The story of Orpheus and Eurydice is one that has been retold countless times over the years. It started as a Greek myth, later being made into a movie titled Black Orpheus. After reading the myth and watching the movie, it is easy to see that there are far more differences in the two works than similarities. These differences are not only in the way the story is told, but also in the organization of the events that take place and in the description of the characters. The main differences in these two versions of the myth are the role of the characters, the main plot scheme, and the journey into the underworld.
The characters in the movie, Black Orpheus, are significantly altered from the Greek myth. In the myth, Orpheus and Eurydice are together from the beginning and are completely in love. Everyone is happy for their love and the only thing that stands in their way is death. In the movie, however, this is notably changed. Orpheus begins as a streetcar conductor that was engaged to Mira, giving the idea that Orpheus was in love with another woman. We quickly see that this is not the case as Orpheus is always very curt and rude with his fiancée. They are slated to get married, but there is an eerie feeling in the air that something is about to go wrong.

The main difference with these characters is that in the movie, Orpheus cheats on his fiancée. We soon see that Eurydice is the wildcard when it comes to Orpheus. It does not matter whether or not he is with another woman, she will do what it takes to win Orpheus’s love. This is where one of the main differences occurs. Contrary to the myth, Orpheus cheats on his fiancée and gives his love and affection to Eurydic...

... middle of paper ...

... Orpheus thinks that a trick is being played on him and turns around, causing Eurydice to be lost forever. This leads the viewer to believe that Orpheus was not really in the underworld and that this was just a fake journey into a nonexistent underworld. It seems quite odd that anyone can walk down a spiral staircase and be placed at the gates of Hades. This is the main reason the journey into the underworld appears to be a false one.

Overall, the two versions of the story convey the same message, but in very different ways. From the differences in the characters to the plot variances, we can see that the similar messages can be portrayed in a variety of ways. The story of Orpheus and Eurydice is an ancient one that will forever be retold and altered. A prime example of this was shown in the differences between the original myth and that movie of Black Orpheus.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Contrasting the Black Orpheus Film and the Greek Myth of Orpheus

- Contrasting the Black Orpheus Film and the Greek Myth of Orpheus and Eurydice If you met a man named Orpheus who had a girlfriend, would you assume her name was Eurydice. Many people would, because the myth of Orpheus and Eurydice is from “many, many thousand years ago” and is still passed on today, verbally and through works of literature. In his 1959 film Black Orpheus, Marcel Camus interprets this well-known myth, making changes to the story to make it more dramatic and interesting. Black Orpheus is substantially different from the original myth because Orpheus has a girlfriend before meeting Eurydice, Hermes plays a different role, Orpheus kills Eurydice, Orpheus cannot bring Eurydice...   [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]

Powerful Essays
1246 words (3.6 pages)

The Myth Of Theseus And Helen Essay

- In ancient Greece, art was a means of capturing and explaining the unexplainable. All throughout Greek vases, either ancient mythology was expressed or reality was shown in an idealistic form. The Bell Krater by a follower of the Niobid Painter, exhibited two pieces of art; one on either side of the vessel. Created during 460-450 B.C. side A depicts the myth of Theseus and his pursuit of Helen, while side B shows a maid bringing news to the Queen. This ceramic Krater used the same red-figure technique on both sides, however the they are seemingly painted by two different artists....   [tags: Greek mythology, Zeus, Minotaur, Theseus]

Powerful Essays
855 words (2.4 pages)

How Herakleion Was A City Of Myth Essay

- Herakleion was a city of myth that is until its discovery in 2000 by Franck Goddio. The questions that will be answered are what type of civilization was in Herakleion which is also known as Thonis. What types of artifacts were discovered and retrieved from the site and what took place to cause this city to be buried in the waters of the Nile. The city of Herakleion was positioned at the mouth of the Nile River and was a port for travelers and merchants to pass through. Herakleion was an area of great trading due to its position on the Nile....   [tags: Egypt, Ancient Egypt, Horus, Nile]

Powerful Essays
1332 words (3.8 pages)

Greek Myth God, And Marduk Essay

- I will demonstrate that Zeus, the Greek myth god, and Marduk, the spitting image of Zeus in the Mesopotamian stories, have many similar and different characteristics, but both seem to have a similar purpose because of their power, identity, and other leadership roles and ideals. Marduk, who is said to be very handsome with limbs well made, with fire from his mouth, as well as his huge four ears and four huge eyes, is the son of Ea and Damkina. Marduk is known as the chief god in Babylon and later declared as “Lord of Universe” by other gods....   [tags: Zeus, Greek mythology, Dionysus, Hades]

Powerful Essays
1162 words (3.3 pages)

Rape, Racism, And The Myth Of The Black Rapist Essays

- In the article, Rape, Racism, and the Myth of the Black Rapist, the author, Angela Davis, discusses on the creation of the myth of the black rapist. This article brings two main ideas together to in order to make a valid argument to why both claims are false and hold no legitimacy. Davis argues that one was created in order to cover up for the other I order to veil the true offenders of sexual abuse. Davis also elaborates on the issue by adding to the argument and stating that white women are also being affected by these myths in a negative way because of the women’s bodies are being perceived as a right....   [tags: White people, Black people, African American]

Powerful Essays
1020 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about The Role of Women in Greek Mythology

- Women have given birth to new generations for centuries and have the common stereotype of being caring and gentle. But in the creation myth, women were given to man as a punishment. In the book of collected Greek tales, " Mythology Timeless Tales of Gods and Heroes", by Edith Hamilton, women take up important roles that shape each story. Although women are usually characterized as being helpful and motherly, Greek mythology, on the other hand, portrays them to cause distress, fear, and anxiety to numerous men....   [tags: mythology, greek myth, Trojan War]

Powerful Essays
600 words (1.7 pages)

The Myth Of Black Violence Essay

- Recently it has been commonly said that America is making progress to reach racial equality, and it is believed that soon the treatment of the whole population will be equal regardless of one’s race. Although, in the academic and artistic circles, racial equality is very doubtful and not a consensus. In the photograph above, a black man is being assaulted by a white cop during a peaceful protest that happened in London for race equality. While the aggression happens, the other cops just look at it without acting, as if it was normal and they were not liable for their actions....   [tags: Black people, Race, White people, African American]

Powerful Essays
1730 words (4.9 pages)

The Greek Myth Of The Gods ' Approval Through Reading Antigone Essays

- Ancient Greek myth provide stories that can be used to understand their life at that time. These stories can reflect their morals and values within their society and aid us in understanding that time in history. Though reading the Iliad, we learned their importance of war and what they value in a hero. We can understand the importance they place on the Gods’ approval through reading Antigone. Throughout the other greek myths studied in the class, women are continuously portrayed as a degradation of man....   [tags: Greek mythology, Hermes, Persephone, Demeter]

Powerful Essays
1706 words (4.9 pages)

Is the Black Family Only A Myth? Essay

- Is the Black Family Only A Myth. My objective for writing this essay on the black family was to examine and interrogate a myriad of stereotypes surrounding this family structure. Slavery and its inception need to be explored because it enables one to acquire a better understanding of the modern day black family. It is my hope that once we achieve this level of understanding, if not acceptance, that we may be able to start the healing process that is so necessary. THE MOYNIHAN REPORT. SINGLE PARENT FAMILIES....   [tags: Exploratory Essays Research Papers]

Powerful Essays
4102 words (11.7 pages)

Urban Myth Story - Original Writing Essay example

- Urban Myth Story - Original Writing It was a very murky, misty night. The wind was whistling. A young lady was driving down a deserted road in her small car. It was around half ten at night, Mary was driving home from University. She was very tired and apprehensive, as she was driving alone at night along an abandoned road. As she was driving, the full moon was shone through the bare branches casting eerie shadows on the path where she saw a strange lady. She looked closer and saw a frail, old lady hobbling down the road....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
817 words (2.3 pages)