In order to answer the main essay question on whether or not Field
Marshall Haig was the Butcher of the Somme I will include points for
and against and also quotes to sum up and give a complete answer on my
opinion of Field Marshall Haig.
When field Marshall Haig was appointed commander of the British
forces, he was 54 years old. Before this time Haig had had a long and
successful career in the military and 15 years previous he had been a
celebrated Calvary commander in the Boer war.
Haig believed that the only way you could win a battle was through
Even though hundreds and thousands of men had been killed, in December
1915, the western front was still stalemate. It was debated as to how
well the British army was being led and in the same month, a new
commander was appointed, General Haig.
However experienced Haig was, he now encountered an even worse and
more complex problem – trench warfare. Since generals had no idea of
how to fight against trench warfare they simply used methods of
fighting and tactics that they had used in past wars.
General Haig used the same plans for this war that he had devised for
the battle of Nueve Chapelle. Haig’s plans were very thorough and used
as much intelligence that was available at the time. He used aerial
observation, photography, ground patrols and interrogation of
Haig’s plan was to-
1. Begin with an artillery bombardment to destroy the German barbed
wire in front of their trenches.
2. Then there would be a mass infantry attack over No Man’s land on
the German tren...
... middle of paper ...
...ajority of the soldiers
were new and had absolutely no idea about the state of affairs they
were going to go through, nor were they trained for an event this
intense. After Haig had been in many wars and fought for most of his
life I believe that the amount of training he gave the troops was poor
and inadequate for a man of his experience. The men were simply led on
false pretences and made to believe that the war wasn’t going to be
that bad, whereas if Haig had made it worse than he knew it was going
to be then they would have displayed better fighting qualities and
would have been fully prepared.
Another focal point that suggests against Haig; is that even when it
was clear that his plan wasn’t working he stuck to it and didn’t think
about trying to change his ideas to suit the new type of trench
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- ... I don't think he knew what a trench was like. And they made him an Earl and gave him £100,000. I know what I'd have given him.’ The source has clearly showed how Haig treats his soldiers – stay 50 kilometers away the front line and giving commands when he is feeling good. Alongside Fred, David Lloyd George, British Prime Minister during the First World War, writing in his War Memoirs (1935) had mentioned that ‘Haig was a second-rate Commander in unparalleled and unforeseen circumstances... He was not endowed with any of the elements of imagination and vision ...... [tags: WWI military casualties, Battle of Somme]
1320 words (3.8 pages)
- Haig's Reputation as the Butcher of the Somme In the run up to the war, Field Marshal Sir Douglas Haig was appointed the Director of Military Training. In an effort to create a reserve standard army which could double up as a 'home front' defence force, plus a fighting unit for use abroad, he managed to achieve this by pushing for legislation that lead to the creation of the TA (Territory Army) and the BEF (British Expeditionary Force) which were to be later used in the war effort in the 'war to end all wars'.... [tags: Papers]
653 words (1.9 pages)
- Field Marshall Haig Sir Douglas Haig replaced Sir John French as commander of the British army. He faced many problems from the state French had left the army in. He faced the task of planning battles and training his army. His tactics were first put to the test at the Battle of the Somme in 1916 and the casualties began to rise into unacceptable numbers. The British army put their faith into Haig because of his reputation as a great leader. He had had past success' during the Boer War in South Africa, were some of his tactics proved to be very successful.... [tags: Papers]
706 words (2 pages)
- Field Marshall Sir Douglas Haig In this oral assessment I am going to talk about Field Marshall Sir Douglas Haig, Haig was a war leader in the First World War who led the army on few occasions. One of his most memorable battles was the battle of the Somme; in this battle the allies suffered over 2 million causalities and over 500,000 deaths. We may have won the battle and the war, but at a huge cost. In this assessment I am going to try arguing the case that Haig was a fool who cost the lives of too many British soldiers.... [tags: Papers]
984 words (2.8 pages)
- Haig As a Leader I think Haig was a bad leader who made many critical mistakes during the battle of Passchendaele. From looking at the sources I can see many bad views of Haig as a war leader, although some good views can also be detected. In source A it is evident that Haig always ensured that his army was well equipped by asking the War Cabinet for more ammunition. I also know that Haig was one of the first generals to pay attention to aerial intelligence, this was very good for Britain as it put them at an advantage over many countries.... [tags: Papers]
1508 words (4.3 pages)
- Evaluation of the Battle of the Somme World War 1 started in 1914 and lasted for four years. There were many causes for the World War and many thought it been coming for a very long time. There was a growing tension between France and Germany over land and border lines. Also, Kaiser Wilhelm, theGerman leader, wanted to prove how powerful he thought the Germans were. But, the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand is what many historians believe to have started the war. On the 28th July 1914, Austria-Hungary declared war on the Serbs.... [tags: Papers]
1217 words (3.5 pages)
- The Battle of the Somme as a Victory for the British This investigation seeks to evaluate the level of success for the British in the Battle of the Somme in 1916 and analyse whether this battle was really a "victory" for the British or not. The main body of this investigation outlines what happened to the British army in The Battle of the Somme in 1916, with references to many sources. The battle is then analysed to see to extent was it a victory for the British and to what extent it wasn't, with importance on the country and the army.... [tags: Papers]
1279 words (3.7 pages)
- Haig as an Efficient and Highly Skilled Soldier During the First World War, Field Marshall Haig was a military leader from Britain. Throughout the war and soon afterwards his reputation had labelled him as a successful hero. However, over the years after the war people began to reflect on the horrors of the war and how soldiers had to suffer due to Haig's order. Haig was given a name as 'the butcher of the Somme' because he had caused numerous deaths which were avoidable.... [tags: Papers]
1116 words (3.2 pages)
- Field Marshal sir Douglas Haig as The Butcher Of The Somme Sir Douglas Haig was appointed Field Marshal of the British Army in 1915, as no progress had been made since 1914, when the First World War began. Trench warfare was introduced for the first time. Much of the nature of the fighting taking place in the First World War was alien to Haig and his Generals, a cavalry man who served with distinction during the second Boer War. In February 1916 the Germans attacked Verdun again, the French were desperate and near to surrendering, the British desperately needed to relieve the pressure on the French.... [tags: Papers]
756 words (2.2 pages)
- Field Marshal Sir Douglas Haig: War hero or butcher of the Somme. Many historians see the Somme as one of, if not the most, significant events of the war. The devastating casualties and deaths of the war left thousands without their loved ones, a whole generation was lost at the Somme. After the devastation of the war, many soldiers blamed Haig. It was thought that Haig's leadership was to blame for the tremendous amount of casualties and deaths of the Somme. The soldiers were thought to have followed their orders courageously, precisely and so that everything went exactly as planned, but they were let down by their leaders.... [tags: Papers]
710 words (2 pages)