'All's Cheerless, Dark and Deadly' Are Kent's Words a Fair Summary of The Tragedy of King Lear?
Samuel Johnson asserted that the blinding of Gloucester was an 'act too horrid to be endured in a dramatic exhibition', and that he was 'too shocked' by the death of Cordelia to read the play again until he was given the task of editing it.1 Nor was Dr Johnson alone in finding himself unable to stomach the violence and apparent injustices that unfold in King Lear. The 18th century certainly found the play 'all cheerless' and preferred Nahum Tate's 1681 watered-down version of Shakespeare's original.
King Lear is a dark play, with the near triumph of the malcontent Edmund, the intense sufferings of Lear and Gloucester, and the seeming lack of justice at the piece's conclusion. Shakespeare locates his tragedy in an extreme and entropic universe that makes his audience uncomfortable, and indeed is supposed to. On its own, the sheer violence of Act III.7 bears witness to Kent's nihilistic utterance at the plays close. However, Lear's universe, as I have just stated, is one of extremes, and not merely negative ones. As A.C. Bradley notes:
There is in the world of King Lear the same abundance of extreme good as of extreme evil. It generates in profusion self-less devotion and unconquerable love.2
The play contains a cluster of characters that are unequivocally good. Kent, for instance, is a paradigm of devotion. In Act I.I he is publicly insulted and humiliated. In spite of Lear's threats, Kent remains determined to serve his master, even braving the storm to be near him. Cordelia too, is traduced and punished by Lear, and yet she is the...
... middle of paper ...
... condemned to short lives - 'nor live so long'. Edgar's closing words are disturbingly equivocal. They allude to the antithesis constantly at work in the play a mixture of hope and despair. Perhaps the couplet is ultimately nihilistic, and the play as a whole equally so. Redemption remains unattained. However, while I would agree that Kent's words that 'All's cheerless, dark and deadly' may be the overriding message of the tragedy, I do not believe that King Lear can be simply summed up in such a comment. To do such a thing would be to see the drama two-dimensionally to ignore the world of polarities, of good as well as evil, which Shakespeare creates in which to hold his play.
1 Johnson as Critic, ed. John Wain, Routledge & Kegan Paul 1973, pp. 216-217
2 A. C. Bradley, Shakespearian Tragedy, Macmillan 1908, pp. 304 -305
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- All the tragedies in Hamlet were because of a single man and his ambitions, greed and fear, which led him down a dark path. There are seven deadly sins, which all humans have: Wrath, Greed, Sloth, Pride, Lust, Envy and Gluttony. Claudius had three major “sins,” which led him down a dark path, and led him and many other people to their early deaths. His three major “sins” were Envy, Greed and Lust. Claudius’s ambitions, desires and fear are responsible for all the tragedy and chaos in Hamlet. Claudius was always an ambitious person.... [tags: Seven deadly sins, Lust, KILL, Gluttony]
1244 words (3.6 pages)
- The fatal pattern Shakespeare 's The Tragedy of Macbeth, set in Scotland,tells a story of a Scottish general who, afflicted by malicious prophecy, kills the king to claim the throne for himself. Emphasizing the murderous pattern exhibited by Macbeth and his wife, the play tragedizes the devastating consequences of political ambition and murderous intent. The pattern, however, ends with Macduff 's fulfilling of the witches prophecy and claiming Macbeth 's life. This essay aims to explore such pattern by examining the assassination of king Duncan, the attempted murders of Banquo 's sons, and the slaughter of Macduff 's family that would eventually drive the thane to take the life of Macbeth... [tags: Macbeth, KILL, Macduff's son]
1835 words (5.2 pages)
- The Sin of Pride Exposed in King Lear, and The Duchess of Malfi In this brief monograph, we shall be hunting down and examining various creatures from the bestiary of Medieval/Renaissance thought. Among these are the fierce lion of imperious, egotistical power, a pair of fantastic peacocks, one of vanity, one of preening social status, and the docile lamb of humility. The lion and the peacocks are of the species known as pride, while the lamb is of an entirely different, in fact antithetical race, that of humility and forgiveness.... [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]
1555 words (4.4 pages)
- The supernatural was a popular element in many of the plays written in Shakespeare's time (including Hamlet) and everyone of Shakespeare's time found the supernatural fascinating. Even King James I took a special interest in supernatural and written a book, Daemonologie, on witchcraft. It must be remembered that, in Shakespeare's day, supernatural referred to things that were "above Nature"; things which existed, but not part of the normal human life and unexplainable. The play Macbeth involves many supernatural actions that act as a catalyst for suspense and thrill, insight into character, foreshadowing of future events as well as making connections with the theme.... [tags: European Literature]
858 words (2.5 pages)
- William Shakespeare The Globe William Shakespeare was one of the most famous play writers of all time. He was born in Stratford-upon-Avon in England more than four hundred years ago. At the young age of eighteen Shakespeare wedd a woman by the name of Anne Hathaway whom was eight years older than him. Together they had a daughter called Susanna and twins Hamnet and Judith. Shakespeare decided to start travelling and to go to London. Luckily for Shakespeare just before he went to London, theatres had been opened for travelling actors for they weren’t respected and a man by the name of James Burbage wanted to change that.... [tags: English Literature]
798 words (2.3 pages)
- William Shakespeare's Macbeth The bard of Avon, William Shakespeare, wrote the great tragedy Macbeth in 1606 and has come to be known as the cursed Scottish play as there were many mishaps during its production. This dark tale was written as a favour to please the new king, King JamesI, as he was intrigued by witchcraft and tales of the supernatural. The plays theme fell greatly on the king as it featured King James’s ancestor Banquo. Macbeth has a dark and evil theme to it as it is steeped in themes such as supernatural, manipulating and most importantly deadly ambition.... [tags: Papers]
863 words (2.5 pages)
- The Greatest Villain In William Shakespeare's Macbeth The word villain can be used today as both serious and comical. For example there are mad villains in cartoons and theatre for example the wicked step mother in the play Cinderella are not particularly serious. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Then you go to serious and sinister acts of crime like paid murders (Assassins and Hit men). These people benefit in payment for their acts of crime.... [tags: Papers]
659 words (1.9 pages)
- The Selfish King in Shakespeare's King Lear In Shakespeare's King Lear a king is stripped of his land, wealth, soldiers, and all of his power because he is stubborn, egocentric, and unkind. Other than losing money and power he loses his three daughters as well. Lear?s pride is so overwhelming that he is unwilling to allow anyone to contradict him. If anyone (besides his fool) even remotely hints that his actions were wrong he gets unnecessarily enraged.... [tags: King Lear William Shakespeare Tragedies]
1012 words (2.9 pages)
- Examining the Three Deaths in William Shakespeare's Macbeth I will show how Shakespeare makes us feel horror pity and fear by examining three of the deaths in the play. These are the three main components to any tragedy, dating back to the ancient Greek tragedies. I will look at the murder of King Duncan and that of Banquo as well as the killing of young Macduff and his mother. The play was Macbeth was probably first performed in front of King James at Hampton Court Palace in 1606; six centuries after the birth of the real Macbeth on whose life the play is loosely based.... [tags: Papers]
1586 words (4.5 pages)
- Gertrude never seems to get in the middle of Hamlet and Claudius' disputes, so many tend to assume that she is involved in King Hamlet's murder. However, there is an abundance of in-text evidence that suggests she is very innocent and oblivious to Claudius' plots throughout the play. Most of this evidence supporting that Gertrude has nothing to do with King Hamlet's sudden death. From the start, Gertrude comes off as a very clueless and almost blind character to the things happening around her.... [tags: essays research papers]
795 words (2.3 pages)