A Comparison Between William James' and Jean Paul Sartre's Points of View on Emotions

A Comparison Between William James' and Jean Paul Sartre's Points of View on Emotions

Length: 687 words (2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Good Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A Comparison Between William James' and Jean Paul Sartre's Points of View on Emotions



What is an emotion? William James and Jean-Paul Sartre present two different arguments regarding what constitutes an emotion. This paper will explore William James' analysis of emotion as set out in his 1884 essay . It will attempt to discover the main points of his view, and then present Sartre's rebuttal of this view taken from his essay on emotions . Concluding with an explanation regarding why Sartre's account is flawed and James's argument is the stronger of the two, it will use outside examples to demonstrate the various weaknesses and strengths within the two perspectives.

William James analysis of emotion revolves around his theory that an emotion is nothing more than the senses and feelings we experience in our bodies that come about after we perceive something. He says that " … the bodily changes follow directly the perception of the exciting fact, and that our feeling of the same changes as they occur is the emotion". He gives several premises to back up this theory.
First of all, that if you were to take away the bodily changes and senses that we associate with an emotion that you would have nothing left of the emotion. He refers to the state of fear and how there would be no emotion left, if the feelings of "… quickened heart-beats nor of shallow breathing…" were taken away. It would simple be a state of being, as opposed to an emotional state. Presenting an emotion with out the bodily changes that are associated with it is, as James states, is "… inconceivable."
As well, James then states how difficult it is for human beings to re-enact the bodily functions that take place when an emotion...


... middle of paper ...


... same time, each representing a specific emotion. But it is much harder to imagine that the mind could transform a person's perception of an object in conflicting ways at the same time.

James' analysis of emotion is a much stronger argument than Sartre's. Its truth can be seen in many examples of past and present day. Although the common public definition of what entails an emotion will most certainly change, it is much more likely to fall in line with, or derive from similarities in James' definition, rather than Sartre's.



Bibliography:

William James,'What Is an Emotion?', from Twenty Questions: An Introduction to Philosophy, 3rd Edition, by Bowie, Michaels, Solomon pp. 394-98.
Jean-Paul Sartre,'Emotions as Transformations of the World', from Twenty Questions: An Introduction to Philosophy, 3rd Edition, by Bowie, Michaels, Solomon pp. 399-401.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Sartre 's Ethics Of Ambiguity Essay

- Simone de Beauvoir 's ethics is exceptionally complex. In The Ethics of Ambiguity, her ideas of "vagueness," "exposure," "common flexibility," "moral opportunity"-taking their takeoffs from Jean-Paul Sartre-interweave to frame unpredictable groups of argumentation. To these conceivable reasons we may include the basic origination of Beauvoir as only Sartre 's followers and the slow decay of existentialist scholars in academia. Sartre’s ethics, his Being and Nothingness, and the advancement of his thinking are tough subjects to handle....   [tags: Existentialism, Jean-Paul Sartre]

Good Essays
1041 words (3 pages)

Sartre 's Theory Of Existentialism Essay

- It was in the 19th centuries where a French writer Jean-Paul Sartre who popularized the concept of existentialism during his play No Exit. The play was published in 1943. Sartre explained Existentialism, which states in the belief that life has no meaning. Reynolds stated that, “People should be responsible for themselves rather than make excuses for the occurrences in their life, the belief that humans have free will” ( ). Each is separate from all other individuals, so each person has the power to place himself in the position he wishes, that every individual is responsible for his actions....   [tags: Existentialism, Jean-Paul Sartre, Psychology]

Good Essays
885 words (2.5 pages)

Existentialism, By Jean Paul Sartre Essay

- “Existentialism in Humanism” is a speech given by Jean-Paul Sartre given in 1946. Existentialism is a philosophy that states the existence of the individual person determines their own development through the acts of free will. Basically, this means that a person is free to decide and manipulate the course their life will take. They can control their reactions to situations, and cause other actions to occur. The argument made by Sartre is essentially nature vs nurture. The point Sartre argues is that existence precedes essence....   [tags: Jean-Paul Sartre, Existentialism, Human, Religion]

Good Essays
1000 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Existentialism, By Jean Paul Sartre

- Existentialism Comparison Essay Existentialism is a philosophy, which revolves around the beliefs humans create themselves. Every person has his own view on existentialism and displays it differently. An existentialist in search of his meaning of life to end meaningless existence. Jean-Paul Sartre in his story The Wall attempts to demonstrate the conditions due to which a protagonist loses himself and becomes an existential after a deposited psychological trauma, but afterwards finds his new meaning....   [tags: Existentialism, Jean-Paul Sartre, Meaning of life]

Good Essays
1871 words (5.3 pages)

Existentialism And Human Emotions By Jean Paul Sartre Essay

- Another famous philosopher in support with my idea of the good life is Jean Paul Sartre, he spends the majority of his book, Existentialism and Human Emotions, expressing his disapproval of the generalization of humans. Each man or woman is their own person and contains the ability to choose his or her values. He believes the way of living is for each individual to choose, and that any person has the right to change their job, where they live or even their way of living. Sartre looks upon humans as intelligent beings, able to make rash choices and take responsible for their actions....   [tags: Human, Existentialism, Meaning of life]

Good Essays
1113 words (3.2 pages)

The, Sartre, And Voltaire 's Views On The Self And The Stages Of Life Essay example

- One of the most common struggles that every person on this globe faces is figuring out who they are, finding their ‘self’. This is a stage that often occurs more than once in your lifetime and can sometimes last relatively long. It is not easy to find yourself and to create a life based around that self. Often times, the individuals that have the hardest time with discovering themselves are college students. When experiencing doubt and despair, one might look up to a guiding figure, such as a parent, professor, or mentor....   [tags: Existentialism, Jean-Paul Sartre]

Good Essays
709 words (2 pages)

Emotions versus Emotion Essays

- The idea that pride is both horrible and wonderful is similar to how the symbols in "The Scarlet Ibis" cause opposing emotions at the same time. The Scarlet Ibis, written by James Hurst, is an intriguing piece of realistic fiction that shows how symbols can have double meanings while telling about the relationship between a boy named Doodle and his family. In this story Doodle is born in a caul and everyone expects him to die. To his family's surprise, Doodle lives but is physically handicapped and cannot do the things a normal child can....   [tags: The Scarlet Ibis by James Hurst]

Good Essays
771 words (2.2 pages)

Essay about Characters in Sartre's No Exit

- Characters in Sartre's No Exit     “No Exit,” by Jean-Paul Sartre, is a play that illustrates three people’s transitions from wanting to be alone in Hell to needing the omnipresent “other” constantly by their sides. As the story progresses, the characters’ identities become more and more permanent and unchangeable. Soon Inez, Garcin, and Estelle live in the hope that they will obtain the other’s acceptance. These three characters cannot accept their existentialist condition: they are alone in their emotions, thoughts and fears....   [tags: Jean-Paul Sartre No Exit Essays]

Good Essays
1602 words (4.6 pages)

The Body as Anstoss in Sartre's Account of Constitution Essay example

- The Body as Anstoss in Sartre's Account of Constitution ABSTRACT: Of all the German idealists, Jean-Paul Sartre refers the least to Fichte-so little in fact that there have been long-standing suspicions that he was not even familiar with Fichte's writings. It is perhaps ironic, then, that Fichte's writings are as helpful as they are for clarifying Sartre's views, especially his views on subjectivity and inter-subjectivity. Here I want to look closely at a key concept in Fichte's mature writings: the concept of the Anstoss, a concept which Dan Breazeale has called "Fichte's original insight." Fichte introduces the Anstoss, or "check," to explain why the I posits the world as it does....   [tags: Jean-Paul Sartre Philosophy Existentialism]

Free Essays
3932 words (11.2 pages)

Sartre's Philosophy Essays

- Sartre's Philosophy Sartre believed that one day man happened, or occurred, and after this anomalous event man’s life took meaning. With this theory, Sartre articulated the premise that “existence precedes essence”. Through this assumption, Sartre evolves further ideas in which a human can gain a greater understanding of human nature and responsibility.      In his theory stating that “existence precedes essence”, Sartre takes the belief that life has a meaning that far transcends our short and insignificant lives....   [tags: Philosophy Sartre Essays Papers]

Good Essays
999 words (2.9 pages)