A Good Samaritan Law is Never a Good Idea Essay

A Good Samaritan Law is Never a Good Idea Essay

Length: 1196 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A Good Samaritan Law is Never a Good Idea


Less than one year ago, the largest television audience since the series finale of M*A
*S*H tuned in to watch the last episode of Seinfeld As the nation watched, Jerry, Elaine, George, and Kramer said farewell with the arrest, trial, and conviction of violating a Good Samaritan law. While this made for a hilarious television show, this law itself seems to both contradict its essence as well as violate the right to freedom of choice of a citizen. The Good Samaritan law, which requires a bystander to provide aid to those who are in harm’s way if there is no apparent immediate danger to the bystander, encroaches upon the rights of a citizen. This law is an inexcusable violation of American civil liberties and should be stricken from the records, leaving only people’s moral compasses as their guide.

The morality of this law is relatively simple: help those in trouble. Generally society
seems to consider it a moral obligation to prevent the injury of another person, sometimes even at risk to one’s self. People who do not help others in need are frequently bad examples for the rest of the world. For example, in Charles Dickens’s classic A Christmas Carol, Ebeneezer Scrooge is infamous for his selfishness and disregard for the well-being of others such as Bob Cratchett and his family (barely paying him and not allowing him more than a day for Christmas). Scrooge’s partner, Jacob Marley, is damned for the same type of crimes. The only path to redemption for Ebeneezer is through helping others who are in need: giving food to the Cratchetts and caring for a sickly Tiny Tim.

While Scrooge had a moral reason to help others, there was no Constitutional burden to
do so. If the federal...


... middle of paper ...


...ce call buttons more accessible to the public since many are willing to contact the law enforcement officials.

Although Jerry and Elaine can not seem to provide more than a few jokes when seeing
their fellow man in trouble, the majority of Americans seem to be willing to help. Despite several incidents to the contrary, the morals of most people will guide them. These less-talked-about occasions in which people called the police, yelled for help, or even tried to physically stop attackers outweigh the apathetic few. With these facts in mind, this law presents unacceptable violations of the freedom of liberty. Ultimately, then, Good Samaritan laws are both unnecessary and dangerous.

Bibliography

“Good Samaritan Laws are Questionable.” alt.politics.lawenforcenieflt.Ca.Com (12 October 1998)

“Rapist-Murderer Case.” alt.adoption.com (03 September 1998).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Why Law Is Law?

- Law is Law In order to determine whether something is legitimately law or not, one must first determine what exactly law is; something that theorists such as Hart, Aquinas, Austin and Fuller have been arguing about for generations. While it is easy enough to argue who can make law, how it can be made, and so on, it is a little bit more difficult when it comes to deciding whether a bad law, such as the The Law for the Prevention of Offspring with Hereditary Diseases put into effect in 1933, among many other laws which were put into effect during this time by Hitler as Germany’s sovereign, is indeed actually law....   [tags: Law, Appeal, LAW, Political philosophy]

Strong Essays
2037 words (5.8 pages)

Essay about Natural Law And Human Law

- Natural law can be considered to be the root of human morality and Aquinas’s idea of a Natural law implies that it is divine, immutable and eternal, but also very general with many grey areas. The fact that natural law is very general causes us humans to create human laws that are created to handle specific cases, which natural law may not be able to find a just solution. According to Aquinas Natural law is to “general” to handle the many different situations that can be found in the legal system and human law allows us to find a clear and just answer with minimal errors; which is not the case with natural law....   [tags: Law, Human rights, United Nations, LAW]

Strong Essays
1524 words (4.4 pages)

The Future Of Law : Are You Ready? Essay

- The Future of Law: Are You Ready. Due to recent events happening in North Carolina, attorneys are getting a glimpse of what the future. 1. Avvo is offering limited legal services to consumers online. 2. Legal Zoom filed a 10.5-million-dollar antitrust lawsuit against the North Carolina State Bar which was settled last year. Part of the consent order that resulted from that lawsuit requires both parties to “mutually support and use best efforts” to pass House Bill 436. HB436 will further define the “practice of law.” Companies like Legal Zoom and Avvo have increased their market share through the use of technology to meet the needs of consumers in a different way....   [tags: Lawyer, Law, Innovation, Practice of law]

Strong Essays
1089 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on The Decision Goes Against Law

- On the other hand - Rightly decided Authors and legal professionals all mostly argue that the decision goes against law and is therefore wrong, there is, which I consider, a strong argument for it being right. Statute is our supreme law and it is thus constitutional that parliament has complete sovereignty when it comes to our legal system. To that effect judges are only there to apply and interpret the law. This brings forth the question of, why wouldn’t we apply the Contractual Mistakes Act 1977, when parliament enacted it to help the courts to mitigate arbitrary effects of mistakes on contracts....   [tags: Contract, Law, Common law, Contractual term]

Strong Essays
795 words (2.3 pages)

The Crime Of The Criminal Law Essay

- The criminal law takes immense part in society, including the following functions: to deter people from acts that harms others or society. Furthermore, people who do not follow the rules that are being set by the authority, they will be punished. The criminal law is there to guidance the general public on the manners of behaviour, which are seen acceptable by society. (Jonathan Herring; criminal law, page 4 eighth edition) Criminal laws are set of rules set by the authority to set control in society....   [tags: Morality, Law, Ethics, Moral]

Strong Essays
827 words (2.4 pages)

One World Government Isn 't A Good Idea Essay

- One World Government Isn’t A Good Idea Throughout the 20th and beginning of the 21st century, the world has seen an explosion of technology that has allowed humans throughout the world to connect like never before. Now someone can from China and connects to someone in the United Sates in a matter of seconds and can have a clear crisp video call. Additionally, the invention of social media means you can find out about a big world event happening half way across the world in a matter of seconds or minutes....   [tags: Immigration, Immigration to the United States]

Strong Essays
963 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on International Law And State Jurisdiction

- The significance of International Law has developed in an undeniably global world. States and their nationals are interconnected and rely on each other to uphold and follow the universal law to meet normal objectives. On the enormous field of International Law, hardly could we abandon the extremely attractive part called State Jurisdiction. State Jurisdiction is the state’s capacity under International Law to prescribe the rule of laws, enforce the prescribed rules of laws and to adjudicate. Generally, there are four main principles of State Jurisdiction, which includes The Territorial Principle, The Nationality Principle, The Protective Principle, and The Universal Principle ....   [tags: International Criminal Court, Jurisdiction, Law]

Strong Essays
1665 words (4.8 pages)

Human Rights And International Law Essay

- Human Rights in International Law International law is very complex, human rights in regards to international law is even more complex. Human rights are basically a sub category of international law. It does not stand on its own body of law but still an important aspect. The practice of human rights includes basic elements of state identity and sovereignty, international organization, and the incorporation of international law into domestic law (Bedesman, 2006). These came around for the mere fact decades ago human rights did not exist....   [tags: Human rights, Law, United Nations]

Strong Essays
1552 words (4.4 pages)

Are Safe-Haven Laws A Good Idea? Essay

- Are Safe-Haven Laws A Good Idea. Debi Faris recently made the sad drive, again, from her home in Yucaipa, California, to the Los Angeles County coroner's office to retrieve the body of a baby boy who had been left by a dumpster. Ms. Faris, her husband, Mark, and others laid baby Jacob (who was named by the police officer who found the child) to rest in the Garden of Angels, a small portion of a local cemetery the Farises established for abandoned infants in 1996. With the help of donations, they bought 44 plots four years ago....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Papers]

Strong Essays
1280 words (3.7 pages)

Catherine The Great And The New Law Code Essay

- Catherine II, or more commonly known as Catherine the Great, reigned over Russia with the ideas of Enlightenment. These ideas are best seen in her attempt at a new law code, the Nakaz. From reading the Nakaz, someone can see that Catherine saw the Enlightenment ideas of natural law, freedom, and liberty as the most important. The new law code was created not only to enforce the enlightenment ideas, but also to have a more concise law code for the people of Russia. Catherine argued that a trend towards Enlightenment of government would help connect Russia with the West....   [tags: Political philosophy, Law, Age of Enlightenment]

Strong Essays
1460 words (4.2 pages)