How many of us want the U.S. government to have the right to tell us what to do, and when w can do it. There are probably not many who would agree that the government should have that right. Though having gun control laws is not to that extreme, some would say it is the first step. Growing up in a small town, and also growing up with guns my whole life I was one of those people who did not want gun control laws. Then after reading two articles that discussed this topic I found that I have been ignorant about this subject.
I read the articles that discussed gun control by J. Warren Cassidy and Nan Desuka. In the first article "The Case for Firearms" by J. Warren Cassidy, the author argues that the right to bear arms is given to American citizens by the Second Amendment of the Constitution. Cassidy argues that millions of Americans believe that the Second Amendment is just as crucial for the maintenance of democracy as the First Amendment Cassidy writes, "the authors of the Bill of Rights knew that a democratic republic has a right-indeed, a need- to keep and bear arms. Millions of American citizens just as adamantly believe the Second Amendment is crucial to the maintenance of the democratic process" (418). Cassidy also believes that there is no high-court decision that has found grounds to challenge this basic freedom of keeping and bearing arms. The author also argues that there has not been a reduction of crime thanks to new gun-control measures, "violent crime continues to rise in cities like New York and Washington even after severe firearm-control statues were rushed into place" (419) . In this thesis Cassidy argues that it is in the best interest of American citizens to support programs in whi...
... middle of paper ...
...cond Amendment that will support his essay, and not the whole thing.
In Desuka's essay, she shoots down Cassidy's point that the Second Amendment gives the American People a "right to bear arms." Desuka writes that the Second Amendment does not guarantee every American Citizen "the right to bear arms". She writes "But the owners of handguns are not members of a well-regulated militia" ( 424 ).
in conclusion, I found Desuka's essay more convincing than I did Cassidy's. What led me to this conclusion was: lack of statistics, dishonest evidence, and pretty much lack of any evidence to support Cassidy's. The Second Amendment specifically says " A well-regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed" (424 ), and not every American citizen is part of a "well-regulated militia".
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The Second Amendment and the Right to Bear Arms The Second Amendment to the Constitution gave United States citizens the right to bear arms. Although, the Second Amendment stated: “A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms. However, the framers could not foresee the type of violence we have in our cities today. Innocent citizens have and are being brutally killed due to this amendment. Stricter gun control laws must be enacted to receive these types of weapons.... [tags: Constituton Bill Rights Right To Bear Arms]
1235 words (3.5 pages)
- The Second Amendment Few issues incite americans more than the issue of rising crime and violence. This problem can easily be linked to the availability of guns."The debate over whether guns are a hallowed tradition and a right guaranteed by the Second Ammendment of the U.S.constitution or whether they are a fearful danger contributing to crime and violence." ("gun control") Due to the outbreak of violence in our society, some people feel that repealing the Second Ammendment would solve the problem.... [tags: Constituton Bill Rights Right To Bear Arms]
1557 words (4.4 pages)
- The United States Constitution says that U.S. Citizens have the right to bear arms. Even though this guarantee was written with no constraints, there are now laws that limit certain aspects of gun ownership. The reasons for gun control fall under the flag of public safety. Though there are many safety reasons why private ownership of firearms should be banned, these arguments are outweighed not only by the need for protection, but because the limitation of ownership rights could become dangerous to personal freedom.... [tags: 2nd Amendment Constitution The Right To Bear Arms]
2373 words (6.8 pages)
- We All Have a Right to Bear Arms The preamble of the United States Constitution clearly states its objective: to establish justice, insure domestic tranquillity, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity The bill of rights is the set of amendments to the constitution intended to secure these objectives for the individual citizens of the United States. The second amendment states: A well-regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.... [tags: Constituton Bill Rights Right To Bear Arms]
1428 words (4.1 pages)
- “A well regulated militia, being necessary to the securing of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.” Those are the words of the seconds amendment to the Constitution of the United States. These words were written by the man who laid the foundation of our government today. As a constitutional right our government has no right to take away our right to concealed carry. The government may mean good by doing this, but will this really help, or only create more problems.... [tags: Anti Gun Control Essays]
609 words (1.7 pages)
- The Right to Bear Arms People argue the right of the Second Amendment all the time. Some people think that guns should not be a given right and that we do not deserve to own them. Most liberals think that outlawing guns will lower the crime rate in America. My question to you is when was the last time a gun that was involved in a crime was legally purchased by the person committing the crime. In most cases, a robbery or crime is committed with a stolen gun. Stolen weapons are harder to trace to the criminal.... [tags: Firearm, Gun politics in the United States]
895 words (2.6 pages)
- Do you know what the second amendment is. Or do you just know the simplest definition. The second amendment is simply defined as the right to bear arms. In further definition, the right to bear arms gives you the right to own a gun but restrains where you can take it and what type it is. First, one of the rights that is restricted is who can own a firearm. The Lewis V. The United States case is related to this restricted right because it is involved with gun ownership. Lewis was accused of a brake light entering with the intent of misdemeanor.... [tags: Fourth Ammendment to the US Constitution]
559 words (1.6 pages)
- The Right to Bear Arms The United States holds five percent of the world’s population, yet thirty-one percent of the world’s public mass shootings (Christensen). Yes, legislation for stricter gun laws is discussed after each devastating shooting; however, the Second Amendment prevents any effective legislation from being passed. Eventually, the talk of new laws diminishes, leaving the number of mass shootings in America tremendously high. Because of the right to bear arms, gun laws remain loose, and American citizens continue to be murdered; therefore, Congress needs to amend the Second Amendment to restrict the right to bear arms and enable stricter gun laws to be passed.... [tags: Firearm, United States]
859 words (2.5 pages)
- The memorable Benjamin Franklin once said, “Those who surrender freedom for security will not have, nor do they deserve, either one.” The right to bear arms is a right given to us by our founding fathers in the second amendment of our Bill of Rights. With acts of terrorism threatening nations worldwide, security becomes a factor of essence in the laws of a country. Some people call for the restriction of guns and gun-related products in order to promote security by disarming the people. Others have called for quite the opposite, arm your people by giving them the liberty to protect themselves so they can help first before the government can.... [tags: Firearm, Gun]
983 words (2.8 pages)
- The Second Amendment And The Right To Bear Arms Throughout the years there has been an ongoing debate over the Second Amendment and how it should be interpreted. The issue that is being debated is whether our government has the right to regulate guns. The answer of who has which rights lies within how one interprets the Second Amendment. With this being the case, one must also think about what circumstances the Framers were under when this Amendment was written. There are two major sides to this debate, one being the collective side, which feels that the right was given for collective purposes only.... [tags: Gun Bear Arms Control Essays Debate]
2184 words (6.2 pages)