Comparing the Dominant and Feminist Readings of Shakespeare's King Lear

Comparing the Dominant and Feminist Readings of Shakespeare's King Lear

Length: 1365 words (3.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Comparing the Dominant and Feminist Readings of King Lear

 
   Shakespeare's King Lear has been the source of much contention as to the way in which the text can be read. The play originally was written for the Jacobean audience of Shakespeare's time, but since then has taken on many other readings. These new readings are produced to comment on issues in the society in which it is explored. Readings encompass a wide range of ideas - from the Dominant reading, the manner in which Shakespeare's audience would have perceived the text, to feminist ideals. The various readings are influenced by the context in which they are discussed. In particular the dominant and feminist readings of King Lear both perceive the text in different contexts; the dominant following the traditional Jacobean interpretation as it was originally written, and the feminist reading pursuing a need for the lack of a patriarchal society in the twentieth century. King Lear can be read in a variety of ways, achieving a set perspective that suits the reader.

 

The Jacobean reading of King Lear focuses the blame for chaos and the subsequent tragedies on Lear's foolish decision to divide his kingdom between his three daughters. Though the play is set in pre-Christian times, Shakespeare's audience was greatly influenced by Elizabethan structure and hierarchy. According to the Great Chain of Being, God was the head of the universe, and the King was established as Gods connection to people. Lear's choice of abdication would have been viewed as blasphemy towards God. The audience would now perceive Lear's tragedy as inevitable due to his decisions. The play `King Lear' can be viewed as an expression of the Jacobean period concept of so...


... middle of paper ...


... focuses on Lear's downfall and the pity we feel for Lear. The feminist reading of King Lear focuses on how the portrayal of women in the play is of a negative aspect and displays women as unfit for any role of leadership, else chaos ensues. The film A Thousand Miles shows how King Lear can be interpreted as a feminist reading in a contemporary setting, revealing the text King Lear in an entirely new light - women portrayed as the victims of men. King Lear can indeed be read in a variety of ways.

 

Works Cited

Frey, C.  Experiencing Shakespeare.  Columbia: University of Missouri Press, 1988.

Granville-Barker, H.  Prefaces to Shakespeare.  London: B.T. Batsford INC, 1984.

Halio, J.  The Tragedy of King Lear.  Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992. 

Thompson, A.  King Lear Criticism.  NJ: Humanities Press International, 1988.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

William Shakespeare 's King Lear Essay

- Rough Draft 1: King Lear Lack of insight or blindness to one’s surroundings can be an indicator of failure in one’s proper metacognition. This blindness is a tragic flaw, that in which, if one is not quick to realize it, it can have deadly and long term effects as developed through William Shakespeare’s King Lear. According to Shakespeare, blindness is not simply a physical issue, but rather an intellectual issue. In the play, the dominant theme of figurative and literal blindness carries both the main and counterplots throughout the play....   [tags: William Shakespeare, King Lear, Blindness]

Powerful Essays
1086 words (3.1 pages)

William Shakespeare 's King Lear Essay

- Shakespeare’s play “King Lear” does not lack wicked characters. Throughout the play, it is evident that most characters only care about themselves and their status in England. Such characters as Goneril and Edmund will do anything to improve their standings in society such as killing and betraying family members. In contrast, The Duke of Albany cares about King Lear and England, but he takes no action to prove that he cares for them. However, the character Albany goes through a metamorphosis as the play evolves....   [tags: King Lear, William Shakespeare, Anxiety]

Powerful Essays
1180 words (3.4 pages)

William Shakespeare 's ' Bloom 's Shakespeare Through The Ages : King Lear

- As Harold Bloom analyzes various interpretations of King Lear in his book, Bloom’s Shakespeare Through the Ages: King Lear, he starts by discussing modern critical interpretations of King Lear. Bloom believes Shakespeare used King Lear to mold out a sense of reality that cannot be seen in any other plays or books except the Bible (304-305). Furthermore, like many other critics have said, Bloom agrees that many elements of King Lear are similar to the Book of Job. However, Bloom believes that Shakespeare sought to have this play resemble the Book of Job in order for the audience to see Job as a model for King Lear’s situation and emphasize the negativity of King Lear’s tragedy....   [tags: William Shakespeare, King Lear]

Powerful Essays
1109 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on William Shakespeare 's King Lear

- Shakespeare 's King Lear is a story of a king who sets out to divide his kingdom among his three daughters, with only Goneril and Regan reaping in his fortune. The family unit becomes torn as conflicts between personalities emerge between King Lear and his three daughters, thus creating a tragic end for many. King Lear 's two eldest daughters, Goneril, and Regan defy the roles and rights of women of the eight-century, displaying behavioral traits that are less desirable. Whereas King Lear 's youngest beloved daughter, Cordelia, embodied the warmth and true spirit of women that one would up most expect during this time period, one who showed loyalty, respect, and honesty, but remained strong...   [tags: King Lear, William Shakespeare, Man, Gender role]

Powerful Essays
1536 words (4.4 pages)

William Shakespeare 's King Lear Essay example

- After reading William Shakespeare’s King Lear, I believe that choice is the governing factor. King Lear, the main character, is lead to his downfall as a result of his own choices. These choices lead him to lose everything, which includes the lives of his daughter as well as his own. King Lear’s poor decisions are a result of his clouded judgment and arrogant attitude. Ironically, when Lear finally realizes his mistakes, it is too late to correct. King Lear was able to avoid his downfall had he made different choices, but unfortunately was blinded by his pride....   [tags: Love, King Lear, William Shakespeare, Choice]

Powerful Essays
1358 words (3.9 pages)

Essay about William Shakespeare 's King Lear

- Communication is the key essential for one to fully understand and personify the thought of another. Without the key essentials themselves, a knowledge for wisdom and understanding would be lost, thus, causing a breakdown towards communication and emotional intelligence. Within the theatrical play, King Lear written by William Shakespeare himself, comes the story of the falling of an old English Elizabethan king, Lear, whose patriarch role was taken away; due to the act of his own pride. Other than the play’s main plot, King Lear too portrays the telling between the lost of communication and the consequences of its breakdown between people, parents and children....   [tags: King Lear, William Shakespeare, Love, Edmund]

Powerful Essays
1302 words (3.7 pages)

Essay about First Five Scenes of William Shakespeare's Macbeth

- First Five Scenes of William Shakespeare's Macbeth 'Fair is foul and foul is fair' are seven of the most important words in William Shakespeare's shortest and bloodiest tragedy. 'Macbeth' tells the story of a heroic Scottish general, Macbeth, who hears a prophecy from a trio of witches that one day he will become king of Scotland. Consumed with ambitious thoughts and spurred to action by his wife, Macbeth murders King Duncan and seizes the throne for himself. He begins his reign wracked with guilt and fear and soon becomes a tyrannical ruler, as he is forced to commit more and more murders to protect himself from being suspected of King Duncan's murder....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1840 words (5.3 pages)

The Selfish King in Shakespeare's King Lear Essay

- The Selfish King in Shakespeare's King Lear In Shakespeare's King Lear a king is stripped of his land, wealth, soldiers, and all of his power because he is stubborn, egocentric, and unkind. Other than losing money and power he loses his three daughters as well. Lear?s pride is so overwhelming that he is unwilling to allow anyone to contradict him. If anyone (besides his fool) even remotely hints that his actions were wrong he gets unnecessarily enraged....   [tags: King Lear William Shakespeare Tragedies]

Powerful Essays
1012 words (2.9 pages)

William Shakespeare's King Lear Essay

- William Shakespeare's King Lear "A man more sinned against than sinning" King Lear is one of Shakespeare's more complex plays and within it many different themes are addressed and explored. King Lear is the somewhat unfortunate vehicle that Shakespeare uses to explore many of these themes creating a complex character including the roles of a father, king, friend and adversary....   [tags: William Shakespeare King Lear]

Powerful Essays
1855 words (5.3 pages)

Essay on William Shakespeare's King Lear

- William Shakespeare's King Lear The locations in Shakespeare’s King Lear fall into three categories: inside a court, out in nature, and in-between nature and civilization. Lear himself also wavers between three states: sanity, senility, and the fine line between the two. These states of consciousness relate directly to the scenes’ locations. However, Lear’s insanity is not the fault of his location in the world; for the most part, he has control over his situation. The series of events in correspondence with the location show that man must acknowledge the nature he originated from and live in the civilized world, but not abandon nature all together because too much control or chaos leads t...   [tags: Shakespeare Play King Lear Essays]

Powerful Essays
1567 words (4.5 pages)