Effectiveness of Punishment and Prisons Essays

Effectiveness of Punishment and Prisons Essays

Length: 1845 words (5.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Effectiveness of Punishment and Prisons

Studies of the effectiveness of punishments often use reconviction
rates as a measurement of success or failure. According to fairly
recent reports there are currently no real differences between
reconviction rates for custodial and all community penalties (Home
Affairs Committee, 1998, Home Office, 1998). However, there are many
problems associated with the reliability of such data, and much
caution is needed when using such measurements as a criteria for
assessing the effectiveness of punishment. For instance, there is
much disagreement about what reconviction should be counted. For
community penalties the counting began on the date of sentence whereas
for custodial sentences the counting begins on the date of release
(May, 1994). therefore, does not take
into account any offence committed whilst in prison. On the
other hand, there is no way of knowing how far re-offending whilst
serving a community sentence is due to the ineffectiveness of the
punishment or an individuals social circumstance. The 1998 report by
the Home Affairs Committee draws attention to even more concerns
regarding reconviction rates. It is stated that:

“Reconviction rates take any subsequent reconviction as an indication
of failure and do not take into account changes in offence severity or
a reduction in the frequency of offending; Reconviction rates
under-estimate the true level of re-offending since for many types of
offence the clear up rate is very low; Police Forces have varying
clear up rates which reflect differences in the changes of being
arrested and re-convict...

... middle of paper ...


Home Office (1998) Prison Statistics England and Wales 1998, London:

Hood, R. G and Sparks, R.F. (1970) Keys issues in criminology, London:
Weidenfeld and Nicolson.

Hood, R (1992) Race and Sentencing: A study in the Crown Court, Oxford:
Clarendon Press.

May, T. (1994) ‘Probation and Community Sanctions’, in Maguire. et al
(eds) The Oxford Handbook Of Criminology, 1st ed. Oxford: Clarendon

McLaughlin, E and Muncie, J. (1996) Controlling Crime, London: Sage.

Vass, A. (1990) Alternatives to Prison, Custody and the Community,
London: Sage.

Wilson, D and Ashton, J. (1998) What every one in Britain should know
about Crime and Punishment, London: Blackstone Press.

Worall, A (1997) Punishment in the Community: The future of Criminal
Justice, Harlow: Addison Wesley Longman.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Effectiveness of U.S. and Scandinavian Penal and Prisons Systems

- Joe is a prisoner in a United States penitentiary convicted of assault with a deadly weapon and attempted robbery. Johan is a prisoner in a Norwegian Correctional Facility also convicted of assault with a deadly weapon and attempted robbery. After eight years of serving their time in custody, they are released back out into society, the world beyond their prison walls. During the following month after their release, Joe has once again been arrested for assault and attempted robbery while Johan has started making a quiet living as a deckhand on the coast for a small fishing company in Kopervik....   [tags: Prisons Systems]

Strong Essays
3052 words (8.7 pages)

It's Time to Privatize Colombian’s Prisons Essay

- The involvement of the private sector in the penal system, prima facie, could be seen as a rapid and low cost, high benefit solution to the most serious penal system problems such as lack of prisons spaces, poor condition within the prisons, and the state responsibilities of running prisons services adequately, by the figure of prison privatization. (Cavadino, M. and Dignan, J. 2007) The figure of contracting out has been well described by Cavadino and Dignan in their analysis of the prison privatization....   [tags: Private Prisons]

Strong Essays
2574 words (7.4 pages)

The Effectiveness of Prison Education Rehabilitation Essay

- ... Although problems still exist, Education can target the most prevalent ones reaching to the root of the problem. Pont makes a very startling point, “Prisons today reek of idleness” (23). The old saying that goes, “Idle hands are the devil’s workshop” can aptly apply to prisoners with nothing to do. Inmates should have the resources, abilities, and encouragement, to get their minds off their past life and channel it into a productive task. “Prison Studies Project”, a program that is working toward education and police change, deduces the following, “Prison education is far more effective at reducing recidivism than boot camps, “shock” incarceration, or vocational training, according to th...   [tags: solving illiteracy rates in US prisons]

Strong Essays
1620 words (4.6 pages)

Capital Punishment in the United States Essay

- Capital punishment has been a controversial topic in association to ethics all of its existence. Issues pertaining to the execution methods, reasonability in the relationship of punishment to the crime, who receives the death penalty, and innocence have been discussed and researched in great lengths. Capital punishment is still an active form of “deterrence” in the United States for crimes considered the worst of the worst. In this paper I will discuss the history of the death penalty. I will also disclose information on the dynamics of race, method, and court cases valid to the death penalty....   [tags: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty]

Strong Essays
2008 words (5.7 pages)

Capital Punishment: An Ongoing Arguement Essay example

- Since the year 1608, over 15,269 people have been executed in the United States and its predecessor colonies (Smykla, and Espy). With the multitude of persons executed, there is still little evidence proving the effectiveness of capital punishment when concerning future violent crime rates. The death penalty is also costly when compared to the cost of imprisoning a violent criminal for life. With such a definitive punishment and with its finality, there have also been a large number of persons executed who were in fact shown to be innocent at a later time....   [tags: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty]

Strong Essays
1042 words (3 pages)

Essay on Effectiveness of Criminals on Parole

- INTRODUCTION Probation is something or a release of an offender from detention. If you are on probation they will be supervised by a parole officer that keeps up with what the criminal is doing. People on Probation can get off by good behavior and by doing what’s right. Using probation and parole, Is for a good use only nothing bad unless your behavior is bad. Probations and Parole is such a great use to the U.S because it has good alternatives, keeps people out of trouble, and sometimes changes people lifestyle....   [tags: probation, forms of punishment]

Strong Essays
914 words (2.6 pages)

Prison Overcrowding in California Essay

- Introduction The proliferation of prison overcrowding has been a rising concern for the U.S. The growing prison population poses considerable health and safety risks to prison staffs and employees, as well as to inmates themselves. The risks will continue to increase if no immediate actions are taken. Whereas fighting proliferation is fundamentally the duty of the U.S. government, prison overcrowding has exposed that the U.S. government will need to take measures to combat the flaws in the prison and criminal justice system....   [tags: proliferation, penal codes, effectiveness, budget]

Strong Essays
2479 words (7.1 pages)

House Arrest with Electronic Monitoring Essay

- My topic is based on house arrest (HA) with electronic monitoring (EM) and I will be arguing in favour of it being an alternative to confinement. This alternative method is reliable, lenient, efficient, and effective. It is reliable because it is a valid option for offenders who committed less severe crimes, leaving more space in prison for serious offenders. After all, there is a growing concern of jails getting overcrowded, meaning more offenders are under custody in one institution that requires more supervision....   [tags: confinement, efficiency, crime, cost effectiveness]

Strong Essays
1752 words (5 pages)

Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Prison System Essay

- The failure of imprisonment has been one of the most noticeable features of the current crisis in criminal justice systems. At best, prisons are able to provide a form of crude retribution to those unfortunate to be apprehended. At worst, prisons are brutalizing, cannot be shown to rehabilitate or deter offenders, and are detrimental to the re-entry of offenders into society. If anything, they do little else than confine most prisoners, and as a result lead to the imposition of certain undesirable learning habits and labels....   [tags: Prison Jail Correctional Facility Crime]

Strong Essays
1803 words (5.2 pages)

Prisons Essay

- Prisons an institution designed to securely house people who have been convicted of crimes. These people are known as prisoners or inmates and are kept in an ongoing custody for a certain amount of time. The type of crime decides the length of the sentence. For some such crimes (i.e. murder) individuals may be sentenced to a lifetime imprisonment. In order for an individual to be incarcerated, they have to be accused of violating criminal law and then tried and found convicted in a jury of their peers....   [tags: History Prisons]

Free Essays
1918 words (5.5 pages)