A Comparison of The Purloined Letter and The Black Cat Essay

A Comparison of The Purloined Letter and The Black Cat Essay

Length: 1121 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A Comparison of The Purloined Letter and The Black Cat

In this essay I will be comparing the two short stories, 'The
Purloined Letter' & 'The Black Cat'.

The Purloined Letter is about a detective (Dupin) who is asked by the
Parisian Police prefect over a Purloined Letter. An eminent minister
has stolen an important letter and it contains information that can be
dangerous for an important individual. No one can find the letter even
though knowing who has it. Dupin has had past history with the
minister, the motivation to get revenge and also Dupin's superior
intelligence helps Dupin to recover the letter.

On the other hand The Black Cat has a totally different story line.
The Black Cat is about the narrators downfall into madness and
murderous violence, his love for animals changing into hate, which is
all fuelled by alcoholism.

After the narrator murders his cat, he has a lot of guilt on his
shoulders. Having so much guilt he finally finds a replacement cat,
which looks similar to his old cat but has a spooky factor to it. The
spooky cat is the result of the narrator's downfall at the end, when
he ends up murdering his wife. The spooky cat gets its revenge when
the police, for the murder of his wife, catch the narrator.

The two stories, which have hardly anything in common story wise, have
some similarities in some aspects of the stories.

First of all, looking at both of the stories plots you can see they
are two completely different short stories. The Black Cat and the
Purloined Letter have a lot of plots, which is probably the only
similarity between both of the stories. The Black Cat has a violent,
murderous plot ...


... middle of paper ...


...e Purloined Letter all each have a characteristic,
which builds up the detective type story, which is mostly about
mystery. On the other hand The Black Cats characters give the story a
more disturbing and haunting vibe.

There are no real similarities between any of the two stories
characters. Except maybe the mysteriousness of the Cat could be
compared to Dupin's mysteriousness. Also both of these characters have
vengeance on their minds.

I think that both stories are good, but do not hold hardly any major
similarities between each other. This is probably because The Black
Cat is a horror and a faster paced story, while The Purloined Letter
is more slow and intellectual. Maybe the only main things that are in
both stories and are similar is probably the mystery in both of the
stories and the thirst for revenge.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Iago Vs. Moriarty: an Argumentative Comparison

- In William Shakespeare’s Othello, the antagonist Iago shows evil motivations towards the protagonist Othello that could be considered obsessive. This pattern of behavior can be compared to the BBC television rendition of Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes and its antagonist Moriarty. Iago and Moriarty’s obsessive behavior greatly effect Othello and Sherlock’s lives respectively that provide a solid argumentative comparison between the two. William Shakespeare’s Othello presents and “evil” character, Iago, who can be compared to the Arthur Conan Doyle TV adaption of BBC Sherlock’s Moriarty....   [tags: Othello, Sherlock Holmes, BBC]

Strong Essays
1370 words (3.9 pages)

The Black Cat By Edgar Poe Essay

- “The Black Cat”, written by Edgar A. Poe, has been called “one of the most powerful of Poe’s stories” with a horrific element that just barely “stops short of the wavering line of disgust”. Originally published in 1843 in the United States Saturday Post, this Gothic tale is perhaps also one of Poe’s most extensively analyzed pieces. (Cambell33) Much diversity is seen in the interpretations offered. The black cats are variously conceptualized as symbolic of the narrator’s wife, manifesting the supernatural, representing the narrator’s “intemperance and lost docility”, and reflecting some rapidly diminishing noble facet of the tale-teller’s character or conscience....   [tags: Edgar Allan Poe, Gothic fiction, The Black Cat]

Strong Essays
1419 words (4.1 pages)

Essay on The Black Cat, By Edgar Allan Poe

- In Edgar Allan Poe 's "The Black Cat,” symbolism is used to show the narrator 's capacity for violence, madness, and guilt. "The Black Cat,” written by Edgar Allan Poe serves as a reminder for all of us. But In his early years, the narrator seems like any other man. He falls in love, marries that special girl, and they decide to get a few pets. Some of these pets appear to be quite unusual, but they seem happy and therefore to each his own. They end up with birds, goldfish, a dog, rabbits, and a black cat....   [tags: Edgar Allan Poe, The Black Cat]

Strong Essays
1393 words (4 pages)

The Black Cat By Edgar Allan Poe Essay

- In short story “The Black Cat” by Edgar Allan Poe, symbolism serves as a powerful vehicle towards the grander theme. Poe uses the second black cats as a symbol for guilt to convey the theme that one cannot avoid guilt because shame and conviction will always follow a person until justice is reconciled. The black cat with the white mark represents what happens when conviction creeps into one’s life and becomes so unbearable that guilt will temporarily disappear only to return with a ravishing hunger for justice....   [tags: Edgar Allan Poe, The Black Cat, Shame, Guilt]

Strong Essays
962 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on The Black Cat, By Edgar Allen Poe

- Edgar Allen Poe is well-known for having characters and narrators in his story that are insane like he has in “The Black Cat.” Gothic scholar Jerrold Hogle has stated, “No other form of writing or theatre is as insistent as Gothic on juxtaposing potential revolution and possible reaction - about gender, sexuality, race, class, the colonizers versus the colonized, the physical versus the metaphysical, and abnormal versus normal psychology - and leaving both extremes sharply before us and far less resolved than the conventional endings in most of these works claim them to be.” The short story explores the extremes of abnormal versus normal psychology through the influence of the supernatural,...   [tags: Edgar Allan Poe, Short story, The Black Cat]

Strong Essays
1673 words (4.8 pages)

Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Black Cat” Essay example

- In Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Black Cat” Afracanist presence as defined by Toni Morrison asserts itself through the narrator while transforming him from a tender kindhearted person into one who allows perverseness to take over. This type of presence allows the reader to witness the dark undertone and the hidden messages that lie within the text. In order to effectively show the narrators transformation and how his actions allow Afracanist presence to be presented, Poe uses two cats, one of which is completely black while the other resembles the first but instead has white fur covering the region of its breast....   [tags: Edgar Allan Poe, The Black Cat]

Strong Essays
862 words (2.5 pages)

Edgar Allan Poe 's The Black Cat Essay example

- The Bible claims that all men are born in sin,even though some seem to be born pure and just. Yet how we are born does not reflect our decisions later in life. It is possible, and more favorable to live the rest of your life in purity, but some chose to delve deep into the pit of sin, allowing for body and mind to be consumed. As life began for the narrator of Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Black Cat” he became a docile and humane man with a love of animals and people alike. After years of slowly succumbing to a reliance on alcohol, he destroys his and his wives lives in a series of events caused by his large cat Pluto....   [tags: Edgar Allan Poe, The Black Cat]

Strong Essays
1118 words (3.2 pages)

The Black Cat - Abnormal Madness Essay

- The  Black Cat - Abnormal Madness It seems that almost every Edgar Allen Poe story ever written has a much deeper and darker meaning hidden inside its lines. Many of these pieces are demented enough even if the reader does not read "between the lines." "The Black Cat" is an example of this kind of story. In this morbid look into the narrator's mind, the reader follows the narrator as he does many disturbing things in his household. This story, like many of Poe's other pieces, is a venture into abnormal psychology where the narrator is completely insane, not only because of the horrible things he does to his cat and his wife, but  because of his state...   [tags: Poe The Black Cat Essays]

Free Essays
1191 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on The Importance of Point of View in The Black Cat

- The Importance of Point of View in The Black Cat Point of view is a very important aspect of The Black Cat. The main character tells the story to the reader from his first person point of view. You have a good feel for the story because you have the first person narration. As you read into the story it comes apparent however that the narrator telling the story is not a reliable interpretation of the details around him. You have a good feel for his emotions and the events of the story, but the narrators opinions are so far out that you are forced to wonder just what of the story is the askew interpretation of a madman and what is the reality of the situation....   [tags: The Black Cat Point of View Literature Essays]

Free Essays
1328 words (3.8 pages)

Edgar Allan Poe's The Black Cat Essay

- Edgar Allan Poe's The Black Cat Edgar Allan Poe's "The Black Cat" is a story of how an arguably demonic, manipulating black cat ruins the life of its master. After being maimed and murdered by its once loving owner, the cat is reincarnated and finds its way back to its murderer to seek revenge....   [tags: Edgar Allan Poe Black Cat, remorse]

Strong Essays
1312 words (3.7 pages)