The Miranda Decision Essay

The Miranda Decision Essay

Length: 1523 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Miranda Decision


In 1966, the U. S. Supreme Court handed down its landmark decision in Miranda
v. Arizona. The Miranda decision was a departure from the established law in the area of
police interrogation. Prior to Miranda, a confession would be suppressed only if a court
determined it resulted from some actual coercion, threat, or promise. The Miranda
decision was intended to protect suspects of their 5th Amendment right of no
self-incrimination. The verdict of Miranda v. Arizona is an efficient way of informing
criminal suspects of their rights established by the Constitution, allowing un-Constitutional
confessions to be nullinvoid in the court of law. However, it does not enforce it well
enough. For example, a statement taken in violation of Miranda can be used for
impeachment purposes and deciding whether evidence derived from a Miranda violation is
admissible. Also, Miranda applies to undercover police interrogation and prior to routine
booking questions, protecting all suspect in American custody to be aware of their rights.
Next, it says that police may not continue to interrogate a suspect after he makes a request
for a lawyer.
At approximately 8:30 p.m. on November 27, 1962, a young woman left the First
National Bank of Arizona after attending night classes. A male suspect robbed the woman
1
of $8 at knife-point after forcing his way into her car. Four months later, the same suspect
abducted an 18-year-old girl at knife-point and, after tying her hands and feet, drove to a
secluded area of the desert and raped her. On March 13, 1963, police arrested
23-year-old Ernesto Arthur Miranda as a suspect in the two crimes. Miranda had a prior
arrest record for armed robbery and a juvenil...


... middle of paper ...


....
The Supreme Court has practically abandoned the underlying principle of the
Miranda decision, that custodial police interrogation is inherently coercive, and has carved
out many exceptions to the Miranda exclusionary rule. Consequently, a violation of the
Miranda ruling does not necessarily mean that the resulting statement will be inadmissible.
The Supreme Court has made it clear that the Miranda warnings are not constitutionally
required but are only prophylactic rules designed to protect a suspect's right against
compelled self-incrimination. Voluntariness remains the constitutional standard that must
be met when obtaining a statement from a suspect. Nonetheless, law enforcement
agencies should consult with legal counsel to ensure that investigative practices conform
to the requirements set forth by the Supreme Court in Miranda and other precedent.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Miranda Case Of Miranda V. Arizona Essay

- MIRANDA WARNING 2 The Duhaime’s Law Dictionary defines Miranda Warning as: “A requirement that police officers, in the U.S.A., before any questioning is so begun, warn suspects upon arrest that they have the right to remain silent, that any statement that they make could be used against them in a court of law, that they have the right to contact a lawyer and that if they cannot afford a lawyer, that one will be provided”. If an officer fails to read the Miranda warning prior to questioning, any confession or information that is obtained will not be admissible in court....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Strong Essays
1063 words (3 pages)

Essay on The Case Of Miranda V. Arizona

- MIRANDA 2 The case of Miranda v. Arizona (384 U.S. 436 [1966]) is one of the most important cases in history. It brought about prominent rights that are still existent today in 2015 regarding interrogations and custody. The results of this case are still seen in the current criminal justice system. However, even though the rights that were given to the system by the court, there are still instances today in which these Miranda rights are violated. The concept of Miranda has evolved a lot from a court case to a code used by law enforcement during custodies and investigations....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona, Police]

Strong Essays
1271 words (3.6 pages)

Essay about Miranda Rights And The Grand Debate

- Miranda Rights and the Grand Debate As we have learned the Fifth Amendment and the Miranda Rights are linked in one way or another. They became linked in 1966 when the Supreme Court decided the Miranda v. Arizona that made it clear that the public is being questioned or has been placed in custody by an officer that they must be read there Miranda Right, before they start to question them. It is so important that officers do their best to make sure that they read the individuals there Miranda right, so that they can use information that is obtained against the suspect....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Strong Essays
1111 words (3.2 pages)

The Miranda V. Arizona Case Essays

- The Miranda v. Arizona case not just for the case itself, but also for the significance of the case it had after the case. The Miranda is a nationwide that has changed law enforcement and has changed the rights of an individual. The Miranda rights law took affect after a man named Ernesto Miranda was under arrest by police officers. As police arrested Ernesto Miranda they didn’t read him his rights. Ernest Miranda lived in Phoenix, Arizona where he was charged with rape, kidnapping and robbery. Ernesto Miranda was a criminal, however he was not informed of his legal rights before the arrest....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Strong Essays
1709 words (4.9 pages)

Miranda Vs. Arizona Case Essay

- The landmark case, Miranda vs. Arizona is one of the most important legal cases in the United States. The decision of the case led to the creation of the Miranda Rights, which is still practiced to this day. Miranda Rights- “You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say or do can and will be held against you in a court of law. You have the right to speak to an attorney. If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be appointed for you. Do you understand these rights as they have been read to you?” (Decision Date: June.13.1966)....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Strong Essays
735 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Miranda V. Arizona Case

- Everyone agrees that police should not use unconstitutional methods to coerce a suspect into giving out a confession, yet police have used unauthorized force throughout American history. Fortunately, the Supreme Court created a legal safeguard against police abuses. The safeguards were created in the 1960s after taking a case titled Miranda v. Arizona. Miranda v. Arizona is unarguably one of the most important actions the Supreme Court has taken to prevent police abuses. Many jurisdictions have interpreted Miranda v....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Strong Essays
1116 words (3.2 pages)

Essay On Miranda Rights

- Kenny Keller Period 5 Crime Research Paper 11/4/17 Miranda Rights Crime, by definition, is an action or omission that constitutes an offense that may be prosecuted by the state and is punishable by law. Every crime, and every criminal has a story. The story of how the Miranda Rights came to be is one of the most well known crimes in history. The Miranda Rights have changed the world of crime and justice to the point of no return, and has affected the lives of everyone involved in crime, has been arrested, has had their rights read, or who has read said rights....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Strong Essays
1808 words (5.2 pages)

Outline Of Ernesto Miranda 's Speech

- Ernesto Miranda Ernesto Arturo Miranda was born in Mesa, Arizona on March 9, 1941. During his grade school years, Miranda began getting in trouble. His first criminal conviction was during his eighth grade year. The following year, now a 9th grade dropout, he was convicted of burglary. His sentence was a year in the reform school, Arizona State Industrial School for Boys (ASISB). After his release from the reform school, he got into trouble again with the law and was returned to ASISB. Once released for the second time, Miranda relocated to Los Angeles where a few months later he was arrested on suspicion of armed robbery and sexual offenses even though he was not convicted of these crimes....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Strong Essays
1148 words (3.3 pages)

Essay On Miranda Rights

- The Miranda Rights “You have the right to remain silent, anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. You have the right to an attorney. If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be appointed for you…” (Mirandarights.org) how many times have you heard this phrase uttered on a TV show or movie. Probably so many times that you can recite it yourself. Hearing this phrase so often may cause us to overlook the significance and importance of what it means. This phrase, which is known as the Miranda Rights, is a cornerstone to the American legal system....   [tags: United States Constitution, Miranda v. Arizona]

Strong Essays
1027 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about Rosenberg, Epp, and Miranda: Implementation of Supreme Court Decisions

- On the surface, it seems that determining how much power courts have would be a simple task. However, history has proven this to be false. The courts have been viewed in many different ways through out the history of our country. There are three common views of court power that are important for modern scholars of the court system. Those who believe courts have little power to cause social change are said to adhere to the Constrained Court view. Those who believe courts have a great deal of power to cause social change are said to adhere to the Dynamic Court view....   [tags: Miranda Essay 2014]

Strong Essays
2400 words (6.9 pages)