19th Century Theories in Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment
"I teach you the Superman. Man is something that has to be
surpassed. What have you done to surpass him?" These words said by
Friedrich Nietzsche encompass the theories present in Dostoevsky's
nineteenth century novel, Crime and Punishment. Fyodor Dostoevsky, living
a life of suffering himself, created the character of Raskolnikov with the
preconceptions of his own sorrowful and struggling life. Throughout his
exile in Siberia from 1849-1859, his sentiments of suffering, sorrow, and
the common man surfaced and heightened, inspiring him to begin writing
Crime and Punishment in 1859.
The main motif in this novel is that of suffering. It is apparent
that all characters, major and minor, experience some sort of internal or
external affliction. The overall theme of the work is that all mortal men
suffer, and that salvation can not be obtained unless this anguish is
present. Dostoevsky's protagonist, Raskolnikov, must evolve and realize
this fact to overcome his conflicts and reach the salvation of peace and
tranquillity. Volumes and volumes of critique can be written on where this
suffering originated, but Dostoevsky's main concentration and focus is not
where, but why suffering must exist and how this suffering can be
overcome. This is seen from the fact that throughout the six sections of
the novel, only one section is focused on the origin of the torment - the
Crime, and the remaining five sections are concentrated on Raskolnikov's
path to overcoming this anguish - the Punishment.
By focusing solely on the punishment, the internal an...
... middle of paper ...
... all serve a justified purpose in benefiting his moral and rational states. He overcomes the common man through the salvation he obtains from this linear evolution of trials. He suffers not from Marxist classes, but from internal struggle, excluding him as a member of the proletariat, or common man. Though not physically or emotionally fit to survive, his confession becomes his salvation, his survival, and his disclaimer in the Darwin theory of surviving. The common man may survive because he is fit to survive, but Raskolnikov survives because he chooses to survive. Unlike Freud's theory that the everyday man lives his life through his ego, Raskolnikov makes his decisions based on his superego, doing things not just because it would be rational, but because that it the way it should be done. So then, "Is Raskolnikov a Superman?" Yes.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Fyodor Dostoyevsky wrote, It must have been a difficult task for Dostoevsky to come to this conclusion. He could be compared to that of the Prodigal son, who returned to God only after all other forms of belief were ventured. Being raised in a Russian Orthodox household, as a youth Dostoyevsky rebelled against religion and later began to believe in the anarchist and atheistic philosophy that was common among radical students and middle-class people that were against the status quo in 19th century Russia.... [tags: Crime and Punishment Essay]
1514 words (4.3 pages)
- In the novel Crime and Punishment, the so-called "extraordinary man" theory plays an important role. Raskolnikov, downtrodden, and psychologically battered, believes himself to be exempt from the laws of ordinary men. It is this creedo that makes him believe he has the right to murder Alyona Ivanovna. In the nineteenth century, the extraordinary man theory was widely popular. There were two main schools of thought on the subject, the proponents of which were the philosophers Georg Hegel and Freiderich Neitzsche.... [tags: Crime Punishment Essays]
652 words (1.9 pages)
- If we studied through the history of criminal theory, spiritual and natural theories are taken as major theories of causation of crime. During medieval period, spiritual explanations were taken as punishment given by god for doing wrong things and any natural disasters like flood, fires, etc were evaluated as curse of high power. In modern period, the basic theories of causation of crime are classical theory, biological theory, psychological theory, cultural theory and conflict theory.... [tags: Crime ]
1238 words (3.5 pages)
- I. Summarize each of the theories posited in this chapter. In the early days of Juvenile justice a theory of criminology was developed to explain crime and why it was committed. The Classic School of Criminology developed after Cesare Bonesana Beccaria published an essay titled “On Crime and Punishment” and was followed by Jeremy Bentham’s “An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation” (Bartollas, 2014, p.51) The general idea of this school of thought is that human have the ability to make the right choice, if not we will be punished.... [tags: Criminology, Crime]
1682 words (4.8 pages)
- The Limitations of Reason Exposed in Crime and Punishment Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment illustrates an important idea. The idea is that "reason," that grand and uniquely human power, is limited in reach and scope. Social critic Friedrich August von Hayek commented once that, ". it may be that the most difficult task for human reason is to comprehend its own limitations. It is essential for the growth of reason that as individuals we should bow to forces and obey principles we cannot hopefully to understand, yet on which the advance and even the preservation of civilization may depend." Such limitations imply that on life's most important questions - pa... [tags: Crime Punishment Essays]
3051 words (8.7 pages)
- For example, in the 1950s, Mao stated that offenders who did not have “blood debt” and those offenses that did not cause grand public indignation, should be given the suspended death sentence. Post-Mao leaders also voiced their views on the death penalty. Deng, who initiated the strike-hard campaigns in light of the rampant crimes, commented that the authorities could not be soft on crime, and the death sentence was “a necessary educative tool” in dealing with a few most serious offenses. 9 Current leaders, such as President of the PRC Hu Jintao, Premier Wen Jiabao and President of the Supreme Court Xiao Yang, have stated that China cannot abolish the death penalty under the current social c... [tags: Capital punishment, Crime, Prison, Decapitation]
1249 words (3.6 pages)
- A Study of the literary techniques used by Fyodor Dostoyevsky in Crime and Punishment to convey the downfall and subsequent rise of the main character. "Crime and Punishment" by Fyodor Dostoyevsky is the story of a young student Raskolnikov and his need to murder an old woman to prove one of his many philosophies. The book begins with the murder, but the primary focus is on his reasoning and reactions before and after the act. It is set in St Petersburg where the main character, Raskolnikov, appears to be an ex-student living, in poverty, a life of lethargy.... [tags: Crime and Punishment Essays]
2235 words (6.4 pages)
- When is murder ever justifiable. That is a question that needs to be asked when discussing the righteousness or wickedness of capital punishment, or more simply stated, the death penalty. The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy describes the act of capital punishment as deliberately killing an individual for a criminal offense, usually a serious offense such as murder or treason (Murtagh, n.d.). Taken at face value, capital punishment is premeditated murder committed by a governing authority justified by law as the punishment for the crime committed.... [tags: Capital punishment, Crime]
1537 words (4.4 pages)
- Punishment has been in existence since the early colonial period and has continued throughout history as a method used to deter criminals from committing criminal acts. Philosophers believe that punishment is a necessity in today’s modern society as it is a worldwide response to crime and violence. Friedrich Nietzche’s book “Punishment and Rehabilitation” reiterates that “punishment makes us into who we are; it creates in us a sense of responsibility and the ability to take and release our social obligations” (Blue, Naden, 2001).... [tags: Punishment and Rehabilitation]
2222 words (6.3 pages)
- Introduction The author is a strong supporter of the notion that "punishment for the sake of deterrence is justified", and this is because people tend to obey the law after calculating the consequences attached by the law to a particular act of crime. Punishing a person for a crime in order to deter others from performing the same crime again does not guarantee us that the crime will never be performed by anyone at all, but it definitely lowers the number of people who would commit the same crime in future.... [tags: Deterrence Theory of Punishment]
2543 words (7.3 pages)