Essay on Observations on the Writing Profession in The Republic by Plato

Essay on Observations on the Writing Profession in The Republic by Plato

Length: 1406 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Questioning of the Writing Profession Plato’s The Republic


For all the time today’s students spend learning to write well, Plato is skeptical of those who spend their lives crafting words. In the tenth chapter of The Republic, Socrates condemns poets as imitators. In the dialogue that bears his name, Phaedrus wonders whether words in the constructed rhythms of speech or poetry will obscure Truth, the philosopher’s ultimate goal. Speech-writing is just the clever use of rhetorical device, poetry is faulty imitation, and both empty voices can deceive us. Eventually, though, Socrates admits that the work of words deserves our effort. Because he is a writer himself, Plato’s criticism of the writing profession rings hollow: "It’s not speaking or writing well that’s shameful; what’s really shameful is to engage in either of them . . . badly," says Socrates (Republic 69A).1 Writing never ceases to be an imitation. Bad writing and speeches always threaten philosophy. Yet Plato’s own work reflects the constant questioning of philosophical dialogue. It passes Socrates’s test for good writing.

When he refers to writing, Socrates means speech writing. Philosophers judge the written against the spoken—what Phaedrus calls the "living, breathing discourse" (276A). For the philosopher, the spoken word is superior to the written one. Composition takes on meaning when an audience hears it; even Homer’s merits as a poet come from the speeches his characters give. Socrates asks: "Have you only heard of the rhetorical treatises of Nestor and Odysseus—those they wrote in their spare time in Troy?" (261B). Good writing is a tool for talk; The Iliad is better heard than read. Socrates has no use for silence. Writing is meant to be read, a...


... middle of paper ...


... philosophical conversation. But by his very existence as a writer, and by the form his writing takes, Plato satisfies the doubt, perhaps his own, that writing’s risks are worth it. His written words are careful in their sound and sense, but they keep in mind the eternal search for truth. Plato’s dialogues clarify only by confounding; his work preserves, but does not simplify. In its echoing, spontaneous polyphony, dialogue achieves all the truth that writing ever can. We are readers but hear their voices in our heads.



Works Cited

1) Plato, The Republic, trans. Allan Bloom (New York: HaperCollins Publishers, 1968).

2) Elizabeth Barrett Browning, Sonnets from the Portuguese: Illuminated by the Brownings’ Love Letters (NewJersey: Ecco Press, 1996).

3) William Strunk Jr. and E.B. White, The Elements of Style, fourth ed. (London: Allyn and Bacon, 2000).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Plato's Explanation of an Ideal State in his Work, The Republic Essay

- What is the ideal state. This question has sparked debate since the very formation of organized political society. In Plato’s The Republic, Plato seeks to define justice and in doing so he seeks to explain the ideal just state. In Plato’s explanation of an ideal state, there is an extreme emphasis on unity and harmony. The reason unity and harmony are so important to Plato are because they are responsible for bonding together Plato’s ideal state and protecting it from tyranny. Plato explains at great length the framework which ties together the individual soul with the ideal political society....   [tags: The Republic]

Powerful Essays
1874 words (5.4 pages)

Plato's Ideas About Philosopher Kings Depicted in Republic Essay

- In Plato's most famous work 'Republic' he puts forward the view that only the study of philosophy would allow man to see what was good and just. Therefore to cure the ill's of society it would be necessary to either make kings philosophers or make philosophers kings. I intend to show how Plato justifies this view and then attempt to point out some possible problems with this justification and to forward my own view that 'the people' should ultimately be king. Plato's starting point was his recognition that justice was one of four cardinal virtues, along with wisdom, courage and moderation, that when working harmoniously together in a high level of order - he felt equalled the elusive 'good l...   [tags: Republic]

Powerful Essays
1710 words (4.9 pages)

De-regulate the Medical Profession Essay

- De-regulate the medical profession. The government has to many regulations on who can do what in medicine. Someone who is a 3rd year medical student can perform surgery and medical task and a nurse with 30 years of experience can’t. We live in a county with more than 300 million people and only have 600,000 doctors, that’s 500 patients for every doctor. There are many potential students who can make it through medical school but cannot afford it, or a family crisis. Over 95% of forms are rejected and its true we want the most proficient team of medical students but in a health care crisis like we have we have to take our chances....   [tags: medical profession, ]

Powerful Essays
729 words (2.1 pages)

U.S. Army: A Profession of Arms Essays

- The impact of the War on Terrorism on our military is profound. Over the past decade the Army has rapidly expanded, lowered its entry standards, and reprioritized its training objectives. Now as the wars now diminish, the Army again faces change due to budget cuts and troop reduction. Such actions have forced critics to question whether the Army is still meeting the expectations of a profession. The answer is that the Army is holding true to the title of a “Profession of Arms” like never before....   [tags: profession, budget, reduction, standards]

Powerful Essays
812 words (2.3 pages)

My Career Goals in Nursing Profession Essay examples

- Profession of Nursing is always regards as a complex, dynamic and noble. The nursing profession requires many things such as hard work, a vast knowledge, excellent communication skills, and a passion for the noble profession. All these qualities are needed to be an effective nurse. Today, nurses are living in a world of ever changing field of medicine .The present patient statistics poses, nurses are expected to take responsibility of accomplishing the requirements. The requirement for excellent nursing skills is added as well as well-formed skills in different aspect....   [tags: Nursing Profession]

Free Essays
722 words (2.1 pages)

Observations at the Park Essay

- Observations at the Park A cigarette butt lies next to my foot, still emitting a trace of smoke. Nearby on the dusty asphalt a pigeon waddles self-consciously, bobbing its head as if pecking the air for some invisible food. A squirrel churrs a threat to his brother, challenging him to romp. The walkway before me never becomes silent. A buzz of voices blends with the city soundscape of cars driving and trucks backing, swingsets squealing and sparrows chirping. A toddler, holding tightly to his sister's stroller, yells "Achtung....   [tags: Observation Essay, Descriptive Essay]

Powerful Essays
527 words (1.5 pages)

Justice In Plato's The Republic Essay

- Justice In Plato's The Republic Ralph Waldo Emerson once wrote “One man’s justice is another’s injustice.” This statement quite adequately describes the relation between definitions of justice presented by Polemarchus and Thrasymachus in Book I of the Republic. Polemarchus initially asserts that justice is “to give to each what is owed” (Republic 331d), a definition he picked up from Simonides. Then, through the unrelenting questioning of Socrates, Polemarchus’ definition evolves into “doing good to friends and harm to enemies” (Republic 332d), but this definition proves insufficient to Socrates also....   [tags: Plato Republic Justice Philosophy Essays]

Powerful Essays
999 words (2.9 pages)

The Importance of Thrasymachus in Plato’s Republic Essays

- The Importance of Thrasymachus in Plato’s Republic      Dr. Malters’s comments: This student does two things quite remarkable for an undergraduate student. In his compact essay, not only does he display an in-depth understanding of complex perspectives on justice put forth by the protagonist Socrates, he deftly explains how Plato has artfully made rude objections by a seemingly minor character early in the dialogue function as a structuring device for nearly all the important ideas examined thereafter....   [tags: Plato Republic Essays]

Powerful Essays
932 words (2.7 pages)

Observations Of Life Essay

- INTRODUCTION I am not a psychologist by far, I have no degree in the field of psychology nor do I wish to have, I am just an everyday person that observes and analyzes the things I see. As I am writing this I am at the ripe old age of 18. To some people this may imply that I do not have any credibility in writing these things because I do not have the wisdom of age. Well, to those people I say that they should hear me out on these perceptions and continue reading, because you can not judge someone else unless you have heard their side of the story....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
2830 words (8.1 pages)

Light Observations Essay

- Light Observations Made on 2-17-05 From the hours of 1800 to 2200 on Thursday 2-17-05, an inspection of the lights found on the exterior of the warehouses, container lots, pipe yard, and dock took place. After searching all the light fixtures on the outside of the warehouses there were only two found that possibly could cause a hazard to someone. The first one found was at bay door 1A-1, the fixture was hanging loose off the wall with wires exposed. 2B-2 was the other site with a possible hazard....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1095 words (3.1 pages)