Marginality and Othering in Metalious’ Peyton Place Essay

Marginality and Othering in Metalious’ Peyton Place Essay

Length: 2721 words (7.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Research Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

Marginality and Othering in Metalious’Peyton Place


Metalious’ best known novel, Peyton Place, was a bestseller and a media phenomenon in the mid-1950s and 1960s, creating a stir because of its depictions of teenage sexuality, incest, and illegal abortion. Surprisingly, however, few close examinations of the novel’s content and style have been published by literary critics. This essay provides a discussion of a key concern in the novel: racial, ethnic, geographical, and sexual marginality. Written to challenge the inscription of white, middle class, nuclear family life as the standard by which difference should be measured, Peyton Place features several characters who inhabit the metaphorical margins of American society, including Samuel Peyton, an escaped slave and the founder of the town; Tomoas Makris, a mysteriously handsome Greek school principal with several resemblances to George Metalious; and Selena Cross, a dark-skinned, beautiful young woman describes as a “gypsy,” whose life ties in to the incest and abortion subplots within the novel. I will provide a working definition of marginality and “othering” to begin this essay, followed by a discussion of Metalious’ social status as a French Canadian in New Hampshire, a description of the characterizations of Samuel Peyton and Selena Cross, and a final word on realism, reception, and the novel’s legacy.

Marginality and “othering” are terms that have a long history in literary and critical discourse of the 20th century. In cultural criticism of the last three decades, these terms have been used to describe differences in power among individuals, nations, and cultural forms. In Orientalism, for instance, Edward Said invokes this idea of marg...


... middle of paper ...


...ched understanding of the novel’s legacy. The unique and provocative treatments of marginality and othering in Peyton Place illustrate conflicts and anxieties that remain unresolved in 21st century American culture.


Works Cited

Mussell, Kay. Fantasy and Reconciliation: Contemporary Formulas of Women’s Romance Fiction. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1984.

Said, Edward. Orientalism. New York: Vintage Books, 1979.

Sorrell, Richard S. “A Novelist and Her Ethnicity: Grace Metalious as a Franco-American,” Historical New Hampshire, Fall 1980: 284-327.

Stearns, Jane and Michael Stearns. “Peyton Place.” Encyclopedia of Popular Culture. New York: Harper, 1992: 381-383.

Toth, Emily. Inside Peyton Place: The Life of Grace Metalious. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 2001.

“Unpopular Best Seller.” Life, November 12, 1956: 104.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Grace Metalious' Peyton Place

- Grace Metalious' Peyton Place Unlike many other romance novels, Grace Metalious’ Peyton Place has aroused a plethora of academic debates ranging from the aggressive promotion of the author’s image to the themes contained within the actual narrative. Arguably the most interesting, yet elusive, theories on Peyton Place are centered on how the novel fits into the social fabric of postwar America. Many average readers, as well as literary experts, are prone to identify elements in Metalious’ novel which suggest that this cross-dressing housewife was out to subvert dominant 1950s ideology, while others will argue that the book can do nothing else but support the dominant patriarchal structure u...   [tags: Grace Metalious Peyton Place essays]

Research Papers
2069 words (5.9 pages)

Marginality by Jung Young Essay

- Marginality By: Jung Young Lee is one of the most profound books I have read. Every page draws more insights into the lens of those marginalized by society. Lee is able to take a word that has been used as a one-dimensional, negative term for articulating a people group and not only make it three-dimensional but establish a positive marginality for all. Based on the author’s first hand experiences of living on the margin, he invites the reader to learn through a personal journey of the margins....   [tags: book revies and report]

Research Papers
1638 words (4.7 pages)

Peyton Manning vs Tom Brady Essay

- “Peyton Manning and Tom Brady are the preeminent QBs of their generation (Battista and Breer).” Two quarterbacks, from two completely different backgrounds, are fighting for supremacy among all the men to quarterback in the National Football League (NFL). Football in the day and age today is a landscape unlike a few centuries ago. On paper just about any coach in the NFL would start Peyton Manning, former first pick in the 1998 draft, over Tom Brady, former one hundred and ninety ninth pick in the 2000 draft, just based on where each player was selected....   [tags: quaterback, NFL, football, athlete, draft]

Research Papers
1874 words (5.4 pages)

Hip Hop Culture Has Articulated Black Marginality Essay

- Mike Martini Professor Busch AMS 205 December 6, 2015 Hip hop culture has articulated black marginality in many ways since artists like Grandmaster Flash helped pioneer hip hop. Even though the culture was new and focused on life in the city, it still stayed consistent with keeping African American traditions including variety of Afro-Caribbean and Afro-American musical practices and dance forms. The local streets on which people lived, turned into the face for hip hop. With the help of music videos, rap artists showed what life was like in their place of urban decline....   [tags: Hip hop music, African American, Hip hop, Funk]

Research Papers
920 words (2.6 pages)

My Favorite Place Essay

- My favorite place as a child was County Park Lake. When we had family picnics because we all got together and there was great food and kids playing and the adults playing horse-shoes and could tell there was love for one another. There was no other place like this when I was a child. Some of my fondest memories was at that picnic site we should all have memories likes those. The entire family got together and it was always a last minute thing but no matter what was going on we all decide we would go up to County Park Lake to have family time....   [tags: Place Essay]

Research Papers
722 words (2.1 pages)

Developmental Psychology: The Case of Peyton Essay

- Childhood A representation of Peyton’s behavior and thinking that is associated with the ordinary American gender performance, in regard to socialization was demonstrated in Peyton’s adamant attitude towards women occupations careers, such as being a police officer or firefighter. Peyton’s friends have exposed her to their personal perceptions of gender roles, affirming that the boys should not engage in activities consisting of dress up or dolls with the girls. Peyton’s attitude is fixed, due to the gender-stereo values and behaviors demonstrated by her peers and community....   [tags: childhood, adolescence, child-rearing styles]

Research Papers
1674 words (4.8 pages)

The Language Analysis On Peyton Essay

- I completed the language analysis on Peyton, an exceptionally social, intelligent, and energetic, 42-month-old girl. She was cheerful and carefree the day I visited her house, which meant she was especially talkative. Peyton lives with her mother, father, and younger brother Benjamin, who just turned 6 months old. She typically stays at home with her mother during the week, but is enrolled and attends a daycare part time. She also spends a great deal of time with her nannies so that mom can run extra errands when she needs to....   [tags: Language, Word, Word game, Linguistics]

Research Papers
1347 words (3.8 pages)

Sharing My Place Essay

- ….......................................................Sharing My Place........................................................... Stopwatch countdown beeps like a bomb. Final scribbles accelerate in time to the eerie ding, ding, ding. Time’s up. Tossing aside the pen, I stand and stumble, landing behind a podium. Gulp. Then… syllables trickle and burst, berating air, shimmying up off note cards into the audience. Sounds shape shift into creatures creating cadence. I’m doing it. I feel like Daniel Webster reincarnated, but waddling in high heels and stuffed into a black suit, I look like a penguin....   [tags: place, podium, speak]

Research Papers
579 words (1.7 pages)

Essay on The Marginality of Women in the Media

- Historically, women have been marginalized and underrepresented in many areas of the mass media, most predominately advertising. Billions of dollars annually are allocated for businesses in marketing schemes and advertising. They include subliminal messages, which most likely are geared directly at a particular gender. With society becoming more aware of the influence of the mass media, and exposure increasing, inaccurate views of gender continue to twist reality by altering viewer perception. These gender stereotypes, both visible and invisible, need to halt the casting of women in traditional and inferior roles, and begin placing them in equal roles comparable to that of their male counte...   [tags: Sociology]

Research Papers
866 words (2.5 pages)

Place Management Essay

- Place Management Place management is the process of making places better. This is practiced through programmes to improve a location or to maintain an already attained desired standard of operation. Place management can be undertaken by private, public or voluntary organisations or a mixture of each. Despite the wide variety of place management initiatives the underlying common factor is usually a desire to maximise the effectiveness of a location for its users, whether they are residents, shoppers, tourists, investors, property developers or business owners....   [tags: Place Management]

Free Essays
1656 words (4.7 pages)