Is the romantic impulse towards rebellion driven by natural human instinct? Perhaps science should study this question a bit more in depth and share its findings with the major governments of the world because it appears as though the impulse towards rebellion is inherent to situations in which the freedoms of the individual are sacrificed to the good of the collective. If indeed rebellion is instinctual, does that mean that the individual is the highest order in natural law and therefore must cast off the oppression of artificial constraints? Throughout history democratic and socialist governments have unflinchingly managed to put the purported ‘good of the group’ in opposition with the rights of individuals; but are the two really in opposition to one another? Is their opposition a natural state, or an artificial one created by those in power? Until these questions are examined and answered rebellion will continue to erupt whenever conditions restrain the growth of the individual. Although the United States was founded upon rebellion, it appears as though that romantic impulse has been successfully crushed by a more realistic acceptance of subjugation in the 21st century. By comparing and contrasting the elements that contributed to rebellion during the age of the Transcendentalists – belief in the individual, recognition of government crimes against the individual, and conditions favorable for reform – with these elements as they exist today, it may be possible to pinpoint why there is no revolution in 21st century America.
Perhaps the single most important factor in the formation of government is whether the creators possess a ...
... middle of paper ...
.... Shorter 6th ed. NY: Norton, 2003, 527-538.
Emerson, Ralph Waldo. “The American Scholar.” The Norton Anthology of American Literature. Nina Baym ed. Shorter 6th ed. NY: Norton, 2003, 514-526.
“Minarchism.” Wikipedia: The Free Encyclopedia. 2003.
Moore, Micheal. “A Michael Moore.com guide to the USA Patriot Act.” 19 November 2003. www.michaelmoore.com
“Robert Nozick.” The Public Philosopher. www.geocities.com
Thoreau, Henry David. “Resistance to Civil Government.” The Norton Anthology of American Literature. Nina Baym ed. Shorter 6th ed. NY: Norton, 2003, 837-852.
Vidal, Gore. “The Erosion of the American Dream: Interview with Gore Vidal.” Dateline, SBS TV, Australia. 12 March 2003. www.ratical.org/ratville
Weinstein, James. The Long Detour: The History and Future of the American Left. Boulder: Westview Books, 2003.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- There have been countless religious rebellions throughout history, but none quite like that of Transcendentalism. At the time of the movement’s birth, newly acquired religious freedom in the United States allowed for new ideas and beliefs to blossom freely. Ideas and beliefs that the public and government previously greeted with bitter rejection. At the heart of Transcendentalism lied its most famous ambassadors, Ralph Waldo Emerson and his apprentice, Henry David Thoreau. Although Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau shared similar views and beliefs relating to Transcendentalism, the approach each author took in writing and making the ideas that were so important concrete was not alw... [tags: rebellion, religion, belief, Thoreau, Emerson]
1401 words (4 pages)
- In the 1830s the Transcendental movement sprouted. Through the movement founded by Ralph Waldo Emerson, the idea emerged that there is an inherent goodness in all of us. We learned that just because everyone else has a certain philosophy, it does not mean you are required to think that way. Transcendentalism revolved around the themes of religion, politics, the environment and intuition. Even though the transcendental movement ended more than a century and a half ago, its ideals thrive within modern day society.... [tags: Ralph Waldo Emerson, transcendentalism]
1545 words (4.4 pages)
- According to the New York Times, teenagers listen to an average of 2.5 hours of music in a singular day. The messages coming through in each song may vary between drug/alcohol reference or transcendentalism. No matter where there is music, there is a lesson to be learned through ideas that Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau created. Though transcendentalism is a relatively foreign word to most, it can be defined by using five i's: individualism, inspiration, intuition, idealism and imagination which are displayed on all platforms of music today.... [tags: Transcendentalist Essays]
1176 words (3.4 pages)
- First Nations The significant societal, economical, and political changes of the First Nations tend to be overlapping and correlational. As political maintenance declines the economy declines, and as the economy declines society crumbles and quality of life declines. While issues in one area cause issues in others it becomes hard to separate what can be solved politically vs. societally. All issues, either with society or politics, cause damage to the First Nations economic situation creating gaping issues with society such as health issues, famine, sheltering, and education.... [tags: rebellion, poundmaker, first nations]
861 words (2.5 pages)
- Nathaniel Bacon and William Berkley, the governor of Pennsylvania had many differences that stopped them from getting along one of them was their opinion on the Indians in Pennsylvania. Bacon started the rebellion because Berkley did things with out consulting Bacon, which undermined his military authority. It caused King Charles II to send 1,100 troops to Virginia and appoint a commission to determine its causes. The British rule had to get involved and put it in stricter rules, which made it harder for people to get power.... [tags: turning points in US history]
2588 words (7.4 pages)
- With American Indians randomly attacking the colonies, grave economic problems, corruption in the government, a desire for a representative government, and no help from Great Britain, the American colonies were on the brink of rebellion. All that was left to ignite the rebellion was a leader and a spark. Both of these came in the years to follow 1675. There were great economic problems in the colonies at the time. For one thing, the prices of tobacco, the major economic base of the colonies, were falling fast.... [tags: Essays on American Revolution]
704 words (2 pages)
- Followers of the Transcendentalist movement stressed the religious, philosophical and ideological importance of life. Henry David Thoreau was a staunch supporter of the movement. Thoreau felt that a person lived a good life by following his conscience and instincts. He also felt that materialism was a sure way to distract a person from leading a good and moral life. Thoreau proposed for the government to be involved in as little of a citizen's life as possible; he felt too much government control just complicated a person's life.... [tags: Civil Disobedience, Transcendentalist Movement]
771 words (2.2 pages)
- The New England Renaissance brought out two distinct, yet influential movements known as transcendentalism and anti-transcendentalism. The two concentrated on intuition and human nature and formed a revolt against previously accepted ideas such as Calvinist orthodoxy, strict Puritan attitudes, ritualism, and the dogmatic theology of religious institutions. Transcendentalism is a term rooted back to Plato, a Greek philosopher who first affirmed the existence of absolute goodness, which he characterized as beyond something of description and as knowable only through intuition.... [tags: Transcendentalism Essays]
1021 words (2.9 pages)
- Transcendentalism Many people have theories and philosophies about life in general. There have been hundreds of thousands of books published by many different people on the ideas of people in the past and the present. Transcendentalism falls in amongst all of these ideas. There have been articles, essays, poems, and even books written about this subject. Transcendentalism has effected many people since the philosophy was first introduced. The idea was complex and hard to grasp for many commoners and therefore it was understood by few people, and some would think that the idea was not understood at all and that was part of the idea.... [tags: essays research papers fc]
1611 words (4.6 pages)
- Transcendentalism Transcendentalism was a movement in philosophy, literature, and religion that emerged and was popular in the nineteenth century New England because of a need to redefine man and his place in the world in response to a new and changing society. The industrial revolution, universities, westward expansion, urbanization and immigration all made the life in a city like Boston full of novelty and turbulence. Transcendentalism was a reaction to an impoverishment of religion and mechanization of consciousness of eighteenth century rational doctrines that ceased to be satisfying.... [tags: American America History]
3303 words (9.4 pages)