The Debate Over the Origin of Modern Homo Sapiens Essay example

The Debate Over the Origin of Modern Homo Sapiens Essay example

Length: 1739 words (5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Debate Over the Origin of Modern Homo Sapiens

There has been a great deal of heated debate for the last few decades about where modern Homo sapiens originated. From the battle grounds, two main theories emerged. One theory, labeled “Out-of-Africa” or “population replacement” explains that all modern Homo sapiens evolved from a common Homo erectus ancestor in Africa 100,000 years ago. The species began to spread and replace all other archaic human-like populations around 35,000 to 89,000 years ago. The rivaling opinion, entitled the “regional continuity” theory or “multiregional evolution” model refutes this theory and states modern humans evolved from various species of Homo erectus who interbred with others that lived in places such as Asia, Africa, and Europe. These scientists believe this theory would explain why there are differences among races around the world.

As sound as the regional continuity theory appears, it seems to be slightly lacking in genetic support. It appears that most of the support of this theory depends on fossil record which is important information but not stable evidence. The Out-of-Africa theory relies on more than just fossil evidence but a combination of fossils and genetic studies. It is important to use this information as well as the fossil records because “various interpretations of the transition are possible if researchers concentrate on only fossil evidence, while the mtDNA studies more strongly support replacement….the best approximation of the process still appears to be an African-based spread” (Nitecki and Nitecki, 1994). In a time where technology is becoming an integral part of society, it is easier to discover information that did not seem possible before.


... middle of paper ...

...and Matthew Nitecki, eds. (1994). Origins of Anatomically Modern
Humans. Plenum Press, New York.

Noble, Ivan. (2001). Boost for ‘Out of Africa Theory [online]. BBC Available from: [Accessed 24 March 2001].

O’Hanlon, Larry. (2002). New Out-of-Africa Theory Unveiled [online]. News Brief
Available from:
[Accessed 1 April 2004].

Reuters. (2001). Scientists Challenge Evolution Theory [online]. ABC News Available
outofafrica010109.html [Accessed 24 March 2004].

Roach, John. (2002). Skull Fossil Challenges Out-of-Africa [online]. National
Geographic News Available from: [Accessed 24 March 2004].

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Origin Modern Humans Essay

- The origin of modern humans is a matter of debate. There are two different theories regarding the origin of modern humans or Homo sapiens. The first and primary theory states modern humans emerged in one place and from a single origin. This theory is known as the Recent African Origin Model. It suggests that modern humans are the product of speciation during the late Pleistocene in Africa. Homo sapiens eventually migrated out of Africa to Eurasia, and replaced all other human populations, without interbreeding....   [tags: Anthropology]

Powerful Essays
1604 words (4.6 pages)

The Origin of Modern Humans Essay

- Throughout history, humans have asked many questions in regards to our own beginnings. Religion and science have examined what makes us who we are, and have tried to answer the enduring question of our own modern origins. Scientifically, theories are still debated as to when, where, and how modern Homo sapiens came to be what they are today. There are two major theories that now dominate the discussions of experts in the field of biological anthropology: the “Out-of-Africa” model and the “Multiregional” model of evolution....   [tags: Debate, Multiregional Method, Scholars]

Powerful Essays
1944 words (5.6 pages)

Essay on Herto Homo Sapiens and the Origin of Man

- Herto Homo Sapiens and the Questionable Origin of Man Many discoveries have been made that give more and more clues to the history of life on earth. Paleontologists find artifacts throughout the world that not only answer many questions but also raise many new ones. A topic that is still a mystery today is the origin of man. Scientists often debate over where man originated from and who some of his prehistoric relatives were. Some people think that all men are related, and that there has been inter breeding between different groups of men....   [tags: Anthropology Essays Paleontology Papers]

Powerful Essays
1465 words (4.2 pages)

The Mystery of Human Origin Essay

- The Mystery of Human Origin The mystery of human origin is an often-debated topic. It is an issue that can never be proven, something as vague as the existence of God, the proof of a human soul, or even as evasive as the human psyche itself. The debate itself is divided between two main camps: the Evolutionists, who concur with Darwin's theory of evolution, survival of the fittest, and natural selection. They believe that mankind evolved from earlier versions of hominids, which in turn evolved from earlier primates....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
522 words (1.5 pages)

The Evolution of Homonin Tribe from the Time Period of Homo Habilis to Mordern

- To the ongoing question as to how humans evolved has still been a debate over several decades. Homo sapiens is a scientific name given to humans. Homo sapiens are classified under the kingdom-Animalia, phylum-chordata, class-mammalia, order-primates, family-Hominidae, genus-Homo and species-sapiens. According to Linnaeus Carlos, scientific way of classifying living organisms (Relethford, 2010). According to Relethford, Hominin is a tribe that comprises of humans and their closest ancestor. Hominin family has shown some resemblances with the evidences collected from fossil records as well as the evolutionary processes to the mordern humans....   [tags: homo sapiens, hominin family, human skull]

Powerful Essays
1230 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about The Evolution of Modern Humans

- While time travel still remains elusive to us, scientists have been able to discover things about our past as a species that were practically inconceivable over 150 years ago when Charles Darwin released his book entitled The Origin of Species. They have especially uncovered many pieces to our still incomplete puzzle over the past 20 years so that we now have a nearly complete idea of how our species Homo sapiens came to be. This story of our history includes dozens of species’ and hundreds of fossils and bones, yet fairly few complete or even partial skeletons....   [tags: Homo Sapiens]

Powerful Essays
2715 words (7.8 pages)

Neanderthal Origin, Behavior, and the Characteristics that Compare and Differentiate Them from Homo Sapiens

- ... Some components of the skull are thought to be developmentally modifiable to some extent, and therefore, these parts may be subject to the influence of the environment. (Harvati and Weaver 2006). Neanderthals are strongly distinguished from modern humans by a wide range of cranial and post-cranial characteristics (Tattersall and Schwartz 1999). Differences in cranial morphology that distinguish H. neanderthalensis from H. sapiens include the hafting of the face with a long, low vault with relatively thick bone; the face is large and protruding; a large nasal aperture and fossa and a receding zygomatic arch; a distinct double-arched and a rounded supraorbital torus (the forehead ridge rig...   [tags: late Pleistocene era, similarities, tools]

Powerful Essays
1431 words (4.1 pages)

Essay on The Big Bang Theory of the Origin of the Universe

- INTRODUCTION Since the beginning of time, people have wondered about why we are here, how we got here, and where we came from. Although many of these questions have not been answered, the question of where the universe we see today came from has been answered, or at least answered as well as possible with the technology available. Currently the leading theory for the origin of the universe is the Big Bang theory. Although some scientists still dispute this model for the development of the universe, the vast majority of scientists accept it as truth....   [tags: Origin of the Universe]

Powerful Essays
2982 words (8.5 pages)

Homo hablis Essay

- Homo hablis The next most recent ancestor of man is Homo habilis. The first ever fossil remains of Homo habilis were discovered in 1964 in Tanzania, East Africa by the Leakeys. Robert Jurmain wrote in his text book, Introduction to Physical Anthropology, "Louis Leakey suggested that there was a Plio-Pleistocene hominid with a significantly larger brain then found in Australiopithecus. They made this claim based on the findings at Olduvai Gorge." Leakey and his team gave a new species name to the fossil remains The fossils of Homo habilis are different then those of the Australopithecines by several physical characteristics such as a larger cranial cavity, smaller rear teeth, and skelet...   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
426 words (1.2 pages)

Homo Erectus Essay

- Homo Erectus In the quest to explain human origins it is necessary to find a species that bridges modern man (Homo sapiens) with the apes. To fill this gap evolutionists have set forth Homo erectus, who lived approximately 400,000 to 1.6 million years ago (Johanson and Shreeve1989). Although the distinctions are somewhat vague, below the neck, Homo sapiens and Homo erectus are practically Identical and Homo erectus was responsible for pioneering the use of standard tools (such as the hand axe), big-game hunting, and the use of fire (Johanson and Shreeve1989)....   [tags: Science Ancestry Science Essays]

Powerful Essays
1582 words (4.5 pages)