The Black Legend and White Legend: Relationship Between the Spanish and Indians in the New World

The Black Legend and White Legend: Relationship Between the Spanish and Indians in the New World

Length: 2576 words (7.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Black Legend and White Legend: Relationship Between the Spanish and Indians in the New World


The Spanish-Indian relationship can be defined in many
ways. One definition used is through the Black Legend and the
White Legend. The interpretation of the Black Legend can
depend on whom you are talking to. The Black Legend speaks of
the Spaniards abusing the Indians and being guilty of much
more misconduct than history has ever recorded. The White
Legend speaks of how the Spaniards benefitted the Indian
society by building communities, hospitals and spreading the
Word of God. There are two reasons why the Spaniards were so
intent on spreading the Gospel. The first is because Spain
wanted to ensure political and military means of safety and
independence of their own religious community and even more so
their predominance over others. The second was a deeper
desire to convert, which included appealing to the minds and
hearts of individual unbelievers by preaching, reasoning and
if needed by force (Plumb 152).

The conquest of the new world began with a small band of
Spanish soldiers. The soldiers proceeded to march against and
subdue the huge population of the mainland (Black 24). The
Black Legend speaks of all that the Spanish had done to the
Indians and the horrible things done to them and the land.
This Black Legend exists only in areas where the people are
"anti-Hispanic" especially where English is spoken, and in
modern Spanish America (24).

The White Legend is true only in reverse. The people who
claim to believe in this Legend hold to the belief that the
Spanish were a credit to society and help the Indians in their
everyday lives by providing livestock and new medici...


... middle of paper ...


... they had never intended to live. They were forced
to lose their families in the name of the Spanish crown and
the Spanish crown had only a vague knowledge of what was
really happening in the new world. Which one, whether Black
or White Legend, a person believes will have to depend on
their own personal view of the truth.


Bibliography

Gibson, Charles. The Black Legend: Anti-Spanish Attitudes
in the Old World and the new. New York: Knopf 1971.

--------- Spain in America. New York: Harper 1966.

--------- Spanish Tradition in America. Ny: Harper 1968.

Haring, C.H. The Spanish Empire in America. New York: Oxford
1947.

Ludenfeld, Marvin. 1492 Discovery Invasion Encounter. Massachussets: 1991.

Plumb, J.H. The Spanish Seaborne Empire. New York: Knopf 1966.

Sale, Kirkpatrick. The Conquest of Paradise. New York: Plume
1990.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Spanish American War : A Highly Forgotten War Essay examples

- Spanish-American War The Spanish American War is a highly overlooked war in history but is a very important piece in what shaped today’s world. The Spanish-American War of 1898 ended Spain’s rule on the western hemisphere and Spanish colonial rule in the Americas. The Spanish–American War was a strife in 1898 between Spain and the United States, the result of U.S. intervention in the Cuban War of Independence. U.S. attacks on Spain 's possessions in the Pacific led to involvement in the Philippine Revolution and ultimately to the Philippine–American War....   [tags: United States, Philippines, Spanish–American War]

Powerful Essays
1310 words (3.7 pages)

The Spanish And New England Colonies Essay

- Finally, the Spanish and New England colonies were largely similar yet somewhat different in their treatment of the indigenous people due to intermarrying with the tribes and forcing the natives into slavery. The Spanish colonies and New England had largely similar views on intermarrying with the native tribes. In the Spanish colonies, colonists started to form relationships with the indigenous people. With the almost completely male population of conquistadors being sent to the Americas from Spain, the conquerors began to marry and have children with the indigenous women....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Powerful Essays
829 words (2.4 pages)

The Control of England in North America and Demise of the Spanish Power in the Atlantic

- The Control of England in North America and Demise of the Spanish Power in the Atlantic The year 1942 marked a division in the contemporary world history. There were a number of developments that would bring enormous effects for the Old and the New World Wars. The discovery of these developments changed the diets of both the western and eastern regions, assisted in initiating the Atlantic slave trade, and spread illnesses that had a destructive effect on populations in India, and resulted in the creation of European colonies across the Western region (Cohen and Rosenzwei 124)....   [tags: columbus, spain, new world]

Powerful Essays
1501 words (4.3 pages)

The Movement of People and Creation of A New Nation Essay

- Through the course of history there were many migrations of peoples, such as the Europeans to The New World, or was later to be known as America. The British landed on America's east coast in 1492, it wasn’t long before the European explorers countered the Natives, the Native American Indians. The Natives quickly welcomed and accepted the settlers to the new land they claimed to have discovered, the Natives felt the land was to be shared. They became friends and shared the land and traded goods....   [tags: new world, native americans, colonization]

Powerful Essays
537 words (1.5 pages)

Essay about Hedonism in Hills Like White Elephants, by Ernest Hemingway

- The search of pleasure has always been an inherent desire in human nature. The roaring twenties witnessed the uprising of a society that extolled such desire through the creation of a culture solely dedicated to consume. Ernest Hemingway analyses the behavioral patterns of such culture in his short story "Hills Like White Elephants", where the concept of Hedonism- fathomed as an egotistical action whose only purpose is to bestow pleasure- and its consequences on the individual is explored. Through the characters' dialogue in which they avoid a substantial conversation and implicitly state their disappointment in life, Hemingway explores the emptiness generated by pleasure-seeking actions....   [tags: Hills Like White Elephants Essays]

Powerful Essays
1602 words (4.6 pages)

Mexican Spanish Conquest Essay

- The meeting between Hernán Cortés with the Spanish expedition into Tenochtitlan, the Mexican imperial city under the reign of Montezuma has brought a vivid depiction of the conflict and contention between these two forces that would prosper a range of different accounts and perspectives of the incidents that would consequently follow during and after the clash. Bernard Sahagún wrote the ‘Florentine Codex’ which depicts these series of events from the accounts of the indigenous and Spanish population that are based around his religious motives and interpretation of the truth....   [tags: World Civilization ]

Powerful Essays
1323 words (3.8 pages)

Essay about Taking a Look at the Spanish Conquest

- Introduction: THE SPANISH CONQUEST of the Americas is an interesting story of exploration, wealth, greed, devastation and death. The Aztec civilization, which lived in what we know today as central and South America, began to come under threat from European explorers during the late 15th century. The Aztec civilization was one of the most spectacular in the world, and at its heart was the masterpiece of the Aztec capital, Tenochtitlan. However, the prosperity and wonder of the Aztecs came to an end with the arrival of Hernan Cortés and his Spanish conquistadors....   [tags: European discovery of America]

Powerful Essays
1325 words (3.8 pages)

Spanish Conquistadors: Heroes Or Murderers Essay

- Spanish Conquistadors: Heroes or Murderers "The Indians in the first fatal decades of the white man in America were conquered because they could not conceive what it was that the white man was after, and what manner of man he was." (The Indians of the Americas, p97) This misconception, was that the Indians could not imagine was that the Spanish Conquistadors would come to the Americas and brutally murder men women and children in the name of a god. They could not see how a group of people could follow such a god....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Free Essays
812 words (2.3 pages)

The Spanish Tourism Industry Essay

- The Spanish Tourism Industry Spain has long been the European centre for package tourism. Miles of beautiful sandy beaches along with crystal clear waters of the Mediterranean attracted tourists from the 1950's onwards. Little fishing villages have grown to be massive concrete disasters filled to the brim with linear 1970's hotels along the sea. This steady progression from idyllic white walls with clay roofs to cabaret evenings and Tourist "tack" has taken 56 years but has it finally reached it pinnacle....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
570 words (1.6 pages)

Spanish Labor Systems Essay

- In the US it is very common to still hear of the poor way African Americans were treated in the early part of this nations History. We hear stories of black slaves working 18 hour days picking cotton and the trauma of slaves being beaten for disobeying their masters. For many African American families, it seems, that was the way of life not long ago. While it is very important to realize what these African Americans went through, I think it is often forgotten that indigenous people of Latin America were exploited in similar ways but through different Labor Systems....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
2172 words (6.2 pages)