One of the most intriguing science-and-culture debates of the twentieth century is that of the origin of behavior. The issue that has its roots in biology and psychology is popularly framed as the "nature versus nurture" debate. At different points in time, consensus has swung from one to the other as the supposed cause of our actions. These changes are not only the result of an internal dynamic but were subject (as they are today) to external influences, most notably politics and developments in other academic disciplines. The oversimplified polarities in this case-study illustrate an important characteristic of the larger scientific process. In search of a more refined theory, these are the necessary stepping stones in the attempt to get it 'less wrong'.
Historical developments of a political nature have had a significant impact on the way the nature-nurture debate developed. Social Darwinism is a doctrine based on genetic determinism and natural selection, advocating a laissez-faire capitalist economy and promoting eugenics, racism and the inherent inequality of such a society. Extending Darwin's theory of evolution to social thought and political philosophy, the biologically-deterministic view culminated in the extremism of Nazi Germany. After the horrors of World War II, the debate swung in favor of "nurture", with American psychologists taking up a rhetoric of environmental influences on behavior, emphasizing the learning process. In turn, the European school of ethology arose in opposition to the environmentalists, focusing on innate behavior (that is, their genetic origins). While this divergence was eventually resolved, according to Barlow (1991)1 the s...
... middle of paper ...
...3), 291-308. Retrieved from Lexis-Nexis.
9) Richelle, Marc N. (1993). B F Skinner: A Reappraisal. Hove, UK: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
10)Cowley, G. (1995, March 27). It's time to rethink nature and nurture. Newsweek, 125(13), 52-53. Retrieved from Lexis-Nexis.
11)Morrish, John. (2003, April 27). Books: Don't keep your baby in a soundproof box, Mr Scientist; Nature Via Nurture by Matt Ridley. Independent on Sunday, Sunday features, 19. Retrieved from Lexis-Nexis.
12)De Waal, Frans B.M. (1999). The end of nature versus nurture. Scientific American, 281(6), 94-99. Retrieved from Expanded Academic.
13)Laland, Kevin; Brown, Gillian. (2002, August 3). The Golden Meme: Memes offer a way to analyse human culture with scientific rigour. Why are social scientists so averse to the idea. New Scientist, 175(2354), 40-43. Retrieved from Expanded Academic.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The debate of nature versus nurture has been argued for a long period time. The concept of tabula rasa was popularized by John Locke; it stated that babies are born into this world without innate knowledge. Knowledge and personality are developed through experiences and environment, emphasising the nurture in the nature-nurture split. At first blush, Frankenstein avidly supports the theory but in some other parts it does not. The novel’s support of tabula rasa is easiest to see through the creature’s emotional development.... [tags: Nature versus nurture, Tabula rasa, Innatism]
1403 words (4 pages)
- Born and Raised Albert Camus once said, “Man is the only creature who refuses to be what he is.” But what makes man what he is. Is it his sheer genetic makeup, or is it the way he was raised. The nature vs. nurture debate has raged on for centuries, but neither side has been able to prove their point indefinitely. Even today we see displays of the contrast between genetics and learned behaviors, some of which are athletics, intelligence, medical histories, etc. Every person is completely unique, a combination of genetic makeup and environment make an individual who they are.... [tags: Nature versus nurture, Eugenics, Human behavior]
2222 words (6.3 pages)
- The Nature Versus Nurture Debate, Sociocultural and Biological factors Contributing to Youth Criminal Behaviour Youth criminal behaviour is a complex and multifaceted issue that’s becoming an increasing problem. Richards (2011) has conducted various research on Australian adolescents and found that 21 percent of all offenders processed by Victoria Police were juveniles and that crimes peaked at ages 16-20 for violent and non-violent crimes, thus making it a concerning issue. A topic that therefore continues to spark debates in various scientific fields is genetics and environmental social factors that influence youth’s criminal behaviour.... [tags: Nature versus nurture, Genetics, Aggression, Crime]
1364 words (3.9 pages)
- People can get their blue, hazel, or brown eyes from one of their parents, and their freckles from the other. But where does their talent for singing, or knack for craftsmanship come from. In other words, what makes individuals who they are. Is it predetermined in their genes or was it taught to them by family or friends. My General Psychology instructor recently explained this contest of nature and nurture as won by neither side. “The nature versus nurture debate is one of the oldest issues in psychology.... [tags: learning, environment, biology]
740 words (2.1 pages)
- The nature versus nurture debate is one that has continued for years arguing over whether children are effected more by their innate personality or their personal experiences. Ivan and Charles are examples that both are factors in a person’s disposition. In what ways were Ivan IV and Charles VI’s upbringing similar and did this have a comparable effect on their leadership and later mental diagnosis. Ivan IV and Charles VI had a similar upbringing in relation to their lineage and throne inheritance which led to their analogous leadership styles and mental illnesses.... [tags: Mental disorder, Psychiatry, Mental health]
1390 words (4 pages)
- Nature vs Nurture Debate Nature versus Nurture is the issue of the degree to which environment and heredity influence behavior and development. In this issue nature can be defined as, behaviors due to heredity. Which means behaviors are based on the genetic makeup of an individual and is an influence of the individuals' growth and development throughout life. On the other hand nurture are causes of behaviors that are environmental. Which means the influence is from, parents, siblings, family, friends and all other experiences to which the individual is exposed to.... [tags: Socialization Genes Science Nature Essays]
454 words (1.3 pages)
- “Nature is all that a man brings himself into the world; nurture is every influence which affects him after his birth (Rosch).” Nature vs Nurture is an age old debate on how what affects the human mind. What makes it tick. Is it genetics that decides how smart a person is. What about the environment in which they are raised. The nature side of the debate is that people are pre-programmed in the womb to behave and think a certain way. The nurture side believes that people are shaped by their surroundings more than genetics.... [tags: Nature versus nurture, Eugenics]
1440 words (4.1 pages)
- ... Altruism is also present in human infants. These infants have not been taught any social guidelines. They selflessly help other humans anyway, like with assisting in tasks like opening doors. This proves the experience theory wrong, since the infants have no experience of learning how to be selfless. Finally, scientists working in twin studies also found with their results that altruism is not learned, but genetic. Identical twins share 100% of genes, while fraternal twins share 50% of genes.... [tags: genetics versus environment]
775 words (2.2 pages)
- The Nature vs. Nurture Debate No change in circumstances can repair a defect of character. Ralph Waldo Emerson One of the great controversial debates in Psychology is determining if characteristics and behavior are primarily due to genetics or the environment. We can now readily accept that genes determine our eye color, height, blood type, and other biological factors. Do these same genes that determine anatomy also determine our tendency towards traits such as violence, homosexuality or alcoholism.... [tags: Papers]
1310 words (3.7 pages)
- How the Pendulum Swings: The Nature-Nurture Debate One of the most intriguing science-and-culture debates of the twentieth century is that of the origin of behavior. The issue that has its roots in biology and psychology is popularly framed as the "nature versus nurture" debate. At different points in time, consensus has swung from one to the other as the supposed cause of our actions. These changes are not only the result of an internal dynamic but were subject (as they are today) to external influences, most notably politics and developments in other academic disciplines.... [tags: Biology Essays Research Papers]
1663 words (4.8 pages)