Drama vs. History in Shakespeare's Henry V Essay

Drama vs. History in Shakespeare's Henry V Essay

Length: 3565 words (10.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Drama vs. History in Shakespeare's Henry V

 
    It is not necessary to have authored seven historical dramas, as Shakespeare had when he set to work on Henry V, to conclude that history is frequently not very dramatic. Chronicles of the past have the subjectivity and subtly of national anthems - they are about appropriating the truth, not approaching it. Noble causes and giant killing abound in these documents, often at the cost of fact and explanation. All this adds up to an account of the past in which the winners reign victorious before the battle even begins, while the losers' natural iniquity contributes as much to their defeat as enemy swords and soldiers. Readers in the present may wonder that their ancestors ever felt twinges of suspense as the events wore on, for according to historians, the outcome of these clashes was, as King Henry would say, "as gross/ As black on white" (2.2.104). It is as predictable, the Elizabethans might have said, as a bad play.

 

And yet there was suspense and anxiety in days gone by, as surely as political maneuvering in the present sows seeds of unrest. Shakespeare realized this and came to a startling conclusion - there is a gap between the events of the past and historical narrative. The proclivities of the historian become the very shape of history, cramming the past with mighty deeds and epic heroes. But this shape is warped, fashioned, as it is, in the likeness of famous men and dubious motives. Historians see the past as a straight and singular line; Shakespeare knew its course could neither have been quite so direct nor quite so simple. Henry V is his attempt to reinsert the complexities of the past into the straightforward narrative of history, to ...


... middle of paper ...


...0.

Becker, George J. Shakespeare's Histories. New York: Frederick Ungar Publishing Co., 1977.

Bloom, Harold.  "Introduction."  Modern Critical Interpretations William Shakespeare's Henry V.  Ed. Bloom.  New York:  Chelsea House Publishers, 1988. 1-4.

Brennan, Anthony. Henry V. New York: Twayne Publishers, 1992.

Granville-Barker, Harley.  "From Henry V to Hamlet."  Studies In Shakespeare.  Ed. Alexander.  London:  Oxford University Press, 1964.

Rabkin, Norman.  "Either/Or:  Responding to Henry V."  Modern Critical Interpretations William Shakespeare's Henry V.  Ed. Bloom.  New York:  Chelsea House Publishers, 1988.  35-59.

Shakespeare, William. Henry V. Ed. A. R. Humphreys, New York: Penguin Books, 1996.

Shakespeare, William. The Complete Works of William Shakespeare. Ed. John Dover Wilson. London: Cambridge University Press, 1985.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Comedy in I Henry IV and II Henry IV by William Shakespeare

- Comedy in I Henry IV and II Henry IV     In I Henry IV and II Henry IV, William Shakespeare brings together drama and comedy to create two of the most compelling history plays ever written. Many of Shakespeare's other works are nearly absolute in their adherence to either the comic or tragic traditions, but in the two Henry IV plays Shakespeare combines comedy and drama in ways that seem to bring a certain realism to his characters, and thus the plays. The present essay is an examination of the various and significant effects that Shakespeare's comedic scenes have on I Henry IV and II Henry IV....   [tags: Henry IV Henry V Essays]

Powerful Essays
2529 words (7.2 pages)

Sex, Masculine Pride, and War in Henry V Essay

- Sex, Masculine Pride, and War in Henry V        Henry V, though reputed to be a crude, early item from Shakespeare's canon, provides many interesting and mature discussions on morality and psychology. Far from being, as it were, pre-written by being an "historical" work, it is a testament to the bard's skill that he can work so many ideas into a frame that has to take account of popular facts.   Interpretation of the play tends to revolve around issues of kingship, duplicity in Harry's self-presentation, or the consequences of war, but there is a glaring line of discussion present which has generally been missed: the relationship of war to sex and masculine pride....   [tags: Henry IV Henry V Essays]

Powerful Essays
2419 words (6.9 pages)

Essay on William Shakespeare's Henry V

- William Shakespeare's Henry V Shakespeare's, Henry V, was written in the late sixteenth century, this composition will focus upon how Shakespeare portrayed Henry V, using factual knowledge and Shakespeare's own interpretation. I will look at the character, language, structure and history of the play. Most Shakespearian, historical, plays were based upon Holinshead's Chronicles, these were mostly true but often Shakespeare adjusted the figures and facts to emphasise parts of his play's, and create tension and drama, such as when he is attempting to woo Katherine, to make a more interesting play....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1364 words (3.9 pages)

The Passing of the Crown by Shakespeare's Henries Essay

- The Passing of the Crown by Shakespeare's Henries       In his histories from Richard II through Henry V to Richard III, Shakespeare depicts the English monarchy as a game between family and friends of vying for a gold ring -- the crown. Shakespeare gives his reader a central metaphor through which to see this equation in King Henry IV part one. The prank Prince Hal, later King Henry V, and his friend, Poins, play on their friends, particularly Falstaff, parallels the plot's focal passing of the crown....   [tags: Henry IV Henry V Essays]

Powerful Essays
1856 words (5.3 pages)

The History Plays of Shakespeare Essay

- The term History Play is commonly used to denote the plays (whether tragedies or comedies) in which the action and the major themes of the play are primarily political rather than individual or social. Though Shakespeare did not distinguish between the genres of his plays, when the collected works of Shakespeare was published by his own colleagues in the Chamberlain's- King's company as the First Folio in 1623, the plays, the editors divided them into Comedies, Histories and Tragedies. Though some historical plays show the characteristics of tragedy or comedy, they are different from the regular tragedies and comedies in that they deal only with political matters without straying into...   [tags: European Literature]

Powerful Essays
1892 words (5.4 pages)

History and Tragedy in Shakespeare's Richard II Essay examples

- History and Tragedy in Richard II         An attempt to sort Shakespeare's plays into neat categories may appear to have its benefits when striving to understand his work, but even a superficial reading of Richard II indicates that this approach is largely futile and sometimes misleading. While it cannot be doubted that the play is of a historical nature, based on events recorded in Holinshed's Chronicles of 1577 and named after an actual king, a sense of true Shakespearean tragedy is also present throughout....   [tags: Richard II Richard III Essays]

Powerful Essays
2054 words (5.9 pages)

Essay on The Writings of Shakespeare

- Witchcraft is viewed both as a religion and a way of life; it has evolved greatly throughout time and history in Europe, and has a large influence in the arts. Witchcraft dates back to as early as the ancient Celts and Druids, and was originally a nature based religion where people gave reverence to the elements for the animals and vegetables they ate (“Witchcraft Started”). The word “witch” translates to the Hebrew word “kashaph”, which comes from the root meaning “to whisper” (Linder). Witchcraft is a spiritual belief system and a way of life....   [tags: Shakespearean Literature]

Powerful Essays
967 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about Why was Elizabethan theatre so successful?

- Why was Elizabethan theatre so successful. One of the reasons that Elizabethan theatre was so successful was that it was enjoyed by the Queen. Elizabeth never visited the theatre herself, but was known to have invited companies of actors to perform for her at court, as is shown by this extract from government records in 1572: "To the Lord Chamberlain's players at Whitehall, 25 February 1572, for a play presented by them before Her Majesty on St Stephen's Day." She was a very important patron of the theatre, even allowing one company to call themselves "The Queen's men"....   [tags: Drama]

Powerful Essays
819 words (2.3 pages)

Life of Shakespeare Essay

- Well-known throughout the world, the works of William Shakespeare have been performed in countless theatres in different hamlets, villages, and cities for more than 400 years. And yet, the person behind it is somewhat of a mystery to us. The only sources we have of his life are either his work (plays, poems and sonnets) or church and court records However, these only provide an outline and brief sketches of certain events in his life and provide little on the person who experienced those events....   [tags: plays, tragedy, writer]

Powerful Essays
1014 words (2.9 pages)

The Importance of the Elizabethan Concept of Natural Order to Our Appreciation of Macbeth and Henry V

- The Importance of the Elizabethan Concept of Natural Order to Our Appreciation of Macbeth and Henry V The Elizabethan concept of Natural Order to our appreciation of Macbeth and Henry V was down to the belief that God created everything from man down to plants. He arranged hierarchical principles in the world and he ran the whole system. He controlled the animals and where their place was in the world along with all the other living creatures. Its natural instinct to know the lion was the king of the animal kingdom and the eagle was the king of the birds etc....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1183 words (3.4 pages)