Comparison of Three First World War Poems Essay

Comparison of Three First World War Poems Essay

Length: 1164 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Good Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Comparison of Three First World War Poems

The three poems that I will be studying in this essay are “Dulce Et
Decorum Est” by Wilfred Owen, “Comrades: An Episode” by Robert Nichols
and “Who’s For The Game?” by Jessie Pope. These poems are about the
First World War and two of them seem to have a negative attitude
criticising and downgrading the so-called spectacular experience of
the First World War. In “Dulce Et Decorum Est” Wilfred Owen seems to
mention good aspects of the War but compares them to low-class tragic
events. In “Comrades: An Episode” Robert Nichols describes the event
of a soldier being badly injured and eventually dying. It describes
what the corporals and soldiers did and how they reacted to the
situation. However, Jessie Pope’s poem “Who’s For the Game?” talks
about war as if it is a joke and the scary aspect of the war is taken

In each poem a different picture emerges in one’s head. In “Dulce Et
Decorum Est” similes are used quite regularly to create dreamlike
settings and haunting images that provide a vivid picture of the
realities of warfare. To the general public soldiers were seen as
heroes but the first line of this poem ruins that image by describing
the soldiers as

“Bent double, like old beggars under sacks”.

This line creates a grim image of the soldiers portraying them to be
weak and helpless. Other similes are used to create a similar effect
in this poem. Another line, which relates to a soldier, is

“His hanging face, like a devil’s sick of sin”

Which shows how fed up and emotionally tired this particular soldier
must ...

... middle of paper ...

...motionally and most likely
physically scared. The war should be known for its true meaning and
not the fake outside look of it. The poem “Who’s for the game?” is has
the opposite view to these poems. War is described as a game, just a
bit of fun and that if all these lucky men who have the opportunity to
go, in fact don’t go, they will be missing out. There is also a bit of
guilt in this poem, it is at the end. By mentioning the trouble that
their country is in, it makes men who have not joined feel bad that
they have let their country down and be led to such a bad state. When
men thought this, they automatically thought that they have to help
and mend what has gone terribly wrong. I find all three poems
extremely interesting because of all the different approaches taken to
get their point across and their ideas heard.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparison Of Wilfred Owen 's Poems ' 1914 ' And ' Dulce Et Decorum Est '

- Two Sides of One Coin The biggest and I think only main difference between Wilfred Owen’s poems “1914” and “Dulce Et Decorum Est”, (written in 1917) is that in “1914” Wilfred point of view is from a citizen’s stand point and in “Dulce Et Decorum Est”, Wilfred’s point of view as a solider in the British army in the Great War. In “1914” Wilfred Owen wrote about how the Great War broke out and how once it did from the beginning it caused great destruction and darkness to hit the countries that were involved....   [tags: World War I, World War II, Chlorine]

Good Essays
851 words (2.4 pages)

War Poems Comparison Essay

- “Poetry is boned with ideas, nerved and blooded with emotions, all held together by the delicate, tough skin of words”. Here American poet Paul Engle manages to unveil the crux of poems underneath the stanzas, lines and technicalities- the emotions. The strength of the poem depends on the weaknesses portrayed by the poets’ personas because ultimately the easiest way to control one is to tug a little at their heartstrings. No one has conquered hearts with a gaudy show of strength. Hence, emotive language is a weapon of great effect if wielded correctly, which the poets of the six poems mentioned execute successfully....   [tags: Paul Engle, Carol Ann Duffy]

Good Essays
1792 words (5.1 pages)

The Attitudes to the First World War in Poetry Essay

- The Attitudes to the First World War in Poetry Compare and contrast the attitudes to the First World War in the poetry you have read. Focus in detail on four poems, two of which should be by the same author. When the war started the general feeling of the English was that the war was great and would be over before Christmas. This is evident in much of the early war poetry. As the war progressed, however, people began to feel disillusioned and eventually had an overwhelming feeling of futility in that so many lives were wasted for such little gain....   [tags: Poetry World War Poems Poets Essays]

Free Essays
2623 words (7.5 pages)

Essay on The Dreadful And Glorious Aspects Of War

- Much of Wilfred Owen’s poetry in the collection World War One British Poets is of a morbid nature, emphasizing the terrible reality of war, the death, the destruction, the ruined lives that are its aftermath. The poem Apologia Pro Poemate Meo represents a unique expression of the fundamental paradox of man’s experience of warfare. This essay will address the dichotomy of the awful and glorious aspects of war in the poems of Wilfred Owen. There is a stark contrast between Apologia Pro Poemate Meo and the other poems Owen wrote about The Great War....   [tags: World War I, World War II, Poetry]

Good Essays
828 words (2.4 pages)

The Portrayal of War in the Poems, The Cry of South Africa and Drummer Hodge

- Thomas Hardy (2 June 1840 – 11 January 1928) was an English author who considered himself mainly as a poet. A large part of his work was set mainly in the semi-fictional land of Wessex. In 1898 Hardy published a collection of poems written over 30 years, Wessex Poems his first volume of poetry. Emma Lavinia Gifford, Hardy’s wife, whom he married in 1874. He became alienated from his wife, who died in 1912; her death had a traumatic effect on him. He remained preoccupied with his first wife's death and tried to overcome his sorrow by writing poetry, he dictated his final poem to his first wife on his deathbed....   [tags: Poetry Analysis, Poem Comparison]

Good Essays
735 words (2.1 pages)

Theme of War in The Sorrow of Sarajevo by Goran Simic and Duke et Decroum by Wilfred Own

- ... It also has short and simple sentences but therefor very effective. This specific structure is used to mirror. Each stanza in this poem focuses on different aspects of war equally as “Dulce et Decorum”. The first stanza concentrates on sorrow and horror. The second stanza describes the struggle between life and death in Sarajevo. The third stanza illustrates the death of innocence. The fourth stanza depicts the lasting trauma of the siege. Whilst on the other hand “Dulce et Decorum” is also composed of 4 stanzas and uses enjambment, but the sentences are longer and more detailed....   [tags: horror, mistake, poems, war]

Good Essays
950 words (2.7 pages)

A Comparison of World War I Poetry Essay

- Literature and poetry are a reflection of society. The words are reflected in numerous feelings that we can almost touch and can be deeply felt in its reach. Most poets expressed their perception and emotion through their writings. Unfortunately the art and poetry describes one of the worst things that human can do to one another. The legalized murder called "war." Hence, this type of self-reflection called "poetry" has help create new fundamental ideas and values towards our society. In this essay, I will discuss the issue of the "War Poetry" during the "Great War" along with comparing and contrasting two talented renowned poets; Wilfred Owen (1893-1918) and Siegfried Sassoon (1886-1967)....   [tags: Comparative Literature]

Good Essays
2101 words (6 pages)

Comparison of Emily Dickinson Poems Essay

- Emily Dickinson’s poems, “I” and “VIII”, are both three verses long and convey the irony and anguish of the world in different ways. By paraphrasing each of Dickinson’s poems, “I” and “VIII”, similarities and differences between the two become apparent. Putting the poem into familiar language makes it easier to comprehend. “I” and “VIII” are easier to understand after they have been translated into everyday language. In main concept of the first verse of “I” is that success is valued most by those who never succeed and that fruit tastes sweeter to those that are hungry....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
750 words (2.1 pages)

Wilfred Owen's Poetry and War Essay

- Wilfred Owen's Poetry and War Wilfred Owen is now seen as one of the most important of the many poets of the First World War. He was born the son of a railway worker in Shropshire, and educated at schools in Shrewsbury and Liverpool. His devoted mother encouraged his early interests in music and poetry. When he could not afford a university education, he went abroad to teach English in France. He was there when war broke out in 1914, and decided to return to England to volunteer for the army. After training, he became an officer and was sent to France at the end of 1916, seeing service first in the Somme sector....   [tags: Wilfred Owen Poetry Poems War Essays]

Good Essays
2646 words (7.6 pages)

Comparison of Odyssey, Divine Comedy, and Paradise Lost Essay examples

- A Comparison of Odyssey, Divine Comedy, and Paradise Lost      Epics by definition are long narrative poems, that are grand in both theme and style (Webster 417).  They usually involve actions of great glory and are typically centered around historical or legendary events of universal significance.  Most epics deal with the deeds of a single individual, however, it is not uncommon to have more than one main character.  Epics embody several main features including: supernatural forces, sometimes the deity of the time, that shape the action; battles or other forms of physical combat; and a formal statement of the theme of the epic.  Everyday details of life are commonpla...   [tags: comparison compare contrast compody]

Good Essays
1092 words (3.1 pages)