Mixed Reviews of Hemingway's Men Without Women and Winners Take Nothing

Mixed Reviews of Hemingway's Men Without Women and Winners Take Nothing

Length: 1124 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Mixed Reviews of Hemingway's Men Without Women and Winners Take Nothing

Within a span of five years, Ernest Hemingway published two unique novels, Winners Take Nothing, and Men Without Women. Instead of following the customary novel structure, Hemingway incorporated many short stories into a book. Several short stories included were already published in various literature mediums, and quite successful. Fourteen stories composed Men Without Women, and ten poems with three stories formed Winners Take Nothing. Hemingway intended to use these books to establish his place and identity in American history, the one of a super-male writer.

Charles Scriber's Sons published 20,300 copies of Winners Take Nothing on October 27, 1933. (Oliver 355). They sold for two dollars each. (Oliver 355). This book met public outrage, as people became offended by Hemingway's choice of subjects. Hemingway covered topics such as homosexuality, insanity, suicide, nihilism, and veneral disease (Wagner-Martin 32). To understand the public's negative perspectives, attitudes and emotions on Winner Take Nothing, we must examine the historical context of Hemingway's time. America was in midst of the Great Depression. Many people were in direst situations, and barely clinging onto hope for better fortunes. Naturally, they wanted sources of hope, and Hemingway's book certainly does not offer hope or a sense of exit (Wagner-Martin 33). Additionally, Hemingway in Winners Take Nothing boldly tackles delicate moral issues that America regarded sensitively during that time period. As Michael Reynolds adeptly puts it, Winner Take Nothing was "abrasive to the prevailing American moral view of itself." (Wagner-Martin 32).

Because Hemingway failed to write a boo...

... middle of paper ...

...is life." (Pearsall 115). Oddly enough, Hemingway regarded negative reviews as an assault on his reputation, and as a ploy intended to ruin his career as a writer.

However, the negative reviews did nothing to impair Hemingway's place in history as a great writer. Hemingway still has a large following in modern society despite being dead for over forty years. His innovative ability with prose has people exclaiming about Hemingway as one of the greatest prose stylists ever. Winners Take Nothing and Men Without Women played a large role in that reputation.


Oliver, Charles M. Ernest Hemingway A to Z. New York: Checkmark Books, 1999.

Pearsall, Robert Brainard. The Life and Writings of Ernest Hemingway. Amsterdam: Rodopi, 1973.

Wagner-Martin, Linda. Ed. A Historical Guide to Ernest Hemingway. New York: Oxford University Press, 2000.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Report on Winner-Take-All Essay

- Report on Winner-Take-All "Winner-take-all” is a term used to describe single member district and at large election systems that award seats to the highest vote getters without ensuring fair representation for minority groups. In the United States, these are typically single-member district schemes or at-large, block-voting systems. Under winner-take-all rules, a slim majority of voters can control 100% of seats, leaving everyone else effectively without representation. There's something else troubling about the way we elect presidents--something beyond the personal attacks, the derelict voters and the influence of big money....   [tags: Winner-Take-All Elections Politics Essays]

Free Essays
695 words (2 pages)

Post Reviews Essay

- Great post. I definitely agree that the Soft&Tough manufacturer should market their new male skin care product to white collar men because these professionals are very image conscious and they want to present a youthful appearance to be competitive in their career (Anonymous, 2007). Also, professional men tend to spend more money on personal grooming products than blue-collar men (Anonymous, 2007). You make a great point that baby boomer men would be very attracted to the Soft&Tough skin care line because of the allure of products anti-aging and skin protecting components....   [tags: Marketing Reviews]

Strong Essays
546 words (1.6 pages)

A Gathering of Old Men, a Review Essay

- Racism in the South has always been a very real and horrible problem. Ernest Gaines accurately describes the atrocities that black Americans experienced in A Gathering of Old Men. "Gaines's strength lies in his quietly companionate depiction of the plantation Blacks in his native Louisiana...." (Peden 239). The whites in the novel are the representation of the stereotypical white person in the 1970s. Gaines shows every white point of view towards blacks in this novel through the progression of the most backward to the most forward thinkers....   [tags: Book Reviews]

Strong Essays
1383 words (4 pages)

Edgar Allan. Poe and H. L. Mencken’s Uses of Humor in Negative Reviews Essay

- ... Why write escapist ‘wastes-of-time’ that prove no quality or benefit to society, when you could write the next great Moby Dick or 1984. By using sarcasm to deliver his conclusion instead of just lambasting the novel, he makes it okay for the readers to laugh at it too, and wonder what the value was that we saw in it anyways. Though an effective tool in “Lachrymose Love,” Mencken’s positive review of Theodore Dreiser in his essay, “A Modern Tragedy,” lacks as much of a sense of humor. He demonstrates a similar viewpoint on what the import values are, praising the novel as “a criticism and an interpretation of life” (245), which does not try to outdo itself with fancy language and over-the...   [tags: writers, sarcasm, literary analysis, reviews]

Strong Essays
1119 words (3.2 pages)

Are Developing Countries"Winners" or "Losers" of Globalization? Essay

- The one thing that the world definitely needs to do is a better way of understanding globalization. Today, in the era of globalization, which concerns different aspects of life, such as politics, economics and society, it is hard to imagine the life without thousands of goods and services from all over the globe. There are hundreds of multinational corporations that are widespread all over the world, such as Mc Donald’s and Burger King, Coca Cola and Pepsi, Apple and Samsung, Nike and Adidas and others....   [tags: interantional relations, economics, politics]

Strong Essays
1899 words (5.4 pages)

Album Reviews Essay

- Album Reviews There is a time to be concise and a juncture to be descriptive. Technology allows downloads to be purchased track by track or the whole album if the user wishes. Music is a physical reaction and in turn whatever one experiences in their gut can be felt by a listener who the composer never meets. When you listen to new music with previously unheard titled tracks from your preferred artist you naturally want to hope for the best. Regrettably, even your favorite bands can sell out posing for cameras that will launch them onto a magazine cover instead of covering the content which previously propelled the ensemble to the top of the charts....   [tags: Music Review]

Strong Essays
1642 words (4.7 pages)

Essay about Losers and Winners of Globalization

- 'Despite the views of many optimists, there are clearly losers as well as winners from the process of globalization.' The statement at the head of the page assumes that Globalization creates both winners and losers. This is a view shared by many, but not all, theorists and commentators. There are many trends of thought regarding exactly who the winners and losers may be as well as what may be considered a prize or a punishment (e.g. some may sight the availability of McDonalds fast food throughout France an enrichment and some may see it as an unwelcome and unsavoury invasion.) Comparison between these opinions paints an interesting picture of what Globaliza...   [tags: Globalisation Essays]

Strong Essays
1767 words (5 pages)

Graduation Speech: We are Winners

- Parents, family and friends, faculty, Class of 2012: Tonight we celebrate the completion of 12 years of schooling and look toward what will be in store for us in the future. It has been a long road for most of us, and a difficult one for some, but the fact is, we made it. Tonight we are all winners. However, I would like to talk for just a few minutes about losing. Throughout history there were many people we consider winners, who, in fact, lost many times in their lives. Walt Disney was fired by a newspaper editor because he had "no good ideas." Even though he hit 714 home runs, Babe Ruth struck out 1,330 times....   [tags: Graduation Speech, Commencement Address]

Free Essays
933 words (2.7 pages)

Critical Reviews of Brave New World Essay

- Critical Reviews of Brave New World Since the original publishing of Brave New World, the book has stirred up a brew of controversy. It has received many reviews both positive and negative. In this paper I will provide examples of both and look at the reasons behind them. My first review is a negative one. In the review the reviewer states as his main reasons for disliking the book are the obnoxious characters and plot holes. A few examples of this are that Bernard Marx is unhappy with his life and wants to expand his mind yet all he does is take random vacations to the Savage Reservation....   [tags: essays papers]

Strong Essays
752 words (2.1 pages)

Attributes of Typical Heisman Trophy Winners Essay

- HEISMAN DILEMMA The Heisman Trophy: symbol of unquestionable superiority among fellow NCAA division 1-A athletes . . . or is it. This unique honor is awarded to the player who the Heisman panel believes is the “best” player in 1-A. The award can be given to a player of “any position,” or so the Heisman committee says. There has never been a Heisman candidate who hasn’t been a quarterback, running back, or multi-purpose skill player (for example: someone who plays wide receiver, defensive back, and is a situational running back)....   [tags: College Football]

Strong Essays
2427 words (6.9 pages)