In his introduction to the story, Miss Brill by Katherine Mansfield, Michael Meyer says, "Mansfield tends to focus on intelligent, sensitive protagonists who undergo subtle but important changes in their lives" (226). Two key questions in Miss Brill are what kind of intelligence and sensitivity does she posses, and what is the true nature of the change that she undergoes as a result of the young man's cruel remark about her, "But why not? Because of that stupid old thing at the end there? Why does she come here at all - who wants her?" (Mansfield 229).
Miss Brill's turns her sensitivity outward rather than inward. She possesses keen eye for outward appearances and detail, but has little knowledge of inward life. As Rhoda Nathan comments, "...the genteel Miss Brill is an observer of life, one who sits on the sidelines and watches the game in all of its striving, contending, and passion" (92). This is clear from her observations of people in the park. She describes the two people who initially share her seat, the older gentleman with the carved walking stick and the big old woman with her knitting, but they do not interest her because they are not engaged in conflict (Mansfield 227). Instead, they seem perfectly happy together. In fact, most of the old people in the park do not interest her. However, the couple that sat there last week was more interesting because they were arguing. She said she needs spectacles, but when he suggested ones with gold rims, she replied, "They'll always be sliding down my nose!" a statement that irritates Miss Brill (Mansfield 227). Likewise, the brutish gentleman in gray who blows cigarette smoke in the face of the "ermine toque" also fascinates her (Mansfield...
... middle of paper ...
...Even the last line, which at first seems so poignant, is also part of the act, an overly sentimental and banal ending that masks rather than reveals the emptiness of her existence.
Mansfield, Katherine. "Miss Brill." The Compact Bedford Introduction to Literature. 5th ed. Ed. Michael Meyer. Boston, MA: Bedford/St. Martin, 2000. 226-229.
Meyer, Michael. "Katherine Mansfield." The Compact Bedford Introduction to Literature. 5th ed. . Ed. Michael Meyer. Boston, MA: Bedford/St. Martin, 2000. 226.
Shakespeare, William. The Tempest. The Riverside Shakespeare. 2nd ed. Ed. Herschel Baker et. al. New York, NY. Houghton Mifflin Company, 1997. 1680.
Toth, David. Dave's Home Page. Three Rivers Community College. 9 Oct. 2000. http://www.geocities.com/davidjohtoth/brillcrit.html.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- In her short story “Miss Brill,” Katherine Mansfield investigates a case of perception versus reality in which Miss Brill’s imagination distorts her outlook on the world. Miss Brill, an elderly, isolated, and naïve woman, finds entertainment in observing the lives of others. She imagines herself and the people around her as part of a theatrical play, each with a part. However, she becomes so caught up with this whimsical view on life that the wave of reality demoralizes her. Through Miss Brill’s perspective, Mansfield demonstrates the harmful side of imagination that stems from isolation and causes a misperception of the world around us.... [tags: Mind, Imagination, The Play, Theatre]
1080 words (3.1 pages)
- I“Distorted Reality” In her short story “Miss Brill,” Katherine Mansfield investigates a case of perception versus reality in which Miss Brill’s imagination distorts her outlook on the world. Miss Brill, an elderly, isolated, and naïve woman, finds entertainment in observing the lives of others. She imagines herself and the people around her as part of a great theatrical play, each with a specific role. However, she becomes so caught up with her whimsical view on life that the wave of reality demoralizes her.... [tags: Mind, Imagination, Old age, Woman]
1044 words (3 pages)
- “The method a writer takes to bring a character to life” is defined as characterization. "Miss Brill" by Katherine Mansfield displays the character of Miss Brill as the protagonist, confronted with the reality of her existence. In the short story "Miss Brill," by Katherine Mansfield, an elderly woman spends a Sunday afternoon visiting a seaside park as part of her weekly ritual. As a developing character, Miss Brill is forced to face a harsh reality from her routine events. In the short story, "Miss Brill," Katherine Mansfield effectively uses various literary techniques to characterize Miss Brill's complex and interesting character.... [tags: Miss Brill Essays]
1118 words (3.2 pages)
- Katherine Mansfield's "Miss Brill" perfectly captures the phases one's mind goes through when faced with becoming old. Elderly people tend to be nostalgic, even sentimental about their youth. In later years, the nostalgia can develop into senility or fantasy. The ermine fur in "Miss Brill" is the catalyst of her nostalgia and symbolizes the passing of time in three stages: an expectant youth, a vital adulthood, and finally, a development into old age and fantasy. The story opens with Miss Brill's excitement that the "season" has arrived for social engagements; perhaps it is the tourist season when the ladies debut their latest fashions.... [tags: Miss Brill Essays]
612 words (1.7 pages)
- In "Miss Brill," by Katherine Mansfield, Sundays are a magical day for Miss Brill until she is forced to step out of her daydream and face reality. Every Sunday Miss Brill, a shy English school teacher, goes to the Public Gardens and takes her "special seat" to look forward to listening to the conversations of others.. This lonely older woman has become quite the expert on eavesdropping. Miss Brill starts to view everything she observes on Sundays in the form of a beautifully choreographed theatrical performance in which everything, herself included, plays a role.... [tags: Miss Brill Essays]
338 words (1 pages)
- Katherine Mansfield's "Miss Brill" is a woman self-contained, not pessimistic but settled, content. She is not a victim of her circumstances, but the satisfied creator of them. You could say she has her ducks lined up the way she wants them. Through the character of Miss Brill, Katherine Mansfield reveals a woman who has the ability to enjoy a simple world of her own elaborate creation. Miss Brill is a single woman, probably in her mid to late fifties. She lives alone in a very small space without even a cat or bird.... [tags: Miss Brill Essays]
818 words (2.3 pages)
- In "Miss Brill," Katherine Mansfield describes an aging English teacher living in France who visits the Public Gardens every Sunday to listen to the band play and observe the other park visitors. On this particular Sunday, Miss Brill notices that it is just cool enough to unpack her favorite fur. She has not worn the fur in a long time and is delighted to wear it again. When she reaches the park she sits on her favorite bench and proceeds to observe the people around her and listen to the band.... [tags: Miss Brill Essays]
753 words (2.2 pages)
- In Katherine Mansfield’s “Miss Brill” she illustrates a sanctimonious older female whom at the conclusion of the story understands the true definition of the ancient saying, “treat people the way you would like to be treated”. Correspondingly, in Eudora Welty’s “A Worn Path” she exhibits the true meaning of “love” and how it along with courage can help you conquer any obstacle or dilemma you may encounter. With this in mind, the protagonists in each story allocate modest similarities, there are likewise compelling differences to be contemplated.... [tags: Eudora Welty, A Worn Path, Jackson, Mississippi]
811 words (2.3 pages)
- Katherine Mansfield’s “Miss Brill” protagonist, Miss Brill, portrays an educated, older white Caucasian female in France, seems to the reader to be alone, deranged, and miserable with an extensive imagination. Mansfield doesn’t say if Miss Brill is married or not; however, the reader would assume she isn’t due to how lonely she is. The only time Miss Brill gets to interact with people is on Sundays when she goes to the park to eavesdrop and “supposedly” listen to the band play. She is so deranged that she doesn’t even assume eavesdropping is wrong.... [tags: Eudora Welty, A Worn Path, Jackson, Mississippi]
716 words (2 pages)
- Question 1 “Miss Brill” by Katherine Mansfield tells a story of a lonely, English lady in France. Miss Brill is a quiet person who believes herself to be important. The whole afternoon at the gardens, Miss Brill does not converse with anyone, nor does anyone show any inclination to talk with her. She merely watches others and listens to their conversations. This provides her with a sense of companionship; she feels as if she is a part of other people’s lives. Miss Brill is also slightly self-conceited.... [tags: Miss Brill Essays]
1099 words (3.1 pages)