Essay The Lobotomy

Essay The Lobotomy

Length: 1800 words (5.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Better to Have a Bottle in Front of Me Than a Frontal Lobotomy


In the movie, "One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest," Mcmurphy, the main character, undergoes a frontal lobotomy ("cutting of the lobes") to treat his ‘mental illness,’ after several rounds of ECT were unsuccessful in crushing his spirit. In the final scenes of the movie we see from his disposition that he has been reduced from an animated, hyperactive state to a vegetative state. McMurphy’s friend, Chief, tries to talk him, but he stares straight ahead and does not respond. The movie takes place in an insane asylum in the 1950’s, the height of the lobotomy craze in the United States. Between 1939 and 1950, nearly 20,000 documented lobotomies were performed, and thousands more in other countries (1). At first the procedure was used in lieu of Electronic Shock Therapy, for rowdy patients who did not respond well to ECT. The lobotomy was applied as a ‘"fix-all" solution for people with all kinds of major or minor mental disorders. Of course, such an invasive procedure is meant to be used only as a last resort in severe cases of debilitating illness. Many doctors, looking for a quick fix for their patients, used the procedure in cases of "undesirable behavior." Unfortunately, such a broad criterion meant that anything from Schizophrenia to Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD), to unruly behavior in general could be treated by lobotomy. In Japan many of the people lobotomized were just children who did not behave well or who performed poorly in school.

What started the lobotomy craze? As with any result, it is difficult to say what exactly prompted the explosion in popularity of such a gruesome surgery. We can begin by exploring the origins of lobotomy in general: In th...


... middle of paper ...


...d for the rest of their lives. It made so many people worse." As for McMurphy, it is clear in the end of the film that he has no way out of the mental hospital, for he is nearly a vegetable, and no one in such a state could be self-sufficient. And so, by killing him, Chief is giving his friend freedom and thus is actually demonstrating an incredible amount of love and reverence for his friend who fell victim to ‘the system,’ as so many others did who are STILL in asylums today.




References

1)History of Lobotomy,http://www.epub.org.br/cm/n02/historia/lobotomy.htm

2)PBS Website, http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/aso/databank/entnes/dh35lo.html

3)Nobel Prize Website, http://nobelprize.org/medicine/articles/moniz/

4)Research Articles, http://www.psychosurgery.org/articles.html

5)The Frontal Lobe, http://www.cbc/natureofthings/features/brain/brainmain.htm

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Handbook of Postmodern Lobotomy Essay

- Since Egaz Moni created lobotomy as invasive surgical technique to treat certain mental illnesses, rivers of ink have run for and against it. Originally, the new therapy was adopted heartily by those who wanted to get rid of headaches ... this is, other people, of course: Do I have a rebellious son or a daughter. Lobotomy. My niece is a bit frivolous, and my sister does not know what to do with her. Lobotomy. My wife is very jealous. Lobotomy. My mother-in-law tortures my life. Lobotomy. In the U.S., a country that always to adopt new everything (if work, it is good), it came as between 40,000 and 50,000 surgeries....   [tags: Egaz Moni, Mental Illness]

Powerful Essays
1264 words (3.6 pages)

American Lobotomy Essay

- Since Egaz Moni created lobotomy as invasive surgical technique to treat certain mental illnesses, rivers of ink have run for and against it. Originally, the new therapy was adopted heartily by those who wanted to get rid of headaches ... this is, other peoples, of course: Do I have a rebellious son or a daughter. Lobotomy. My niece is a bit frivolous, and my sister does not know what to do with her. Lobotomy. My wife is very jealous. Lobotomy. My mother-in-law tortures my life. Lobotomy. In the U.S., a country that always to adopt new everything (if work, it is good), it came as between 40,000 and 50,000 surgeries....   [tags: Sociology ]

Powerful Essays
1475 words (4.2 pages)

Lobotomy and the Quest for the I-Function Essay

- A large concern of the field of neurobiology seems to be finding and understanding a connection between the structure and function of the nervous system. What tangible system of tissues is responsible for creating a given perceived output. Some outputs can be more easily traced back to a specific 'motor symphony' and the involved structures isolated. This problem has obsessed generations of scientists. One of the first of this generation of researcher was F.J. Gall who promoted the idea that observable features of the brain could lead to an understanding of specific traits of action (7)....   [tags: Biology Essays Research Papers]

Free Essays
2324 words (6.6 pages)

Essay on Lobotomy

- Lobotomy The process of lobotomy was based on several decades of experimental and clinical evidence. Lobotomy is a neurosurgical procedure in which the nerve fibers in the bundle of white matter in the frontal lobe of the brain are severed to interrupt the transmission of various affective responses. It is seldom performed, because it has many unpredictable and undesirable effects. This includes personality change, aggression, socially unacceptable behavior, incontinence, apathy, and lack of consideration for others....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1107 words (3.2 pages)

Brain Busters: The History of Lobotomy and its Application to Neuroscience

- Brain Busters: The History of Lobotomy and its Application to Neuroscience "It seems possible that with additional experience and a minute study of the pathologic changes seen in the brain, the knife may be the means of restoring to reason many cases now considered incurable" --Emory Lamphear (1895) (5) In 1847 an Irish workman, Phineas Cage, shed new light on the field of neuroscience in a rock blasting accident which sent an iron rod through the frontal region of his brain. Miraculously enough, he survived the incident, but even more astonishing to the science community at the time were the marked changes in Cage’s personality after the rode punctured his brain....   [tags: Biology Essays Research Papers]

Free Essays
1308 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on A Crazy World: Untreated Mental Illness

- A Crazy World: Untreated Mental Illness In 1887, The World reporter Nellie Bly convinced officials she was insane by acting disturbed, and detached. Bly was quickly committed to Bellevue Hospital’s psychiatric ward. Upon arriving, she was astounded by the conditions of the hospital and the treatment of the patients. She witnessed patients being beaten, harassed, forced into isolation, and subjected to ice-cold baths that were a precursor to the modern torture method of waterboarding. Stories of the terrible treatments and conditions of the patients lead to the deinstitutionalization of mental patients and their reintegration into society....   [tags: Lobotomy Procedures, Brutality]

Powerful Essays
1124 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about Mental Disorder: What is Lobotomies?

- Imagine sitting at home all day, showing no emotion to the outside world. That is what happens to people who have lobotomies. Mental disorders are a major health concern all around the world. They can affect people starting at birth, or they can develop with age. Cures for these disorders were not very effective until the development of different types of drugs in the twentieth century. Before these drugs were invented, procedures like lobotomies were considered an acceptable treatment for certain types of mental disorders....   [tags: prefrontal lobotomy, cirgury, brain]

Powerful Essays
1245 words (3.6 pages)

A Fearless Character in Etheridge Knight's Poem, Hard Rock Returns to Prison from the Hospital for the Criminal Insane

- In Etheridge Knight's poem "Hard Rock Returns to Prison from the Hospital for the Criminal Insane," he uses a tale to describe the overbearing elements of prisons while simultaneously conveying the persecution that those who mock authority face in society. Knight effectively utilizes imagery and analogies to question the readers senses and draw them into the story. The poem's narrative is centered around a fearless character named Hard Rock. The name "Hard Rock" is a complicated pun on the American penal system....   [tags: lobotomy, corrupt, discrimination]

Powerful Essays
570 words (1.6 pages)

The Stigma of Mental Illness: Undiagnosed and Untreated Essay

- ... 4. REDUCING STIGMA There is no one way to reduce the stigma of mental illness. Shrivastava and fellow researchers provide an individual approach: One of the key requirements for success of early intervention programs is to formulate anti-stigma measures. The lack of awareness alone is not responsible for keeping patients away from treatment, but it is the fear of being labeled as mentally ill. Families know that mental illness is an ‘illness’, but prejudice and shame interferes not only in seeking treatment but also continuing with it....   [tags: Isolation, electro-convulsive therapy, lobotomy ]

Powerful Essays
2380 words (6.8 pages)

Knight’s Poem, Hard Rock Returns to Prison from the Hospital for the Criminal Insane

- Hard Rock Returns to Prison from the Hospital for the Criminal Insane is a poem by Knight, Etheridge. The poem is centered on a heroic character named Hard Rock. Knight’s poem is an allegory of oral tradition. The author depicts Hard Rock as a legend to all inmates, as his exploits are well known among the inmates. Because of his defiance, Hard Rock is sent to a Hospital for the Criminal Insane. When he comes back, Hard Rock has been lobotomized and changed into a different man. He is not the strong prisoner the other inmates have heard of, he is a shell of what he used to be with no sight....   [tags: panopticon, foucault]

Powerful Essays
1022 words (2.9 pages)