The Abortion Arguments of Cider House Rules Essay

The Abortion Arguments of Cider House Rules Essay

Length: 1103 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Abortion Arguments of Cider House Rules


I am writing this essay on a Saturday evening, not with any real contemplation, or even planning. I am writing this because I was just minutes ago watching the movie Cider House Rules. I won't go into the plot of the movie, but, to explain my motivation for writing this, I will simply describe one portion of the movie.

The scene at issue in my mind right now is one where a fourteen-year-old girl comes to the orphanage which is the setting for part of the movie. This girl came to the orphanage because it was known in the region as a place that performed abortions. She had had a crude abortion performed in such a way that she had been severely injured (her uterus was punctured by a crochet hook, and, not being a sterile instrument, this caused an infection of the uterine lining, eventually killing her). The resident doctor is disgusted by this, and uses the girl's injury as an example explaining why he performs abortions. The doctor's argument is fairly simple. If the girl had come to him, rather than the ignorant abortionist she chose, she would likely have survived. In addition, he claims that potential parents have a right to choose to be parents or to not be parents. The doctor, a seeming proponent of utilitarianism, says that this demonstrates a duty to perform abortions.

The young man to which the doctor is speaking, Homer, has been in essence an apprentice under the doctor, but has refused to perform abortions. His reasoning is this: those individuals seeking an abortion should have been responsible enough to have not conceived an unwanted child. Their lack of sexual responsibility should not be an excuse to take human life.

Homer, while not legally a doctor (having...


... middle of paper ...


...e that die do so in the commission of a wrongful act, and because of this are to be blamed for their own demise. Perhaps this sounds cold and uncaring to you. My intent is not to make some kind of case for the despising of young pregnant women who seek abortions. I feel a real sense a pity for them, but I cannot circumvent what I believe to be a solid refutation of one of the major arguments for abortion legalization.

This essay, remember is not meant to be a complete argument against abortion, but rather attempts only to address the argument used in Cider House Rules. There are many other areas of discussion which can have a great effect on the ethics of abortion. The point at which a fetus becomes a person with rights is one such area. The question of whether or not a mother is obligated to carry to term a child who is in fact a full-fledged human is another.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Analysis : The Cider House Rules Essay

- As is the case with most moral debates, too often a black and white approach is taken in order to choose a stance on the issue. Perhaps this is most true in the abortion debate as the majority of people seem to be polarized into one of two extreme opinion sets. However, the reality of life rarely deals in absolutes or black and white circumstances but rather in a varying shades of gray. Thus, a set of definitive and rigid viewpoints infrequently provides intelligible solutions when faced with actual situations and moral dilemmas....   [tags: Decision making software, Decision theory]

Strong Essays
1573 words (4.5 pages)

Essay about The Cider House Rules By John Irving

- Section One: Introduction Imagine being told that you do not have the right to choose what you do with your own body. You are presented with a situation that you are not mentally, physically, or financially prepared for, but you are told that you are not allowed an opinion that could change the outcome. You are forced to deal with it, ruin your life for the next eighteen years because you made a mistake and you do not have the option of fixing it. During the 1980’s, those against abortion attempted to get a constitution amendment passed that would ban abortions nationally (Newsman)....   [tags: Abortion, Abortion law, The Cider House Rules]

Strong Essays
1540 words (4.4 pages)

The Struggle for Acceptance in The Cider House Rules Essay

- The Struggle for Acceptance in The Cider House Rules      In The Cider House Rules, John Irving brings the orphan Homer Wells to vivid life in a rather unusual way.  Homer’s life and existence are part of a large symbolic link to the actual book itself.  Homer’s life as an orphan struggling for acceptance and to “Be of Use” is shadowed by The Cider House Rules struggle for acceptance in the mass literary market and its need to purvey its views on abortion.         After writing his first few books, Irving was left disappointed that although the literary critics embraced them, for the general masses his books fell on deaf ears.  (Hill 250) Unfortunately it is the general case tha...   [tags: Cider House Rules Essays]

Strong Essays
1705 words (4.9 pages)

Essay about The Right to Choose in Cider House Rules

- The Cider House Rules takes place during World War II. The movie opens in a New England orphanage in the early 1940’s, where Dr. Larch takes a specific interest in a young boy named Homer Wells after is returned for the second time after his adoptive parents brought him back. His first adoptive parents thought he was to quiet and then his second foster family beat him. Larch realizes that a twice returned orphan had very little chance of being adopted again, Larch then begins to teach Wells the basics of the medical profession....   [tags: pregnant. abortion, orphanage]

Strong Essays
820 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on Argument Against Abortion And Abortion

- In this paper I will be arguing in favor of Judith Jarvis Thomson view point on abortion. I am defending the use abortion and only in the first trimester. I will consider Don Marquis objections of the practice but ultimately side with Thomson. The standard argument against abortion claims that the fetus is a person and therefore has a right to life. Thomson shows why this standard argument against abortion is a somewhat inadequate account of the morality of abortion. (1) The fetus is a person (or moral equivalent) (2) It is wrong to kill persons (C) It is wrong to have an abortion....   [tags: Abortion, Morality, Pregnancy, Argument]

Strong Essays
1113 words (3.2 pages)

Arguments For And Against Abortion Essay

- There are many arguments for and against abortion one main focus is whether or not the fetus is a person. For this essay I will only be analyzing and discussing two philosophers with two different arguments, who are for and against abortion, with neither of them focusing on whether or not the fetus is a person. First I’ll examine the argument Judith Jarvis Thomson concludes, in the cases of pregnancy due to rape, in her article entitled “A Defense of Abortion.” I’ll explain how she argues for abortion being morally permissible in cases of rape and will indicate one problem with her argument....   [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Morality, Ethics]

Strong Essays
1618 words (4.6 pages)

Pitfalls Of Critical Thinking : The Cider House Rules Essay

- Pitfalls of Critical Thinking “The Cider House Rules” When I started watching The Cider House Rules I did not know what to expect. I came into this experience completely blind, as I did not watch the trailer or read any of the movie reviews beforehand. In retrospect, I am glad I did this because it prevented me from forming any biased opinions before I watched the movie. The Cider House Rules focuses on many controversial topics such as abortion and incest. It is a coming of age story about a boy named Homer and how he struggles with his own personal demons involving his adoptive father Dr....   [tags: Critical thinking, Reasoning, Thought, Abortion]

Strong Essays
947 words (2.7 pages)

Essay about An Ethical Argument Against Abortion

- Each day throughout our world, medical professionals suction thousands of babies from their mothers’ wombs through a procedure called abortion. The law protects and provides consent to both the mother and the medical professionals for these procedures. However, the babies seemingly have no right to protection or life themselves because of the argument regarding when a fetus is determined be human and have life. Pro-life author, Sarah Terzo, in a LifeSiteNews.com article, relays the following testimony supporting this from a medical student upon witnessing his first abortion, “Rejected by their mothers and regarded as medical waste by their killers, society allows these babies to die silently...   [tags: Argument Against Abortion]

Strong Essays
2133 words (6.1 pages)

Arguments Regarding Abortion Essay

- In this paper, I will discuss the pro- abortion argument presented by Judith Thomson. The main idea of Thomson’s argument is that abortion is morally permissible. In supporting her position, Thomson presents several arguments regarding the implications of the right to life that she believes the anti- abortion might have dwelled on. As I explain her arguments, I will also attempt to criticize her view on the topic. As Thomson observes, most of the common argument on abortion is to define whether or not a fetus is a person....   [tags: Fetus, Life]

Strong Essays
1176 words (3.4 pages)

Cider House Rules Essay

- The Cider House Rules" is a movie based on John Irving's best selling book. It is a very wonderful, touching, and real 1943¡¦s life story. The story centered on an orphanage child named Homer and a sick doctor, Dr Larch who will have an emotional bond with Homer. I watched the movie before, and my first impression on this movie, I think it is a very good, and relax movie, where you can watch it with your family, although some of the scene may be offended for children. The Cider House Rules, begins in the 1920s in St....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
731 words (2.1 pages)