Reader-Response Criticism of James Joyce’s Eveline from Dubliners Essay

Reader-Response Criticism of James Joyce’s Eveline from Dubliners Essay

Length: 2400 words (6.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A Subjective Reader-Response Criticism of James Joyce’s Eveline


The subjectivity evident in literary interpretation is hard to deny. Though one

person may feel that James Joyce’s writing proves Joyce’s support of the feminist

movement, another may believe that Joyce views women as inferior. What could account

for such a difference in opinions? Schwarz explains that subjective reader-response

critics would respond to a question such as this by answering that each reader uses the

literary work to symbolize his or her own life and, therefore, each response is unique to

the individual reader. He asserts that the reader will always find an identity theme in the

particular text he or she is reading. Consequently, the text must be looked at in terms of

the response it invokes in the reader, and what this response says about the reader’s own

psychological needs (129). Several of James Joyce’s works are ideal for subjective

reader-response analysis and, in particular, the story “Eveline” from Dubliners.



The story “Eveline” concerns a love affair between Eveline and a sailor, Frank,

and Eveline’s indecision about whether or not to run away with Frank to Buenos Aires.

Throughout the short story, Joyce describes several images and actions that lead up to

Eveline’s eventual inability to leave with Frank. However, there are such a variety of

images and actions that it is difficult to emphasize the specific key images and actions

that lead readers to their ultimate understanding of the story. Due to the great number of

images and actions in “Eveline,” individual readers must designate their own important

aspects of the story in order to assert meaning. “Each person...


... middle of paper ...


...overcoming the paralysis of fear and obligation to take a

chance for a more satisfying way of life.



Works Cited

Bleich, David. Readings and Feelings: An Introduction to Subjective Criticism. Urbana:

National Council of Teachers of English, 1975.

Holland, Norman N. “The Question: Who Reads What How?” 5 Readers Reading.

1975.

Joyce, James. Dubliners. New York: Washington Square Press, 1998.

Schwarz, David R. “Reader-Response Criticism and ‘The Dead’ What Is Reader-

Response Criticism?” James Joyce The Dead: Complete, Authoritative Text with

Biographical and Historical Contexts, Critical History, and Essays from Five

Contemporary Critical Perspectives. Ed. David R. Schwarz. Boston: Bedford

Books of St. Martin’s Press, 1994.

Werner, Craig Hansen. Dubliners: A Pluralistic World. Boston: Twayne Publishers,

1988.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

James Joyce's Dubliners - Anger and Misery in Counterparts Essay example

- Dubliners - Anger and Misery in Counterparts If one story in Dubliners can be singled out for its overly disturbing qualities, then "Counterparts" would be it. In this story the reader witnesses the misery that people in Dublin pass on to each other and through generations. Joyce introduces us to a character that at first is mildly amusing. Farrington is a working-class man that, like so many others, has to put up with verbal abuse from his boss. At first it is comical to watch him outline his speech he will give to his friends about how he wittily insulted his boss....   [tags: Dubliners Essays]

Powerful Essays
955 words (2.7 pages)

Reader Response to James Joyce's The Dead Essay

- Reader Response to Joyce's The Dead     James Joyce's story "The Dead" has a tremendous impact on the readers, especially those who are familiar with the political situation in Ireland at the time about which the Joyce wrote the final story in Dubliners.  In exploring the meaning of James Joyce's long short-story, "The Dead", there are many critical approaches to take.  Each approach gives readers a lens, a set of guidelines through which to examine and express ideas of the meaning of "The Dead."  Joyce himself said that the idea of paralysis was the intended theme of all the stories in The Dubliners of which "The Dead" is the final story....   [tags: Joyce Dead Essays]

Powerful Essays
1068 words (3.1 pages)

James Joyce’s Dubliners Essay

- In James Joyce’s 1914 Dubliners, many adult characters drink to revel in the temporary distraction it brings from the day-to-day monotony. Following the three initial stories exploring childhood in Dublin, the remaining twelve adult-centered stories all allude to or explicitly reference drinking or drunkenness. However, there is a comparative difference in the depth of mention between male and female drinkers in the novel. Only two women – Mr. Cunnigham’s wife in Grace and Mrs. Sinico in A Painful Case – are described in passing as succumbing to this vice, whereas there are ten detailed accounts of male drinkers – such as Farrington in Counterparts – where the entirety of the short story is...   [tags: Monotonous Consumption, Gendered Alcoholism]

Powerful Essays
1261 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Obscenities and Blasphemy in Dead and Dubliners by James Joyce

- The Impression of Gabriel in The Dead If there has ever been an author in history that can get away with writing about bodily functions and sexual desires, it is Mr. James Joyce. His works have not only seen the ugly side of criticism but have even been placed under trial. His novella “Dubliners” was banned due to accusations of obscenities and blasphemy. Yet, many critics and writers, including Ezra Pound, saw Joyce’s work as avant-garde and evolutionary. Despite the many obstacles Joyce endured, his works were published and proposed a different design to literary art....   [tags: impressionism, sexual desires, criticism]

Powerful Essays
1350 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on James Joyce's Araby - Character, Structure and Style in Araby

- Character, Structure and Style in Araby         According to Hazel Edwards, “A good story writer needs to be a craftsman, for the construction is tighter than that required for most novels. Usually a short story concentrates on a few characters- rarely more than three major ones. The story revolves around a single, dramatic incident which typifies the characters’ reactions. Length varies from 1,000 to about 5,000 words.” With these characteristics in mind, then we are going to examine James Joyce’s short story Araby  in terms of depiction of character, the story structure and the style....   [tags: Joyce Dubliners Araby Essays]

Powerful Essays
2408 words (6.9 pages)

Dubliners ' Dubliners By James Joyce Essay

- Corina Waters Dubliners “Dubliners” is a collection of fifteen short stories written by author James Joyce. These short stories reflect on his feelings associated with the city of Dublin, where he grew up in a large impoverished family. After he graduated from the University College in Dublin, Joyce went to live abroad in Paris. Joyce finished writing “Dubliners” in 1905, just a year after moving to Paris, though he had trouble getting the collection of short stories published so it wasn’t officially published until 1914....   [tags: Dubliners, Dublin, James Joyce, Ulysses]

Powerful Essays
1617 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on Dubliners By James Joyce 's Dubliners

- James Joyce uses his novel Dubliners to reveal how fathers are in Dublin during 1904. Joyce utilizes his stories within Dubliners, such as “Eveline” and “Counterparts,” to describe the cruelty fathers were during the early 1900s. Within “Eveline” Eveline Hill is trapped within her home dealing with her abusive father and trying to escape the reality with her lover. However, she remembers her mother’s promise of maintaining the household. Her father is a prime example of Joyce’s representation of fathers within the 1900s....   [tags: Dubliners, James Joyce, Family, Ulysses]

Powerful Essays
725 words (2.1 pages)

An Analysis Of James Joyce 's Dubliners Essay examples

- James Joyce published Dubliners to demonstrate the everyday struggles and the unattractive human behaviors that were occurring among the people in his own hometown. Paralysis, alcoholism and death are three major themes found in Dubliner’s that paint an unsettling picture of Dublin, Ireland during the early twentieth century for its readers. James Joyce portrays his characters within these stories as incapable and crippled in one-way or another. He does this by exploiting the act of drinking to prove that alcoholism leads to personal downfalls, which is a repeating theme found in many of the stories....   [tags: Dubliners, Dublin, James Joyce, Alcoholism]

Powerful Essays
1194 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about James Joyce's Dubliners: Two Gallants

-   In "Two Gallants," the sixth short story in the Dubliners collection, James Joyce is especially careful and crafty in his opening paragraph. Even the most cursory of readings exposes repetition, alliteration, and a clear structure within just these nine lines. The question remains, though, as to what the beginning of "Two Gallants" contributes to the meaning and impact of Joyce's work, both for the isolated story itself and for Dubliners as a whole. The construction, style, and word choice of this opening, in the context of the story and the collection, all point to one of Joyce's most prevalent implicit judgments: that the people of Ireland refuse to make any effort toward positive cha...   [tags: James Joyce Dubliners]

Powerful Essays
2399 words (6.9 pages)

Personal Paralysis in Dubliners by James Joyce Essay

- Personal Paralysis in Dubliners by James Joyce Imagine being paralyzed; unable to move freely. Most people when they think of paralization, it is connected to the physical. However, paralysis takes on more than one meaning and goes way beyond physicality. There are three definitions from Webster online: 1. Complete or partial loss of function especially when involving the motion or sensation in a part of the body 2. Loss of the ability to move 3. A state of powerlessness or incapacity to act The first and second definitions are primarily about physical paralysis, however in the first one, “loss of function,” could be any kind of function....   [tags: Dubliners James Joyce Paralysis Essays]

Powerful Essays
1842 words (5.3 pages)