Relationships in Norman MacLean's A River Runs Through It
"Eventually the watcher joined the river, and there was only one of us. I believe it was the river." The river that Norman Maclean speaks of in A River Runs Through It works as a connection, a tie, holding together the relationships between Norman and his acquaintances in this remote society. Though "It" is never outwardly defined in the novella there is definite evidence "It" is the personality of the people and that the river is running through each individual personality acting as the simple thread connecting this diverse group of people.
With the help of the river these Montana residents are able to teach as well as learn from each other. Since the time of the Indians, fathers have been teaching sons the ways of the river and the Maclean family is no different. Paul and Norman learn from a young age first how to pray, read the Bible, and then fly fish from their father. For the Maclean family "there is no clear line between religion and fly-fishing" and their father is a Presbyterian preacher who incorporates all these lessons into the river. He carefully transitions from telling them "about Christ's disciples being fishermen" to teaching them "to approach the art (of fly-fishing) Marine- and Presbyterian- style" alongside the river. Along this river his sons receive "as many hours of instruction in fly fishing as in all other spiritual matters" making the river a pivotal part of everyday life.
"Although Paul was three years younger than Norman?he was already far ahead in anything relating to fishing" by their early teens. Paul quickly passes Norman and his father in skillful fishing but more than that he acquired more style. His father...
... middle of paper ...
...y and as expected Norman "is blamed for Neal." Norman is able to put his anger quickly behind him however, when he and Paul go on a fishing trip to "recuperate." He looks to "fishing for the healing effects of the cool waters" of the river. He quickly becomes lost in his fishing, so completely that he becomes "totally composed of thoughts about the Elkhorn River, the weather, and a mythological fish" and not a single thought of his dying anger.
Characters are bound to each other by the river and through their common love of the river. Sometimes the only thing they have in common is this mutual love. This Montana community is entwined in the river that runs through it. All the characters obviously feel the same as Norman when he says "I also became the river."
Work Cited
MacLean, Norman. A River Runs Through It. University of Chicago Press, 1989.
The story Duncan’s Way is about a boy named Duncan who lived in Newfoundland for really long he likes to fish he asked his dad to go fishing and his dad always says maybe later or just ignores him, but I read more Duncan’s ALL THE COD IN THE SEA HAS JUST DISSAPERED BUT THERE ARE SOME REASONS THE First REASON IS MAYBE ALL THE foreign factory ships might have sucked up ALL THE FISH FROM THE OCEAN OR PEOPLE like Duncan’s dad father overfished all the cod but all Duncan’s father mostly does is Sit on the couch and watch tv or is just Talking to his buddies and just doing nothing he is really isolating him self from
The idea of belonging is primal and fundamental. It is human nature to want to belong. In Medicine River, written by Thomas King, the desire to belong is crucial to the character development of the protagonist, Will. Belonging is represented in various ways throughout the text but the changes to Will are mainly conveyed through two channels: from community and from family.
One theme common to both narratives relates to how people are similar to bodies of water. Maclean illustrates this as he describes his brother Paul as being "tough"(8) and "very angry"(7) from his youth. Consequently, Paul's favorite river is the Big Blackfoot, which "is the most powerful and . . . runs straight and hard"(13). Maclean describes the river's "glacial origins"(14) and how it was formed overnight in "the biggest flood in the world"(14). Paul...
The characters in the movie and book are taken straight from Mclean’s life. From the hard working, soft centered, minister father, to the drunken, “down on his luck”, brother-in-law, Neil. The character of Paul appears the be the most true to life member of Norman’s family. The audience quickly becomes familiar with Paul and his quick-tempered, always ready for anything attitude. This is evident in the beginning of the story with Paul’s frequent phrase “...with a bet on the to make things interesting (Mclean 6).” “It was almost funny and sometimes not so funny to see a boy always wanting to bet on himself and almost sure to win (Mclean 5).” Unlike Norman who was rigorously home schooled every morning, while Paul seemed to escape this torment. The boys would spend their afternoons frolicking in the woods and fishing the Big Blackfoot River. The differences that developed between Paul’s and Norman’s fishing styles become evident in the published versions of Mclean’s life as well as his real life. Norman followed the traditional style taught by their preacher-father, ten and two in a four -count rhythm, like a metronome.
James Duncan’s book entitled, The River Why, focuses around the main character, Gus, and how he changes throughout the book. In this book Gus is discovering what life really is and that the whole world does not revolve around fishing. After moving out of his erratic house he spends all of his time fishing at his remote cabin, but this leaves him unhappy and a little insane. He embarks on a search for him self and for his own beliefs. Duncan changes Gus throughout the book, making Gus realize that there are more important things to life than fishing, and these things can lead to a happy fulfilled life, which in turn will help Gus enjoy life and fishing more. Duncan introduces a character, Eddy, who significantly changes Gus’s views on what he needs in his life and she gives Gus a sense of motivation or inspiration. Eddy changes Gus by their first encounter with each other, when Eddy instills in Gus a need to fulfill his life and when they meet up again, completing his need. Fishing is Gus’s first passion but he loses it after he puts all of himself into it, and when Eddy comes into his picture Gus feels a need to have more in his life, like love. Through finding love he re-finds his passion for fishing and learns more about himself. When Eddy and Gus finally get together, he sees this “equilibrium” between his old passion, fishing, and his new one, Eddy. Duncan’s use of Eddy gives Gus a new found sense of purpose and to have a more fulfilled life is a critical step in Gus’s development as a character. This is why Eddy is the most important character to this book, because she gives Gus inspiration to find himself.
The plot that develops from the setting is that when the narrator and the man are next to the river, it could be perceived as calming since that is how she felt
Norman Maclean's coming of age novella A River Runs Through It is a heartwarming semi-biography about Maclean’s upbringing in Montana during the early 20th century (between 1905- 1930). The reader learns that a compassionate, but also strict Presbyterian minister headed the Maclean household. Rev. Maclean’s ministerial background caused his son's childhood to be based on traditional religious values (also called family values), with a heavy emphasis on morality, personal responsibility/duty,
I am reading “The Bass, The River, And Sheila Mant” by W.D Wetherell and i am on page 3. So far this book is about a boy who falls in love with this girl and they ended up going on a date. On their way down the river to their date the boy catches a big bass, however his date hates fishing and he is left with a choice. In this journal i will be Questioning and connecting to the story.
All the major life changing events take place at the river; Fish drowns then gets brought back to life, Rose and Quick find love in eachother, Quick and his mother open up to each other and then finally Fish dies there. The river is a recurring symbol throughout Tim Winton's novel Cloudstreet that reinforces the themes of family, love, spirituality and determination in the search for completeness. The main setting is formed through symbolism, where Quick explains "all the important things that have happened to me, have happened near the river." Rose and Quick make the decision to be married on the river, the black angel' walks on the river and tells quick to go back to his family, illuminating fish congregate into Quick's boat, and Fish and Quick are enveloped by the stars on the river. Additionally, "even the only miracle that ever happened to you" happened near the river. The character who is most associated with the river is Fish Lamb. "The river of life" is a biblical reference, as it is where you are renewed and in the act of baptism, sins are washed away. However, when Fish drowns, the reader learns that "not all of Fish Lamb had come back”, when Oriel resuscitates Fish back to
I am reading “ The Bass, the River, and Sheila Mant” by W.D Wetherell. This story is about a boy who loves fishing and a girl next door. He decides to go on a date with her but in the end has to choose will it be the girl or the fish. In this journal I will be questioning and
Dieter Freya, Peter Fischer “Man's Best Friend: How the Presence of a Dog Reduces Mental
...by Mark Twain. The Mississippi River symbolizes freedom for Huck and Jim, as well as being their place of comfort. Nature is also a big part of Huck’s life because he is most comfortable living outside of civilization, in nature. Comparing Huckleberry and Tom, as well as showing how Huck has become affected by civilization, is important in supporting the human nature side of the human nature versus civilization conflict. In this novel, human nature has become more important than civilization because nature has taught Huck far more than living in society ever would. There are many themes in The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain. Although many of them are important in the book, the theme of nature and its significance is the most important in developing the plot, as well as showing the growth of the characters, namely the protagonist Huckleberry Finn.
The son had devised a way to tell his father that he would like to fishing with Bill instead of him alone so that the son may teach Bill. Without offering the dad to join, the boy ask the dad if he can go fishing with Bill “... If you don’t mind I’ll get up early in the morning and meet Harper and he and I will go fishing” (32-34). Trumbo does not use quotations when the boy is speaking, so in turn it speeds up the passage, mirroring the way the boy is asking the father if he is allowed to go fish with Bill. This important because it is showcasing that the son cares for the relationship although he wishes to fish with Bill, marking the first time fishing with someone else. The relationship in this part of the passage is shown to be patchy as the son still cares but wish to do new
In “The Negro Speaks of Rivers”, the river stands as a symbol of endlessness, geographical awareness, and the epitome of the human soul. Hughes uses the literary elements of repetition and simile to paint the river as a symbol of timelessness. This is evident in the first two lines of the poem. Hughes introduces this timeless symbol, stating, “I've known rivers: I've known rivers ancient as the world and older than the flow of human blood in human veins” (Hughes 1-2). These opening lines of the poem identifies that the rivers Hughes is speaking about are older than the existence of human life. This indicates the rivers’ qualities of knowledge, permanence, and the ability to endure all. Humans associate “age” with these traits and the longevity of a river makes it a force to be reckoned with. The use of a simile in the line of the poem is to prompt the audience that this is truly a contrast between that ancient wisdom, strength, and determination of the river and the same qualities that characterize a human being. The imagery portrayed in the poem of blood flowing through human veins like a river flows ...
Hughes describes himself as a teller and participant in this poem. Through the imagery, the reader is able to feel the emotions of the history of African Americans. Hughes tells us the history of black people beyond that in America; he projects upon his reader a world experience. The primary image in this poem is a river, tracing the heritage of African Americans. The lyrical lies are like water, describing the purpose of the river to black people in America. Hughes used the anaphora line “My souls has grown deep like the rivers” to symbolize the physical history of black people and the spiritual history. The river also symbolizes the strength of African Americans as survivors who persevered through history. Finally, Hughes believed that the river reflects the direct path of blacks in American. The whole poems itself is a metaphor to tie together the heritage of African Americans to the great river of the world. Hughes reveals the relationship between the rivers and the lives of black people. He started with a river know to be important during the earliest civilization and ended with a river on which slaves were