Evaluation of Actions of General Douglas Haig Essay

Evaluation of Actions of General Douglas Haig Essay

Length: 1706 words (4.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Evaluation of Actions of General Douglas Haig

Some historians believe that General Douglas Haig was a butcher
because of the amount of people killed in action at the Somme. Others
believe he was not to blame as many of the failures were mostly not of
his creation. In truth, Haig is in the middle of this scale as the
evidence and reasoning I am going to present.

General Haig studied at Sandhurst and graduated. He was then sent to
India with his brigades, which were titled the seventh hussars. He
came back from India in 1904 and was made Major General. He was the
youngest ever. He was steadily promoted up the army ranks after this
and made the full General in 1914. After the war, Haig dedicated
himself to the Royal British Legion. He was made Earl Haig in 1919 and
the Baton Haig of Bermersyde. This shows to me that General Haig was
held in high regard by the British army and was obviously identified
as a success and was well respected.

While researching Haig, I discovered that he was not a fully qualified
general and he did not have the key experience. He came from wealthy
background and I think his families wealth had a bit to do with his
appointment.

When people discuss the failure of the Somme, they consider the first
day. This was when the British lost the most men on any one day in the
war. The figure came to 57,000. That is about 40 men a minute. Was all
this loss of life to do with Haig? Was it his fault? These are the
questions I am going to examine in this essay. My main points will be
that “Haig ignored reconnaissance” and to defend him “is the Somme
really a failure and was it his fault”. In my opinion, Haig is mor...


... middle of paper ...


...tronger
towards the side which says Haig is not to blame. Purely because Haig
was not fully concentrated on the war as the French had distracted him
and his plans at Verdun and the Germans had the higher ground in the
Battle. With hindsight, we can see that Haig made mistakes and the
first day of the Somme was a disaster. However, we also have to look
at the limited options open to him. He was told to relieve Verdun and
this meant attacking the Germans. Haig made mistakes by altering
Rawlinson's plan, but he could not foresee that 30% of the British
shells would fail to explode. Haig was criticised for sending men to
capture enemy trenches, but no politician or military leader came up
with any alternatives in 1916. It is very telling that most people at
the time did not share the hostility later expressed towards Haig.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay Evaluation of an Interpretation for Sufficiency

- Evaluation of an Interpretation for Sufficiency John Keegan, a modern military historian, suggests that Haig was an 'efficient and highly skilled soldier who did much to lead Britain to victory in the First World War'. Is there sufficient evidence in Sources C to L to support this interpretation. There are those that believe Field Marshal Sir Douglas Haig was 'the Butcher of the Somme', those who would agree with John Keegan's opinion of Haig and those who see arguments for both views....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1178 words (3.4 pages)

Evaluation of the Battle of the Somme Essay

- Evaluation of the Battle of the Somme World War 1 started in 1914 and lasted for four years. There were many causes for the World War and many thought it been coming for a very long time. There was a growing tension between France and Germany over land and border lines. Also, Kaiser Wilhelm, theGerman leader, wanted to prove how powerful he thought the Germans were. But, the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand is what many historians believe to have started the war. On the 28th July 1914, Austria-Hungary declared war on the Serbs....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1217 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on General Douglas Haig

- Within this assessment I will be responding to the question ‘Does General Douglas Haig deserve his reputation as the “Butcher of the Somme?” as a plentiful amount of historians criticise him for why multitudinous soldiers died during the battle of the Somme, essentially due to his poor battle plan, but alongside every event there is two sides to what has happened. The battle of the Somme arose because the British and French armies were required to relive German pressure off the French town of Verdun as well as gaining an expansion of territory....   [tags: The Butcher of the Somme]

Better Essays
1134 words (3.2 pages)

General Haig a Butcher not War Hero Essay

- Sir Douglas Haig was born on the 19th June 1861. The Field Marshal was very highly ranked in the duration of The Great War. Haig was a British soldier and a senior Commander of The British Expeditionary Force from the year of 1915. General Haig is notorious for commanding the Battle Of The Somme and also renowned for the third battle of Ypres and various other victories leading to The Triple Entente’s victory of WW1. After the war, Haig was made an Earl and also received gratified thanks from both Houses of Parliament....   [tags: World War I WWI WW1 Sir Douglas Haig]

Better Essays
1265 words (3.6 pages)

Defining Field Marshal General Sir Douglas Haig Essay

- Defining Field Marshal General Sir Douglas Haig Haig was a technical innovator; Haig was an old fashioned fool. Haig was a brilliant strategist; Haig was ignorant. Haig was a great man; Haig was hardly a man. Haig was easily the best man for the job; Haig was obviously the only man left for the job. All these views are shared by different people about Haig, in my essay I will put forward my views about Haig and justifications by referring to the facts....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
819 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on Sir Douglas Haig

- Intro - Sir Douglas Haig was born in Edinburgh on June 19, 1861, and educated at Clifton and Brasenose College in oxford. Haig was a career soldier but had been given job of commander in chief of the British Expeditionary force recently after he had first battle of Ypres and at Mons. To start off with there is much evidence which suggests that Haig was an uncaring general for example on the one hand Haig was called the butcher of Somme & he deserved this given nickname. The reason for that was because Haig had ‘sent men to their deaths’ (1)....   [tags: British History]

Better Essays
950 words (2.7 pages)

General Gouglas Haig Essay

- "A general who wears down 180,000 of the enemy by expending 400,000 men...has something to answer for." This idea from military historian C.E.W Bean is the main line of argument from traditionalist historians. They represent General Douglas Haig, British Commander-in-Chief of the BEF from 1915 to the end of the war in 1918, in a critical, damning light: a hopelessly incompetent general with a willingness to sacrifice the men of Britain for a few metres of muddy ground. On the converse of this interpretation is a revisionist perspective of Haig as a caring ‘architect of victory’, bringing long-term achievements with his perceptive strategies....   [tags: Britain, Commander in Chief, War]

Better Essays
1867 words (5.3 pages)

Field Marshall Sir Douglas Haig Essay

- Field Marshall Sir Douglas Haig In this oral assessment I am going to talk about Field Marshall Sir Douglas Haig, Haig was a war leader in the First World War who led the army on few occasions. One of his most memorable battles was the battle of the Somme; in this battle the allies suffered over 2 million causalities and over 500,000 deaths. We may have won the battle and the war, but at a huge cost. In this assessment I am going to try arguing the case that Haig was a fool who cost the lives of too many British soldiers....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
984 words (2.8 pages)

General Douglas MacArthur Essay examples

- General Douglas MacArthur General Douglas MacArthur is one of the United States' most popular and accomplished generals. He is mostly known for being the commander of all Allied forces in the Pacific theater during World War II. His life was a spectacular rise and tragic fall. He was one of the United States' greatest leaders of all time. He lived his entire life living by the West Point code of Duty, Honor, and Country. Douglas Macarthur was born on January 26th, 1880 in Little Rock, Arkansas (Kelley 35)....   [tags: US Army General Biography]

Free Essays
955 words (2.7 pages)

General Haig's Background and Military Experience Essay

- General Haig's Background and Military Experience General Haig is one of the most important men in world war history, made famous for his tactics of the battle of the Somme, where thousands of soldiers died, apparently needlessly. In this question, I will be looking into Haig's life, and how it shaped him into the army leader in 1915. [IMAGE]Text Box: Haig at private school in 1887. He is at the extreme left of the back row. Haig was born in 1862, the youngest of eleven children, to a rich family that had made their money out of whiskey....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
2547 words (7.3 pages)