It has been said that the mind is the theatre of conflict. But what happens when perceptions clash and heads butt? In the play M. Butterfly, by David Henry Hwang, he uses the title as his primary metaphor, but he convolutes the play by having too many themes working around it which can distort the reaction of the audience. The tenor is the butterfly and the vehicle is the M, now the problem with this is that the tenor and the vehicle imply too many things, making it far too abstract to make a clear description of reality. The interaction between the vehicle and the tenor yields nothing except confusion to an audience that is simply stimulated by the superficial layers of the play.
Looking at the metaphor M. Butterfly, one is able to extract a vast spectrum of ideas which Hwang suggests, for example: East vs. West, man vs. woman, sexuality, power relations, race, gender, class, stereotypes, fantasy… etcetera. Now, from a mathematical point of view the metaphor has many variables in the equation, making the problem much more difficult to solve. In other words, Hwang's butterfly metaphor is too ambitious and the audience can have a head full of themes that don't seem to connect to each other. For example, a secondary metaphor which feeds into the butterfly metaphor is when Gallimard says; "I knew this little flower was waiting for me to call, and, as I wickedly refused to do so, I felt of the first time that rush of power-the absolute power of a man" (Hwang, 32). This example implies a power relationship as the tenor and the vehicle is Song, but the number of themes that this metaphor suggests is too many: Power relations, stereotypes, east vs. west, and man vs. woman, race...
... middle of paper ...
...Post…We all simply concluded that the gentleman was possibly insecure about his own sexual orientation and therefore found the play threatening" (97). Oh well, if that's the case than I'm in big trouble with Hwang.
So there you have it, not only did Hwang's metaphors fail to describe reality effectively to the audience, but the hubris of a Tony award winner has been illuminated by a part-time college misfit. However, the audience was most certainly stimulated by the most obvious sexual aspects of the play, but when looking at the metaphor as a whole the only thing one can do is go cross-eyed because the play is too potent with themes to make quality connections. It's safe to say that gravity works even on an "elevated" play such as M. Butterfly.
Kroll, Jack Newsweek. 6 Nov. 1988
Hwang, David H. M. Butterfly. New York: Penguin Books, 1989.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- David Henry Hwang's M Butterfly "I've played out the events of my life night after night, always searching for a new ending to my story, one where I will leave this cell and return forever to my Butterfly's arms." (Hwang 3.3.1-4) With these words of David Henry Hwang's play M Butterfly, we realize that we have just been staring directly into the memories of Rene Gallimard. The fact that Rene Gallimard serves as the narrator of his memories in the play M Butterfly delivers an impression of the character behind Gallimard than could ever be achieved by the viewing of the screenplay.... [tags: David Henry Hwang M Butterfly Essays]
1562 words (4.5 pages)
- David Henry Hwang's M. Butterfly The relationship between a man and a woman has been a constant struggle of inferiority since the beginning of time. The role of a woman has evolved from being someone not allowed to have an opinion, to the owner of a multi-million dollar company. Over the years women have developed the passion and skills in order to fight for what they believe in. However, in some countries women are still placed at the bottom of the societal list, and their constant battle of how their culture looks and feels about women in modern day society is hard to win.... [tags: Society Women Butterfly Analysis, misogyny, femini]
1479 words (4.2 pages)
- She is petite, submissive, and great in bed, the greatest combination for the perfect woman. Yellow fever is the psychological inclination towards Asian woman that has been expressed by a portion of the male population. This stereotype is a part of orientalism that continues to be discussed amongst today’s society; it is deemed odd or labeled as a fetish. M. Butterfly a Tony Award playwright written by David Henry Hwang consists of ideas related to orientalism through the layers developed in gender identity, global politics and art forms.... [tags: M. Butterfly Essays]
1288 words (3.7 pages)
- Fantasy Dependence in David Henry Hwang’s M. Butterfly M. Butterfly, as its title suggests, is the reworking of Puccini’s opera, Madama Butterfly. In Puccini’s opera, Lieutenant Pinkerton, a United Sates Navy officer, purchases the conjugal rights to Cio-Cio-San, a fifteen-yrear-old Japanese Geisha girl, for one hundred yen, and marries her with the convenient provision that each contract can be annulled on a monthly notice. Meanwhile, Pinkerton leaves Cio-Cio-San for the United States to marry an American girl, Kate.... [tags: Hwang M. Butterfly Essays]
3149 words (9 pages)
- ... The play M. Butterfly is inspired by Rene Giacomo Puccini’s opera Madama Butterfly. It based on an absurd but true story of Gallimard, a French diplomat who carries on a twenty-year affair with Song Liling, a beautiful Chinese diva, without realizing that his lover is in fact a male spy masquerading as a woman. In the play, Gallimard represents a masculine western imperialist, while Song as a submissive Oriental woman figure. What makes the play a marvelous piece is the complete role-reversal between Song and Gallimard at the end of the play.... [tags: asian, oriental women, stereotype]
797 words (2.3 pages)
- The Butterfly Diving Bell sits on my bedside table . It was a busy day when I finished and I'm struggling with how to express my appreciation for the best of the author , Jean - Dominique Bauby . As a beautiful French dessert , each crafted wonderful phrases should be savored. Posted by Bauby bears a sense of humor combined with depression that required for reading and slow digestion . He must have been a Morrissey fan . For those who are not familiar with Mr. Bauby , he was a former general editor of Elle magazine Parisian version .... [tags: The Diving Bell and the Butterfly]
995 words (2.8 pages)
- Feminism in M. Butterfly In the 1989 drama M. Butterfly, the masterwork of contemporary American playwright David Henry Hwang, the topic of sexual politics underlies all other themes, and creates a tension between the genders that pervades throughout the text; moreover, Hwang subverts traditional thematic aspects of sexual politics by questioning the most fundamental unit of sex by considering the very nature of gender and what defines a male or a female. These elements unite and develop a penetrating examination of feminism, and an inspection of the role of females in both Western and Eastern societies as they relate to males, and an exposé of the inequalities of gender which are prese... [tags: David Henry Hwang]
2714 words (7.8 pages)
- ... By this Liling is pointing out the gender difference’s between men and women during that time white women were considered more outgoing than Chinese women thus when galliard finds liling he thinks he has found a women of his fantasies a women h can have as a mistress but she will not tell his wife only be submissive to him. Rene Gillard fantasied of being a true man because they did not consider Chinese men, Real men or masculine during the scene when song and the judge are talking songs says “Her eyes say yes but her mouth says no, the west thinks of itself as masculine big guns big industry while the east is feminine weak delicate, and poor”.... [tags: affair, chinese women, french diplomat]
940 words (2.7 pages)
- At the end of the play M. Butterfly, a jailed French diplomat turned spy named Gallimard says, "There is a vision of the Orient that I have" (Hwang 3.3.7). In that moment he is implying that there are still beautiful women, as he thought his "Butterfly" was. This is suggestive of the colonial appeal. Colonization is made possible by one society characterizing another in a way that makes it seem like a good idea. The characterization of these cultures, such as the Orient or Africa, is carried out through literature, works of art, and drama.... [tags: Literary Analysis, David Henry Hwang]
1667 words (4.8 pages)
- Illusion in M. Butterfly In David Henry Hwang's play M. Butterfly we are introduced to Rene Gallimard who has unknowingly been sexually involved with another man for twenty years. The idea of mistaken gender within the play causes the reader to question how could one mistake his/her lover's gender for so long. In Rene Gallimard's search for self-identity he ignorantly chooses illusion over reality. Hwang effectively uses the opera Madame Butterfly by Giacomo Puccini as a framework to mold the main character, Rene Gallimard.... [tags: David Henry Hwang Gender Sexuality]
574 words (1.6 pages)
- Society's Role in Margery Kempe's Autobiography
- Comparing Heroes and Villains in Measure for Measure, Othello, and Hamlet
- Exploring Existentialism and the Character Leanord in the Film, Memento
- Marxist Perspective on Franz Kafka's The Metamorphosis
- An Analysis of Hawthorne’s My Kinsman, Major Molineux
- Jane Elton's Identity Conflict in Catherine Maria Sedgwick’s A New England Tale