Man's Identity According to Nietszche in Comparison to Marx's and Society's Definition

Man's Identity According to Nietszche in Comparison to Marx's and Society's Definition

Length: 1038 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Man's Identity According to Nietszche in Comparison to Marx's and Society's Definition


Friedrich Nietzsche wrote The Anti-Christ as a response to his own outrage concerning man's Christian-influenced values on life. Nietzsche saw Christianity as the leading cause of the problems with mankind. All the teachings of Christianity were contrary to the ways in which Nietzsche felt man should act and behave. His focus in The Anti-Christ is on this fact that Christianity is the root of all that is wrong with the world. His perspective on what defines an individual, particularly an ideal individual, differs greatly from that of Christian society's definition. Also, in contrast, Nietzsche's idea of what makes up a man's identity disagrees with that of Karl Marx's. While Nietzsche saw the ideal man as one who is secure, independent, and constantly questioning that which he believes to be true, Marx's ideal man is a member of the laboring proletariat class. Even though these two men both agree that the world is a place of constant conflict, their types of conflicts are very different. Marx sees the world on a large scale, and focuses on the conflicts between social classes. For Nietzsche, life is a constant series of internal conflicts within each person. Each man also sees the world as a place of continuous change. Again, Marx sees the need for change on a societal level and Nietzsche seeks change on an individual level. Their primary enemies that threaten their ideal situations are very different as well. Marx's main opponent is capitalism and Nietzsche's biggest threat is Christianity. This opposite style of viewing the world and society causes these two men to have very different criteria for what defines a person and ma...


... middle of paper ...


...economic equivalence. They both saw that the world is full of constant conflict and change, and desired for a means of finding some type of solution. While Marx sees a certain and precise method of rectifying the world's problems through the elimination of economic classes, Nietzsche is much more complex. His work is full of contradictions and unanswered questions. Nowhere does Nietzsche give guidance or assistance to his audience in picturing what his idea of a perfect society would be like. Perhaps he did not have a perfect picture in his head, and simply accepted the world for what it is. He sees all people as unique individuals, so therefore there is nothing he can say to them to give them guidance in their search for truth. What he does do, however, is let people know that there are truths to be found but only they can decide what these truths are.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Identity And The Identity Of Identity Essay

- Identity is very important to each person, the meaning of the words and actions reflect to the person’s specification. There are multiple definitions of identity, more theorists have intense debates of the real basis of describing, whether it is ontological or metaphysical. Sex and gender are both formations of identifying a person. Additionally, sex was acquired from birth with “biological and physiological characteristics that define men and women” (World Health Organization, 2016). For example, male and female have different reproductive organs on the emphasis that women give birth and men do not....   [tags: Gender, Gender role, Gender identity, Sociology]

Strong Essays
1131 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Finding Personal Identity in Rumspringa in the Film Devil's Playground

- The concept of culture spurs many individuals to study, understand, and obtain knowledge of certain customs, values, standards, and rituals that create another perspective to empathetically grasp, and each relatable truth, discovered by its researcher, can establish foundational, inalienable traits to argument the researcher’s identity. Each human is elected to be a researcher of culture with or without the knowledge of the research, but ironically, identity is not a firm state of being; it is continually shaped and molded after each new experience....   [tags: personal, identity, society, affinmations]

Strong Essays
679 words (1.9 pages)

Commentary on David Brandenberger´s National Bolshevism Stalinist Mass Culture and the Formation of Modern Russian National Identity

- NATIONAL BOLSHEVISM STALINIST MASS CULTURE AND THE FORMATION OF MODERN RUSSIAN NATIONAL IDENTITY, 1931-1956 DAVID BRANDENBERGER In the beginning of this book of the history of the Russian people, we find that most Russian’s had no real identity of who they were or from where they descended. (P.11) They were just a people simply trying to make a living for their families not really caring where they came from or most important where the government wanted them to go. Sure they would, like most of us, like to have known where they descended from or who their ancestors were, if they were great or of noble decent, for some kind of recognition to their identity....   [tags: Identity, Society]

Strong Essays
1339 words (3.8 pages)

Self Identity And Social Identity Essay

- Accordingly, this paper will provide a conceptual discussion using relevant theory that critically analyses tensions between self-identity and social identity. These theories propose that aspects of identity driving behaviour is dependent on the context. Foremost, identity theory is reflective of the correlation concerning the roles that people enact in society and then therefore, includes the identities that those roles exhibit (Hogg, et al., 1995, p. 266). Striker, followed by Tajfel and Turner, compose that social identity theory consist of two levels: personal identity and social identity (Hogg, et al., 1995, p....   [tags: Sociology, Identity, Social psychology, Identity]

Strong Essays
1299 words (3.7 pages)

Factors That Influence Gender Identity Essay

- Identity is most simply defined as a person's own sense of self; their personal sense of who they are. Identity development is intrinsically linked with adolescence because, according to Santrock citing Marcia & Carpendale, "...for the first time, physical, cognitive, and socio-emotional development advance to the point at which the individual can sort through and synthesize childhood identities and identifications to construct a viable path toward adult maturity". We often see the results of this sorting process in behaviors of adolescents such as adopting and shedding different personas including speech patterns, clothing styles and peer groups....   [tags: Identity]

Strong Essays
767 words (2.2 pages)

Essay about LGBT Identity Stages and Career Development

- Stage 1: Identity Confusion This is the "Who am I?" stage associated with the feeling that one is different from their peers This stage also is characterized by a growing sense of personal alienation. The person begins to be conscious of same-sex feelings or behaviors and to label them as such. It is rare at this stage for the person to disclose inner turmoil to others (website). In terms of career counseling, a person in this stage may start to look at careers that are outside of their comfort zone....   [tags: Identity Model]

Strong Essays
867 words (2.5 pages)

Gender Identity And Social Identity Essay example

- In today’s modern society people have come to understand the idea of LGBTQ but not everyone understands what gender identity is in depth. The term of gender identity is when individuals view themselves as male or female or what they would pronouns that they would prefer such as he or she and so on. Although this is true, what we as a society have come to understand, slowly but surely is that there are more than two types of gender identification such as the blending of male and female or neither of them....   [tags: Transgender, Gender, Gender identity]

Strong Essays
936 words (2.7 pages)

Social Comparison Research Essay

- Social comparison is primarily known as determining our social and self-worth by associating other’s into the equation. In other words, it is common that we make evaluations about our self and others most of the time. A majority of individuals, however, have the power to hold back our judgments and take control of jealous feelings that might spring up. The social comparison theory is how we discover ourselves and the characteristics we possess by comparing those traits with others’. This theory is much more complex than simply comparing one another - consisting of three types of comparisons and times when these evaluations are necessary....   [tags: Social comparison theory, Comparisons, Comparison]

Strong Essays
850 words (2.4 pages)

Essay about Comparison of the Society of Animal Farm and America Today

- Comparison of the Society of Animal Farm and America Today Humankind has always had a thirst for power; over its peers, environment and spiritual beliefs. To quench this thirst it has gone as far as genocide; but has often employed more subtle techniques, such as mind control. In today’s socio-economical and political worlds, mind control plays a key role in dictating tastes and lifestyles; as well as controlling political thoughts, views, and people’s understanding of the world. It is accomplished using various channels to condition people’s thinking....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
810 words (2.3 pages)

Identity Essay

- Identity is a state of mind in which someone recognizes/identifies their character traits that leads to finding out who they are and what they do and not that of someone else. In other words it's basically who you are and what you define yourself as being. The theme of identity is often expressed in books/novels or basically any other piece of literature so that the reader can intrigue themselves and relate to the characters and their emotions. It's useful in helping readers understand that a person's state of mind is full of arduous thoughts about who they are and what they want to be....   [tags: Identity character literature self]

Strong Essays
1453 words (4.2 pages)