Essay on The Need for Electoral College Reform

Essay on The Need for Electoral College Reform

Length: 1191 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Need for Electoral College Reform


During the horse-and-buggy era of 1789, travel to neighboring states was nearly impossible. A distance of even forty miles could require hours. Therefore journeys to non-bordering states were an extremely rare occurrence. These obstacles and the lack of communication between voters in one state and candidates in another was the constitutional framers’ main impetus for instituting an electoral college for presidential elections. This system ideally elects the most qualified candidate as deemed by educated voters: persons designated to keep abreast of current social issues and activities of political office holders and seekers. These specially selected voters would be chosen according to the will of the people. From the eighteenth (18th) century to today, this is how we elect our president.

Known as the melting pot, the United States’ diverse constituents reflect the diversity of the states themselves and elucidate the complications of change on a national level to this system. Direct election would be one option but it’s major disadvantage is that candidates may ignore smaller states because their campaign stops’ value is proportional to the concentration of people there. The electoral college, then, can be seen as a compromise between large and small states very much like the “Great Compromise” which gave smaller states equal representation in the Senate and larger (i.e. more populous) states representation by population in the House.

Third parties were another concern of the framers because they could eliminate a potential candidate if numerous third party candidates attracted even minimal votes such as those from people’s hometowns. This invite to corruption was discerned by the f...


... middle of paper ...


...on, and “What Were They Thinking” by Burt Solomon, in National Journal (Nov. 18, 2000), 1501 M St., NW, Washington, D.C. 20005

Anderson, John B. “Flunk the Electoral College, Pass Instant Runoffs,” Progressive, Vol. 65 , Issue
1, p.17-19, January 2001.

Clyburn, James E. “Electoral College Needs Reform,” New York Amsterdam News, Vol. 91, Issue
48, p.12, 11/30/2000.

_____ “Giving Credit to the Electoral College,” New Orleans Magazine, Vol. 34, Issue 4, p.13,
January 2001.

Glassman, James. “Reform the Electoral College, Don’t Toss It,” American Enterprise, Vol. 12 Issue
2, p. 16, March 2001.

Limbaugh, David. “Should America Abolish Electoral College System?” Human Events, Vol. 56
Issue 44, P. 10, 12/01/2000.

Schwarz, Frederick D. “How It Got That Way and Why We’re Stuck With It,” American Heritage,
Vol. 52, Issue 1, p.43-50, February/March 2001.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Need to Reform or Abolish The Electoral College Essay

- The Electoral College is the United States' archaic process of electing presidents. It was established in the Constitution as a compromise between election by Congress and election by popular vote. Each state is given a specific number of electors based on the number of its U.S. Representatives and Senators (NARA). This allows for over-representation of small states and under-representation of large states, while the winner-takes-all format followed by most states could result in a candidate winning the popular vote but losing the election (NARA)....   [tags: Political Science]

Strong Essays
2187 words (6.2 pages)

Democratic State Of The Electoral College Essay

- The current system that elects Presidents in the United States, the Electoral College, is in dire need of reform that would update the process to more accurately represent the will of voters. The outdated system that is the Electoral College concentrates its focus particularly on higher populated areas within states that then casts its Electoral votes to only one Presidential candidate. Despite multiple attempts by federal and state governments to change the process, only two states, Maine and Nebraska, implore a district voting system that tallies votes within a respective district and then awards its Electoral votes to a Presidential candidate regardless of how other districts within the s...   [tags: Elections, Election, Voting]

Strong Essays
1544 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on Electoral College Reform

- Electoral College Reform Since the fiasco that was the Presidential Election in the year 2000, many Americans have been calling for a reform of the Electoral College. Most of these people were Gore supporters; disillusioned by the fact that Bush won the office of the President while, in fact, he lost the popular vote. The American people did not elect George W. Bush; the Electoral College did. Last year’s circumstance was the first of its kind in over a century. There have been many close elections, but none have resulted in the popular candidate losing to his opponent....   [tags: Government Politics Political Science Essays]

Strong Essays
1903 words (5.4 pages)

The Electoral College And The Vote Essay

- Who knew that a presidential candidate who won the most votes in an election could have the possibility of losing the election. That hardly seems fair. Well, this phenomenon has taken place four times in our nation’s history, yet our government still has not fixed this problem. The difficulty of this issue lies between the Electoral College and the plurality vote. At the moment, people do not directly elect the president, but rather use their votes to tell each state’s Electoral College how to vote for the president....   [tags: President of the United States]

Strong Essays
896 words (2.6 pages)

Electoral College: Tyranny of the Majority Essay

- With a Presidential election year upon us, the United States’ national election process will once again take its place at center stage of American politics. 200 years after the Electoral College’s creation, it still serves its intended purpose, but the increasing social and political awareness in America has caused a need to look at reform in this process. The question that should be asked by every citizen as they participate in the vote next year is if the Electoral College enables the wishes of the people to be truly represented....   [tags: Politics]

Strong Essays
1794 words (5.1 pages)

Essay on The Electoral College in The United States

- Historical overview As the first Democrat in nearly 20 years to hold the position, Bill Clinton saw a successful, yet embattled tenure in the office of the presidency. As he looked to pass the torch to his Vice President Albert Gore Jr, a virtually unchallenged bid in the Democratic primary, as he carried all of the delegates, with the stance and platform of being a more moderate alternative to the liberal Senator Bill Bradley of New Jersey. The Republican Party was locked in a more challenged series of primaries with the two frontrunners being Senator John McCain of Arizona, and Governor George W....   [tags: bush, al gore, clinton, votes]

Strong Essays
1655 words (4.7 pages)

Essay about America 's Need Of Reform

- America in Need of Reform. Comparing our government as the ultimate in terms of efficiency is saying even with all the glitches in America’s political system we lead the way in superiority amongst the rest of the nations. In a true democracy, the people are in charge of the country, not the elected officials, so in retrospect elected leaders should focus more efforts on the people rather than the growth for political advantage. This is not the case in what’s happening in the United States now, for example, United States elected officials spend much of their time and money addressing certain situations such as themselves and their support groups with very little regard for helping their fello...   [tags: Election, Elections, Voter turnout, Voting]

Strong Essays
1590 words (4.5 pages)

Electoral College Vs Election Process Essay examples

- The Electoral College is a confusing topic to most people, and its effect on how votes are represented in presidential elections. Essentially people vote and electors, people assigned to vote on the people 's behalf, and the candidate that wins the popular election in that state 's gets the the Electoral College votes for that state. The amount of votes is based on the population and the first candidate to win two hundred and seventy Electoral College votes wins. This system is debated on whether it benefits or hinders the election process, and how it does this is also debated by political experts....   [tags: Election, Elections, Voting]

Strong Essays
1416 words (4 pages)

The Electoral College Was Designed During The Constitutional Convention Of 1787

- The Electoral College was designed during the constitutional convention of 1787. The Constitution gave each state two senatorial electors and a certain number of electors based on its population. This system was set in place to give everyone a say through the popular electors, yet still be able to give smaller populated states a say in the election through the senatorial electors (Schulman). This concept has served its purpose successfully for many years. However, because of continual development in America, it is time to reform the Electoral College so that it can continue to accurately represent the needs of the people....   [tags: Elections, Election, Nebraska]

Strong Essays
1049 words (3 pages)

Electoral College System Essays

- Analyze criticism of the "Electoral College" system and the alleged advantages and disadvantages of various reform proposals. The Electoral College is a system in which the individual voter does not actually vote directly for the president. When a person votes they are voting for an elector that has pledged their vote or allegiance to the running party. The Framers realized that without widespread communications available at the time and with other varying factors an "each vote counts" or "the popular vote" system would not be practical....   [tags: Political Science]

Strong Essays
1075 words (3.1 pages)