Chinese Room Scenario by John R. Searle Essay

Chinese Room Scenario by John R. Searle Essay

Length: 517 words (1.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Good Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Chinese Room Scenario by John R. Searle


Through the use of his famous Chinese room scenario, John R. Searle tries to prove there is no way artificial intelligence can exist. This means that machines do not posses minds.
The debate between those who are in favor of strong and weak artificial intelligence (AI) is directly related to the philosophy of mind. The claim of weak AI is that it is possible to run a program on a machine, which will behave as if it were a thinking thing. Believers of strong AI say that it is possible to create a program running on a machine which not only behaves as if it were thinking, but does actually think. Strong AI followers argue that an installation of a computer program is considered a mind as real as the mind of any human.
Searle's claim is that any installation of a program is an operation. The lack of meaning, he states, means that the computer program does not have true understanding and is not truly thinking, it is simply computing and processing symbols. He presents this argument by using his famous Chinese room. Searle begins by ta...

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Turing, Searle, and Artificial Intelligence Essay

- The conditions of the present scenario are as follows: a machine, Siri*, capable of passing the Turing test, is being insulted by a 10 year old boy, whose mother is questioning the appropriateness of punishing him for his behavior. We cannot answer the mother's question without speculating as to what A.M. Turing and John Searle, two 20th century philosophers whose views on artificial intelligence are starkly contrasting, would say about this predicament. Furthermore, we must provide fair and balanced consideration for both theorists’ viewpoints because, ultimately, neither side can be “correct” in this scenario....   [tags: Artificial Intelligence Essays]

Good Essays
1275 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on The Chinese Room Argument

- John Searle formulated the Chinese Room Argument in the early 80’s as an attempt to prove that computers are not cognitive operating systems. In short though the immergence of artificial and computational systems has rapidly increased the infinite possibility of knowledge, Searle uses the Chinese room argument to shown that computers are not cognitively independent. John Searle developed two areas of thought concerning the independent cognition of computers. These ideas included the definition of a weak AI and a strong AI....   [tags: Computer Science]

Good Essays
907 words (2.6 pages)

Essay about John Searle's Chinese Room Argument

- John Searle’s Chinese room argument from his work “Minds, Brains, and Programs” was a thought experiment against the premises of strong Artificial Intelligence (AI). The premises of conclude that something is of the strong AI nature if it can understand and it can explain how human understanding works. I will argue that the Chinese room argument successfully disproves the conclusion of strong AI, however, it does not provide an explanation of what understanding is which becomes problematic when creating a distinction between humans and machines....   [tags: artificial intelligence]

Good Essays
825 words (2.4 pages)

John Searle's Chinese Room Argument Essay

- John Searle's Chinese Room Argument The purpose of this paper is to present John Searle’s Chinese room argument in which it challenges the notions of the computational paradigm, specifically the ability of intentionality. Then I will outline two of the commentaries following, the first by Bruce Bridgeman, which is in opposition to Searle and uses the super robot to exemplify his point. Then I will discuss John Eccles’ response, which entails a general agreement with Searle with a few objections to definitions and comparisons....   [tags: Papers]

Good Essays
1990 words (5.7 pages)

Searle’s Solution to the Missing Object Problem Essay

- Let us imagine that to play a joke on her new friend Suzy, Jenny tells her all about her cocker spaniel. Jenny tells Suzy that her dog’s name is Sally, that Sally has long blonde hair, and that she loves to eat table scraps. The only problem is that Sally does not really exist ¾ but Jenny doesn’t tell this to Suzy. Because of this, Suzy forms all sorts of beliefs about Jenny’s cocker spaniel. She believes that it is named Sally, that it has long blonde hair and loves to eat table scraps, and perhaps a few other beliefs....   [tags: Searle Philosophy Philosophical Essays]

Free Essays
2683 words (7.7 pages)

Why Machines Cannot Have Conciousness Essay

- Machines are made to calculate, capture and store images. Machines are also made to help make individual's lives easier and more efficient. For instance, we are able to keep records of our financial transactions through computers. Also, we are now able to communicate with other individuals from different countries because of technology. As technology advances, some individuals are considering machines to have qualities similar to human beings, such as a consciousness and the structure of the human body....   [tags: Alan Turing, John Searle]

Good Essays
1282 words (3.7 pages)

Essay William Lycan's Response to John Searle

- William Lycan's response as a functionalist seems to be one of the most interesting responses to Searle's paper. However, it also appears to be one of the most empty. Lycan's reaction as a functionalist appears to be very similar to the systems reply. In response to Searle's paper, both the systems reply and Lycan's functionalist response claim that while the individual person locked in the room does not understand the story, the system as a whole does understand the story. Lycan basically writes a logical response to Searle's paper with empty arguments....   [tags: Philosophy]

Free Essays
801 words (2.3 pages)

The View Of Consciousness, By Rene Descartes And John Searle 's Perspectives On Consciousness

- ... Searle begins his discussion of consciousness by providing a definition, which he finds best fits what consciousness means in his view. Consciousness, by Searle’s definition is the awareness we experience from the moment we wake up from a dreamless sleep, and continues throughout the day until we fall asleep again. Consciousness is a biological phenomenon, and Searle states we must treat it equivalent how we treat other biological processes that our body partakes. Other biological phenomenon’s, however, do not have the same features that consciousness has....   [tags: Mind, Philosophy of mind, Consciousness]

Good Essays
818 words (2.3 pages)

Artificial Inteligence in John Searle’s paper: Minds, Brains, and Programs

- Searle’s paper, “Minds, Brains, and Programs”, was originally published in Behavioral and Brain Sciences in 1980. It has become one of modern philosophy’s (and broadly, cognitive science’s) most disputed and discussed pieces due to the nature of the argument presented in the paper. In said paper, John Searle sought, or should I say, seeks, to dispute the claim that artificial intelligence in the form of computers and programs do, or at the most basic level, could (one day), think for their synthetic selves; essentially it’s a refutation of the idea that computers or programs can actually “understand” in the same way that a human can....   [tags: Robots, Computers, Programs]

Good Essays
1961 words (5.6 pages)

Essay about Chinese

- This essay will explore how Classical Chinese literature written during the Ming Dynasty illustrates the social role that women played in the traditional Chinese marriage. Issues and traditions that greatly affected women`s roles in the family and society included lineage, male dominance, families position in society, grounds and repercussions for divorce. In the vernacular short story ``The Shrew: Sharp Tongued Ts`ui-lien``, anonymous is a story in the collection Vernacular Short Stories from the Clear and Peaceful Studio (Qingping shantung heaven) which was writing during the Ming dynasty, the main character Ts`uilien, exemplifies a woman in this time period, subject to its rules and socie...   [tags: Classical Chinese Literature, Ming Dynasty]

Good Essays
2484 words (7.1 pages)