Censorship in Schools Essay

Censorship in Schools Essay

Length: 2166 words (6.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Censorship in Schools

According to “Freedom of Speech” by Gerald Leinwand, Abraham Lincoln once asked, “Must a government, of necessity, be too strong for the liberties of its people, or too weak to maintain its own existence (7)?” This question is particularly appropriate when considering what is perhaps the most sacred of all our Constitutionally guaranteed rights, freedom of expression. Lincoln knew well the potential dangers of expression, having steered the Union through the bitterly divisive Civil War, but he held the Constitution dear enough to protect its promises whenever possible (8).
Issues of censorship in public schools are contests between the exercise of discretion and the exercise of a Constitutional right. The law must reconcile conflicting claims of liberty and authority, as expressed by Supreme Court Justice Felix Frankfurter in Minersville School District v. Gobitis, 1940 in “Banned in the U.S.A.: A Reference Guide to Book Censorship in Schools and Public Libraries” by Herbert N. Foerstel (23).
Minersville provides a very interesting backdrop to subsequent cases with graver overtones of censorship. The Minersville case was brought by the father of Lillian and William Gobitis, on their behalf, against the public schools of Minersville, Pennsylvania. The Gobitis children, Jehovah's Witnesses, were brought up to believe that scripture forbade saluting a flag. They refused to observe the Pledge of Allegiance and were expelled from the public school system, forcing their father to enroll them in private schools (23-25).
Constitutionally, the case at first appears to be a rather one-sided violation of the First Amendment as incorporated through the Fourteenth. The court, however, was of a different opinion: "...


... middle of paper ...


...und the issue (173).
As the case in Illinois clearly demonstrates, concerns about the fundamental discrepancy between a government's authority and what that government's authority guarantees are still being resolved. Cases like Tinker still have meaning and relevance to the situations of today, but at the same time, the lesson of Slotterback and innumerable other cases is that precedent can be defied, that every new generation requires a new interpretation of the provisions and guarantees made in grand terms vague enough to allow just such reinterpretation. History shows that censorship can be unfolded into either prior restraint or public forum, the approach from liberty or the approach from authority. Judicial sympathies have swung from one to the other with some regularity. With an issue as contentious as this, we can safely expect they will continue to do so.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Censorship in Schools is not Justifiable Essay

- Censorship in School is Not Justifiable Walt Whitman once said, “The dirtiest book of all is the expurgated book.” Between the years 2000 and 2009 a total of 3200 books were challenged in school libraries in an attempt to expurgate, or censor, the content in books provided to students. Today the trend of censorship continues as popular novels such as The Hunger Games, The Fault in Our Stars, and Captain Underpants are censored from schools across the nation (Challenges by Reason).Censorship in regards to literature refers to the examination and suppressing of a book because of objectionable material....   [tags: school libraries, suppressing of a book]

Powerful Essays
950 words (2.7 pages)

Essay about The Unspeakable Word: Censorship in Schools

- ... Having a baby is expensive and time consuming. STDs and STIs “are infectious diseases that are spread through sexual contact.” (Sexually, Internet). Emotional scars are the long lasting emotions and thoughts that bring that person back to their traumatic experience. People may say that it is the parents’ job to tell their kid when “they’re ready,” but in reality they have been talking about it since at least the 6th grade. The world is changing; sex is absolutely everywhere, it is on magazines, in the grocery store; on their movies, in their books, even in their conversations....   [tags: sex, school, emotion, pregnancy, infections]

Powerful Essays
722 words (2.1 pages)

Banning Books in Schools Essay

- School boards and teachers have a responsibility for protecting the minds of their students and covering age appropriate material. However, does this responsibility cover the extreme act of banning books from school classrooms. Does not the teacher have a duty to introduce to their students world issues in order to better the students ability to cope with problems in the world. How does a school decide which books should be banned from the classroom, and should it be left up to the teacher to decide what is decided in his/her classroom....   [tags: Censorship In Public Schools]

Powerful Essays
1082 words (3.1 pages)

Censorship in Schools Essay

- Censorship in Schools According to “Freedom of Speech” by Gerald Leinwand, Abraham Lincoln once asked, “Must a government, of necessity, be too strong for the liberties of its people, or too weak to maintain its own existence (7)?” This question is particularly appropriate when considering what is perhaps the most sacred of all our Constitutionally guaranteed rights, freedom of expression. Lincoln knew well the potential dangers of expression, having steered the Union through the bitterly divisive Civil War, but he held the Constitution dear enough to protect its promises whenever possible (8)....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
2166 words (6.2 pages)

Censorship In Public Schools and Libraries Essay

- Book banning seems an archaic notion to many. Yet as outmoded as banning may seem, censorship is still a huge part of the United States literary culture. Book banning is most often successful at the young adult literature level. Parents, and other objectors, utilize the censorship process in an effort to protect children and young adults from books that they deem dangerous. Public libraries, school libraries, and English classrooms are where these censorship attempts are being waged, often successfully....   [tags: Book Banning]

Powerful Essays
2567 words (7.3 pages)

Book Censorship in American High Schools Essay

- Censorship in American High Schools Book banning has a long history and has made both positive and negative impact on readers. People have been trying to stop books from being banned, but there are also people that are trying to ban books to protect their children. Many books have been challenged and even banned because of the “inappropriate” content the books contain such as profanity. Books have started to get censored since the 1500’s and has threatened many cultures. The people who ban and censor books think that they are protecting the readers from the information, but it is secluding the readers from getting more ideas....   [tags: book banning, readers, protection]

Powerful Essays
1974 words (5.6 pages)

Censorship in Libraries and Schools Essay

- Censorship in Libraries and Schools What would you do if you went to your child's school and saw that they were looking at inappropriate material on the internet. Would you react the same way if they were in a public library. Who decides what is okay for your children to view. Who decides where they can view it. What can you do about them being able to view these things. Are there any laws that can prevent this from happening. What are some schools and libraries doing to help prevent children form looking at such material....   [tags: Censoring Literature Essays]

Powerful Essays
1076 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Censorship in American Schools

- Censorship in American Schools You may not realize this but our government plays a large role in governing what sort of information America’s children are exposed to. The average American child receives the majority of their knowledge and education from school, so the information that is allowed to be taught is a very delicate and controversial issue. Literature is often altered or banned from public schools and libraries because they contain of vulgar language, excessive violence, or connotations of drugs and sex....   [tags: Essays Papers]

Powerful Essays
1143 words (3.3 pages)

Censorship in Public Schools Essay

- because he thinks they might contain "obscenities or offensive sexual references" (Berger 59). -A Vermont high school librarian is forced to resign because she fought the school board's decision to remove Richard Price's The Wanderers, and to "restrict" the use of Stephen King's Carrie and Patrick Mann's Dog Day Afternoon (Jones 33). -An Indiana school board takes action that leads to the burning of many copies of a textbook that deals with drugs and the sexual behavior of teenagers (Berger 61)....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Powerful Essays
1617 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on The Role of Censorship

- Censorship plays a huge role in today’s society. Censorship effects society in excellent ways by putting a blind fold on certain types of media, language, and other social values that should not be seen by all humans. Censorship is known to many as being listed under the category of moral. Censorship is moral, because it bans certain books from schools that should be banned, it helps parents keep their children from material they should not be in acquaintance with, and is politically correct for society and students due to its ethical values....   [tags: Benefits, Book Banishment, Schools]

Powerful Essays
1024 words (2.9 pages)