Essay on Idealism and Realism in Bernard Shaw’s Major Barbara

Essay on Idealism and Realism in Bernard Shaw’s Major Barbara

Length: 1283 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Idealism and Realism in Bernard Shaw’s Major Barbara


Submerged in their own ideas about idealism and realism, Barbara and her father Undershaft are at odds with one another in Major Barbara. In this Bernard Shaw play, minor characters are important in exemplifying these conflicting values. The moral perplexities of capitalism and charity are explored through the words and actions of Undershaft’s family, his future sons-in-law, and the common folks at the Shelter.

Thriving in the British upper class, Undershaft’s wife and son are well aware of Undershaft’s grip on Europe’s economy and government. Lady Britomart separates from her husband because he refuses to break the Undershaft tradition of training a foundling to succeed him in his arms business. Stephen does not comprehend this, and Lady Britomart attempts to explain her husband’s ways to her son: “Andrew did it on principle, just as he did every perverse and wicked thing on principle” (58). She also confides that she cannot tolerate her husband “preaching immorality while he practised morality” (59). After all, it is Undershaft who supports his family financially; however, it is also Undershaft who unashamedly laughs when others question him about his views on “right” and “wrong”. With high hopes for Barbara, Lady Britomart is disappointed that her daughter decides to join the Salvation Army: “Ever since they made her a major in the Salvation Army [Barbara] has developed a propensity to have her own way and order people about which quite cows me sometimes. It’s not ladylike” (61). Lady Britomart also comments on Barbara wanting to marry “a professor of Greek whom she has picked up in the street, and who pretends to be a Salvationist” (54), for ...


... middle of paper ...


...ey. This becomes too much for Barbara to bear: she takes off her badge and thinks that she may never be able to pray again. Bill’s taunt “Wot prawce selvytion nah?” (112) is quite right, for the common people cannot be saved simply by spiritual redemption at the Salvation Army – they need practical solutions such as jobs that will provide food and money for them.

Barbara’s Christian beliefs of “poverty and salvation” grapple with Undershaft’s gospel of “money and gunpowder”. Contributing to the moral debate are Undershaft’s family, his future sons-in-law, and the Salvation Army. Mingling idealism with realism, Major Barbara demonstrates that neither extreme is viable, for idealists often do not accomplish anything, and realists are too concerned with the practical.

Work Cited

Shaw, Bernard. Major Barbara. New York, New York: Penguin Books, 1980.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Critical Analysis of George Bernard Shaw’s Play, Arms and the Man Essay examples

- George Bernard Shaw produced Arms and the Man in 1894 which was later published in 1898 as part of his Plays Pleasant volume, which also included Candida, You Never Can Tell, and The Man of Destiny.The play was created in the era of the Victorian society, when most plays were comedies and lighter drama, nevertheless it was one of Shaw's first commercial successes. As Moliere once said satire is "biting exposure of human folly which criticizes human conduct, and aims to correct it", and in his play Arms and the Man, Shaw presents his great ability of writing satire by showing the reader a world full of misunderstandings, romance, materialism and the absurdity of life, while decrying the para...   [tags: literary analysis, literary criticism]

Strong Essays
1629 words (4.7 pages)

Idealism and Realism Essay

- “In the place where idealism and realism meet, that is where there is the greatest evolutionary tension.” Idealism prioritizes ideals, social reforms and morals, by wanting to benefit not just yourself, but the world around you, believing people are generally good. On the contrary, realism gives priority to national interest and security with emphasis on promoting one’s own power and influence by assuming that people are egocentric by nature. Based on the definitions stated above, idealism and realism are significantly different from each other and their divergence of thought is more apparent when various proponents of each such as Woodrow Wilson, Henry Lodge, Barack Obama and George W....   [tags: Political Science]

Strong Essays
1783 words (5.1 pages)

Hypocritical Christianity Exposed in Bernard Shaw's Major Barbara Essay

- Hypocritical Christianity Exposed in Bernard Shaw's Major Barbara Bernard Shaw reveals in his plays a type of religious standard that is not unlike Christianity but with what most people see as a stereotypical view of hypocritical Christianity. Shaw's concept of Crosstianity , as he calls it, shows a religion in which the church preaches what the rich and powerful tell it, scoundrels are treated as equals, and punishment is concerned with prosecution rather than salvation. "Poetic justice" rules judicial retribution rather than redemption....   [tags: Bernard Shaw Major Barbara Essays]

Strong Essays
618 words (1.8 pages)

Idealism and Realism in International Relations Essay

- In regards to the recent events in Ukraine, international relations (IR) have become a popular topic among people again. However, not many truly understand what the term ‘international relations’ entails. Unlike what we usually see in TV dramas, it is more than just people sending representatives to different countries to visit or negotiation about debatable agreements. International relation, sometimes known as ‘world politics’, began after the First World War. This field of academic study concentrates on the, as its name suggests, the politics on the global level with states as the units, relations between states, and maintaining peace in the international system....   [tags: league of nations, ukraine, world politics]

Strong Essays
1314 words (3.8 pages)

We Saved The World : The Debate And Tension Between Wilsonian Idealism And Realism

- “We Saved The World” WWI can help explain the debate and tension between Wilsonian idealism and realism. This tension takes place when America rose to power and influence during WWI, as the U.S. transitioned from unilaterism to internationalism. Also, each theory tries to reshape America’s national interest differently. Wilsonian idealism says U.S. national interest should be based on values like democracy, self-determination, human rights, and freedom. As a result, Wilson argues that America needs to be more engaged in internationalism....   [tags: World War II, League of Nations, World War I]

Strong Essays
1101 words (3.1 pages)

Realism and Idealism for the Godfather Essay

- Realism and Idealism for the Godfather I will never forget what I felt when I first seen my first mobster movie, I was about 12 years old, it was real late at night and I just could not fall asleep. I was flipping the channels looking for something to watch, and that is when I encountered my first mobster movie. I was intrigued from beginning to end; it was like nothing I had ever seen before. The way they talked so confident and cool to the way they looked so sharp and sophisticated. Although they were ruthless criminals, they had certain respectability towards them that no body could deny....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
1158 words (3.3 pages)

Understanding Realism Essay

- Realism has a long history of being debated and is often referred to as part of the 'first great debate” within international politics. Realism is seen as a direct response to idealism and is also heavily criticised for being overly simplistic and somewhat irrelevant to modern world politics. However, like all theories of world politics, Realism is and can be used to explain current issues within international relations and does have valid points to make about such issues in modern society. This essay will explore the key assumptions of Realism (statism, security and self-help)and put them into context of wider world politics examples to assess whether Realist values are suited to analyse c...   [tags: international politics, idealism, globalization]

Strong Essays
1311 words (3.7 pages)

Educational Philosophies: Idealism, Realism, Pragmatism, and Existentialism

- Educational philosophy is no doubt a matter that has changed over the decades, and still today not everyone is in total agreement on the subject. However, one thing is certain philosophy is the foundation of educational styles. Today, four basic educational philosophies exist including idealism, realism, pragmatism, and existentialism. All four philosophies are very different, but all strive for the same goal, to better our education system. Although every teacher has a different style of teaching that can be considered their own, they all adhere to one of the four basic philosophies....   [tags: Philosophy on Education Statement Teaching]

Strong Essays
466 words (1.3 pages)

Symbolism in Bernard Malamud's The Natural Essay

- Symbolism in Bernard Malamud's The Natural    The role of symbolism in Bernard Malamud's The Natural is important in helping the reader understand the theme and meaning of the novel as well as the time period in which it took place.  Malamud¡¦s use of symbolism defines the character of Roy Hobbs and shows how the events occurring around him affected his decisions and, eventually, his career.    Symbolism in The Natural takes the form of characters, such as women who strongly influenced Roy; historical events, such as the infamous 1919 World Series scandal; and even Greek and Roman mythology.  All forms of symbolism used by Malamud are woven into the life and career of Roy Hobbs....   [tags: Bernard Malamud The Natural Essays]

Strong Essays
2419 words (6.9 pages)

Berkeley's Idealism Essay

- Berkeley's Idealism In this essay I shall give the historical background to Berkeley's Idealism and then offer an argument for Idealism and suggest how an idealist could defend his theory against common objections and criticisms. Bishop George Berkeley's Idealism or Immaterialism is the theory that the physical world exists only in the experiences minds have of it. Berkeley's Idealism restricts minds to God, human beings, animals and whatever other spirits there may commonly thought to be, and says that everything else — the intrinsically non-mental — exists only as features of the experience of these minds....   [tags: Philosophy Philosophical Papers]

Strong Essays
1987 words (5.7 pages)