Comparing the Modern Organizational Theory and Improvisation Essay

Comparing the Modern Organizational Theory and Improvisation Essay

Length: 1119 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

"Organization theory deals with the formal structure, internal working, and external environment of complex human behavior within organizations. As a field spanning several disciplines, it prescribes how work and workers out to be organized and attempts to explain the actual consequences of organizational behavior (including individual behavior) on work done and on the organization itself."(Gordon and Milkavoich, 147) It has been evolving for centuries on how should work be done in the public administration and how the organization should be. "Research findings have emerged about what motivates workers and how different incentives affect various tasks, employees, and situations; and the environments in which they operate." (Gordon and Milakovich, 147) Even with all those research statistics and different modes of thought toward organization there are still situations in which the rational approach to public decisions does not help. For instance, what if the environment is instable and has no guidelines or precedents to follow? In the case of Israel, improvisation has changed the organization of public administrations, uprooted the conventional models for policymaking, and strayed off from the Weberian model of administration. This kind of improvisation is the product of "cultural and personal predilections and environmental circumstances,"(Sharkansky and Zalmanovitch, 1)
The use of improvisation is dependent on the culture and the environment in which policy decisions are made. For example, the use of improvisation is found more so in Spanish managers. Why? "Spanish mangers express an explicit preference for spontaneous, improvised managerial style over the methodical and formal planning favored by their American, Eng...


... middle of paper ...


... from the inability to implement policy, or itself be the policy, as in the case of building housing quickly for immigrants. It can be guided by an overriding vision." (Sharkansky and Zalmanovitch, 7)
Improvisation has the ability to arrive to conclusions or actions in an expedient and ingenious way when there are no other alternatives available. It is a means of avoiding stagnation. It is useful when there is uncertainty, few precedents, reliable resources or protocols, few facts and suitable routines; "when there is little way of evaluating the relative efficacy of the various alternatives; and when there is pressure to act in a short time or with resources that appear to be sufficient. Modern organizational theory can only go so far to solve public administrative problems, but with creative thinking such as improvising more can be done for the community.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Organisational Behavioural Theories

- ... Having studied about the faulty in the current system of late1800s, Taylor developed the scientific methods which included clear division of tasks and responsibility between managers and workers, scientific selection of the person to do the job, training of the workers by using scientific method and the close supervision of the workers through the use of hierarchies of authority(Buchanan et Huczynski ,2010) Taylor believed that the workers were motivated by the money so that he used financial incentive to motivate the workers who can perform the best output on the quantity and quality....   [tags: scientific management, modern organization]

Better Essays
1427 words (4.1 pages)

Comparing Organizational Codes of Test Users Essay

- Comparing Codes for Test Users Throughout history mankind has utilized testing. Testing or experiments are done on a daily basis. People do this without even realizing it; it has become part of our daily lives. Most of today’s modern technology such as electricity, cars, and even television were based on a series of experiments. Humans are known to be curious and want to understand how and why things were or happen. This curiosity extends to wanting to know how we act, feel, and understand things....   [tags: Counseling ]

Better Essays
1507 words (4.3 pages)

Organisational Behavior (OB) Essay example

- Introduction Stephen Robbins and A.J.B UBRIN think organisational behavior (OB) includes three interrelated influence and contact area of research: the behavior of the individual level, the group level and the organisational level behavior. This report will research a variety of organisational behavior theories.The following report will start with comparing and contrasting different the organisational structure and culture within Siemens to another organisation. Other parts of the report will focus on individual behavior,organisational theory,motivational theories and the impact of team work on organisational performance....   [tags: Organisational Behavior Essays]

Better Essays
2859 words (8.2 pages)

Human Resources and Organizational Strategy Essay

- Human Resources and Organizational Strategy Introduction Organizational success or failure is dependent on a myriad of variables that can be challenging to measure and interpret. Success or failure can simply be luck and timing or an orchestrated and deliberate effort. As new technologies allow organizations the ability to rapidly measure and assess its internal and external environmental factors, more efficient strategies can be quickly implemented. The focus of this literature review is specifically on one of these mentioned variables....   [tags: Business, Organizational Development]

Better Essays
2373 words (6.8 pages)

Essay on Comparing Classical vs. Modern Liberalism

- Typically Liberalism can be categorized into two different strands, Classical and Modern (yet some thinkers advocate a third strand that is referred to as Neo-Liberalism), each characterized by their differing and to some extent unavoidably overlapping attitudes regarding the theory behind the ideology and how it should be put into practice. Prior to examining how these relate to one another and before making any comparisons, it is important to give a definition, as best as possible, of Liberalism as a concept....   [tags: classical liberalism, liberalism, modern liberalis]

Better Essays
1802 words (5.1 pages)

Discuss the Role Leadership Plays in Shaping Organisational Cultures Essay

- Leadership defined has two fundamental difficulties, firstly, similar to notions such as ‘love’, ‘freedom’ and ‘happiness’, leadership is a complicated idea that has subjective interpretations (Bolden, 2004). Everyone has their own understanding of what leadership is, based on a mixture of personal experiences and learnings. Secondly, the way leadership is defined and understood through one’s influenced theoretical stance (Bolden, 2004). Those who view leadership as the outcome of individual characteristics possessed by a leader, whilst others perceive leadership as a social development that emerges from organisational relationships....   [tags: organizational ]

Better Essays
1330 words (3.8 pages)

Essay about Organizational Behavior Concepts And Terms

- Introduction As an amateur linguist, I am fascinated by words. Their origins and meanings help me to better relate to my surroundings and specific concepts. Many would say that one can not begin to understand a word or concept until a meaning is agreed upon. John Locke wrote in An Essay Concerning Human Understanding (1977) that words signify ideas, and furthermore that if a person can not identify the idea behind the word then the words are lacking in meaning (Kemerling, 2001). This agreement in terminology regarding key concepts is a culmination of my research into word origins, and as defined by Schermerhorn, Hunt, and Osborn in the text Organizational Behavior (2005)....   [tags: Organizational Behavior]

Free Essays
1121 words (3.2 pages)

What´s Improvisation? Essay

- ... It is depends on your purpose of practicing. If the artist wants to be creative, and make some thing new, improvisation is the way to go. If the artist wants to just enhance one specific skills for example guitar player wants to have more power in all their fingers. In that case, a strict set of what to practice is clear, and must be followed. Improvisation skills are not strict to making art. It can be applied to many different fields. The forms of communication and expression in art, science, politics, business, academic....   [tags: pre planning, artist creativity]

Better Essays
987 words (2.8 pages)

Improvisation - A Piece of Improvisation Work Essay examples

- Our improvisation was based on many different scenarios that have been in the newspaper and on television. We had all heard of many stories of previously "poor" families or individuals winning the lottery and becoming wealthy. One story that part of our drama was based on was of a middle-aged man who after winning the lottery, had become an alcoholic and proceeded to drink himself to death. This was a classic case of "money doesn't create happiness". All the members of my group thought that this was a good idea, and we wanted to do this as our performance....   [tags: Drama]

Free Essays
1100 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Organizational Behavior

- Organizational Behavior Shermerhorn, Hunt, Osborn, 2005, Section 1, defines Organizational Behavior (OB) is "the study of individuals and groups in an organization. Developers of this principle have substantiated it using a variety of methods such as Field studies, Laboratory studies, Meta analyses, Survey studies, and Case studies. Extended in the formulation of organizational behavior are other academic disciplines-psychology, sociology, economics, anthropology and political science. However, why should an organization, group, or individual make any effort understanding this study....   [tags: Organizational Culture]

Better Essays
1567 words (4.5 pages)