Postmodern Perspective on Health versus the Biomedical Model Essay

Postmodern Perspective on Health versus the Biomedical Model Essay

Length: 609 words (1.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Good Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Postmodern Perspective on Health versus the Biomedical Model

I have chosen to compare the postmodern perspective on health and the biomedical model. The biomedical model view of the body is mechanistic. This point was argued by Engels, who said that the body was a machine and the breakdown of this machine was disease. he also beleived that the the doctor was the only one who could fix the machine. this point leads to many biomedical views. Firstly, it shows the way that doctors view the body as a set of individual parts, diagnose and treat them as such. This non-holistic view of the body is often criticised because it fails to cnsider the person as a whole and entire building. Secondly it shows the importance of the doctor in the biomedical model. Doctors have and maintain power in the biomedical model. They have all of the information and knowledge and therefore all the power. This can mean that the patient gives total control of their body to the doctor.This power ratio is explored by postmodernists who are interested in how one perspctive gains so much power and influence. Foucault (1963) said that the choice of words and phrases can effect the way people think. So doctors who have more influence and respect can gain power over their patients bodies'. This use of language to affect thinking is called discourse to postmodernists.

A study by peter bellamy (1990) of workers in a pottery factory and the way they took time off work. The study concluded that doctors used their status to medicalise problems such as morning sickness to allow the workers paid time off work. Although to the workers this may seem positive this medicalisation of problems that used to be seen as natural has been criticised. Anne Oakely in her study...

... middle of paper ... critics from different sociological perspectives have points of view on iatrogenesis. coming from a marxist perspective Navarro blames capitalism as apposed to industrialisation for the increase in doctor caused disease. He beleived that in the capitalist society profit is placed over people and this is true of health care.

a major problem with the biomedical model is the way that it fails to explain the cultural differences in health. it cannot account for people in different cultures who use a different model to deal with their health and yet it appears to work for them.

Both the theories give very different perspectives on health, postmodernists beleive that members of society should be able to choose their own methods of health care whereas the biomedical model beleives that science is the only option to make someone healthy.


Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

What is Postmodern Art? Essay

- Postmodernism is described as the phase of twentieth century Western culture that has been often defined as the visual culture produced in the period after modernism, though there has been much recent debate since the early 1980’s as to what the definition of Postmodernism could be. Postmodern art has always been difficult to define for various reasons which include what styles of art should be included in the movement, what is the exact artistic style of Postmodern art and the insufficiency to specify what exactly postmodernism is....   [tags: Postmodern Art Essays]

Good Essays
1813 words (5.2 pages)

Health Belief Model: Condoms and Sexual Risk Essay

- Sexual Risk Teen Pregnancy Prevention (Condom) Section 1- Health Belief Model The health belief model (HBM) is a psychosocial model that was developed during the 1950’s by social psychologists of the U.S public health services, and this model was used to explain why people failed to participate in disease prevention and detection programs. The theory is one of the most health behavior theories, which is used to explain behavior change and maintenances, but often times used to predict behavior outcome (Glanze, Rimer, & Lewis, 2002)....   [tags: health belief model, condoms]

Good Essays
1459 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on Biomedical Model And Social Model Of Health

- Essay question 1: Critically discuss the biomedical model and social model of health and how they relate to lay perspectives on health and illness. Introduction: For this essay I am going to critically discuss the biomedical model as well as the social model of health and how they both relate to the lay perspectives on health and illness. In 1948 the World Health Organisation (WHO) defined health as “a state of complete physical, mental, and social well-being, and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity”....   [tags: Health, Health care, Illness, Medicine]

Good Essays
1176 words (3.4 pages)

The Biomedical Model Of Health Essay

- The World Health Organization (WHO) defined health in its broader sense in its 1948 constitution as "a state of complete physical, mental, and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity" (Who,1946). The Biomedical model of health focuses on the physical or biological aspects of disease and illness. It is a medical model of care practised by doctors and/or health professional and is associated with the diagnosis, cure and treatment of disease. The Biomedical model of health has been evolving for many years leading to improvements in medical science, technology, increase in cures and treatments ie: increase in vaccinations /immunizations emphasis on diagnosis and tre...   [tags: Health care, Medicine, Health, Personal life]

Good Essays
1272 words (3.6 pages)

Health And Human Services : The Holistic Health Model, And The Socio Ecological Model

- In this segment of lectures in Health and Human Services, the class has been learning the “Overview of Health and Human Services”, which focuses on the basics for a variety of careers in the field. The lectures have included: “An Introduction to CHHS”, “HHS Agencies and Organizations”, “Becoming an HHS Professional”, “Understanding Frameworks of Health and Wellness”, “Interprofessional Education and Practice in HHS”, “Career Exploration in HHS”, and two separate career panel days. Due to the immense amount of information that was presented to the class, there were many new concepts and terms that were introduced....   [tags: Health care, Health, Public health, Sociology]

Good Essays
750 words (2.1 pages)

My Perspective On Health And Health Promotion Essay

- Throughout the term, I have been exposed to many new experiences that have helped me grow as a student nurse. My way of thinking about health and what it means to be healthy has changed since I started the Bachelor of Nursing program. Working with Older Adults at the St. Joseph’s Facility for Independent Living has given me great insights in ways health promotion can be implemented and can benefit that specific population. This learning continuum created within all our classes has broadened my mind and also my expectations of health and health promotion in the community context....   [tags: Health, Public health, Nursing, Health care]

Good Essays
1644 words (4.7 pages)

Postmodern Organization Theory Essay

- Introduction As the theme of my essay I have chosen to find out what our contemporary society must not forget in order to be able to make organizational theory evolve well into the 21st century. For this task I have decided to take a look back to Aldous Huxley’s modern dystopia “Brave new world”, that warned against totalitarian regimes that intended to suppress individuality in order to advance the interest of the state in its time. Even as those regimes might not be a direct threat nowadays we can eerily conclude that some aspects of it are quite accurate for the times we live in....   [tags: Postmodern Management]

Good Essays
1460 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about An Evaluation Of The Health Belief Model

- An Evaluation of the Health Belief Model The goal of this paper is to evaluate and discuss the Health Belief Model, its origins, development, key terms and application; review current research that uses the health belief model as a framework for evaluating health related behaviors and provide an example of how the theory can be applied in modern nursing practice. History of the Health Belief Model In the nineteen fifties, a group of social psychologists at the United States Public Health Service developed the Health Belief Model (HBM) in an attempt to understand the widespread failure of people to participate in screenings for asymptomatic disease; an early example being the failure of large...   [tags: Health, Health care, Public health, Medicine]

Good Essays
1113 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Different Perspectives On Health Care

- Different Perspectives on Health Care While The Truman Show is a fiction, comedy film, it holds an important lesson for real life. The film follows Truman Burbank, who is unaware his “real” life is actually a television show influenced by a number of actors and people behind the scenes. Viewers are intrigued by this movie’s premise, but many people do not realize that real world systems operate behind the scenes in their own lives. Conflict theory discusses how conflict is inevitable and is a result of an imbalance in power and access to resources....   [tags: Health care, Barack Obama, Health insurance]

Good Essays
1120 words (3.2 pages)

Postmodern Film Essay examples

- The postmodern cinema emerged in the 80s and 90s as a powerfully creative force in Hollywood film-making, helping to form the historic convergence of technology, media culture and consumerism. Departing from the modernist cultural tradition grounded in the faith in historical progress, the norms of industrial society and the Enlightenment, the postmodern film is defined by its disjointed narratives, images of chaos, random violence, a dark view of the human state, death of the hero and the emphasis on technique over content....   [tags: cinema, postmodern cinema, narrative]

Good Essays
2291 words (6.5 pages)