Deciding when to die and when to live is an issue that has only recently begun to confront patients all over the world. There is an elderly man lying in a hospital bed, he just had his fourth heart attack and is in a persistent vegetative state. He is hooked up to a respirator and has more tubes and IV’s going in and out of his body everywhere. These kinds of situations exist in every hospital everyday. Should physicians or doctors be allowed to assist patients, like this one, in death? Even though, physician-assisted suicide is illegal in the U.S., many doctors are helping suffering patients die. Physicians should not provide treatments that have a low chance of succeeding, such as respirators for patients in a permanent vegetative state.
Rita L. Maker, an attorney and executive director of the International Anti-Euthanasia Task Force, believes “the debate isn’t about the tragic, personal act of suicide, nor is it about attempted suicide…the current debate is about whether public policy should be changed in a way that will transform prescriptions from poison into medical treatment”(45).
Oregon is the only state that allows assisted suicide. A doctor will prescribe medication and the pharmacist will say “be sure to take all of these pills at one time-with a light snack or alcohol-to induce death”(45). The states insurance companies pay for the medication, which are paid for by Medicaid called “comfort care”(46).
“Whether other states embrace Oregon-style care will depend upon a willingness to carefully examine what truly is at stake in this debate…about public policy”(46). It
does not matter about your point of view on physician-assisted suicide; it’s the layout and...
... middle of paper ...
...oice to end their life they wouldn’t, but knowing they have a choice would put them at ease and when they think it is the right time to end their life they can do so, just like Rollins mother did. Rollins mother took the prescription when she felt most comfortable. Rollins concludes it by saying “times have changed…but ultimately, I can’t help these people the way I helped my mother. What I can do is join the fight to change the law. It’s going to be a state-by-state battle, and California is next up.
I am totally for physician assisted-suicide. Physicians should respect the wishes of their patients, even when the patient wants to die. Decisions about how to die are personal, private matters that the government should stay out of. Dying patients should have the right to choose a quick, painless death and doctors should be allowed to help them achieve it.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The Morality of Assisted Suicide Deciding when to die and when to live is an issue that has only recently begun to confront patients all over the world. There is an elderly man lying in a hospital bed, he just had his fourth heart attack and is in a persistent vegetative state. He is hooked up to a respirator and has more tubes and IV’s going in and out of his body everywhere. These kinds of situations exist in every hospital everyday. Should physicians or doctors be allowed to assist patients, like this one, in death.... [tags: Papers]
1973 words (5.6 pages)
- One of the tenet of the Hippocratic Oath is that the physician should do no harm and always look to ease the pain and suffering for their patient. The debating rages on about the morality and legality of physician-assisted suicide. Valid questions have been asked about what sought of role physician should have during end of life decision, and weather, economics should play a role in these very important. However, belief that despite valid concerns, the decision should not only factor in economic factors, but should be a decision left to the patient and his physician.... [tags: Medicine, Physician, Health care, Patient]
2114 words (6 pages)
- America is a country that allows its citizens to enjoy an abundance of liberties including the right to make many of their own decisions. The United States military stands guard to protect each member's right to personal freedom guaranteed by the United States Constitution. The United States Government has very little to say when it comes to a person’s choices about their life. Americans make decisions for themselves about pregnancies, jobs, education and marital status. It is surprising that among all of the liberty and freedom, one topic that seems to continue to draw controversy and government intervention is physician-assisted suicides.... [tags: Assisted Suicide]
2186 words (6.2 pages)
- The Morality of Suicide We as humans, according to Camus, seek meaning. As humans we look for answers in a meaningless universe that yields no such comfort to our questions. Camus says it is absurd to shout into this void for answers. Since there is no such meaning, you as a free agent can choose to find meaning by taking a leap of faith, placing your hopes in a god, or choose to conclude that life is meaningless which results in suicide. Those that judge life as unworthy of living commit suicide.... [tags: Suicide, Meaning of life, Death, Assisted suicide]
1765 words (5 pages)
- Assisted Suicide Assists the Terminally Ill Waiting, suffering, pain, and death. These words constantly flow through the minds of people lying on their death beds. Some have cancer or life threatening diseases while others just wish they were not alive and want their lives to end. In today’s world, too many people encounter these life or death situations. Because of this, a controversy over assisted suicide has grown all over the United States. Assisted suicide, the “termination of one’s own life by the administration of a lethal substance” with the help of a physician, has been passed and made legal in a few states such as California and Oregon; however, other states are weary and unsure a... [tags: Death, Suicide, Suffering, Morality]
1494 words (4.3 pages)
- A Moral Consideration of Physician-Assisted Suicide Physician-assisted suicide refers to a circumstance in which a terminally ill patient requests a physician to aid them in terminating their own life. In our nation today, the concept of physician-assisted suicide is extremely controversial. Many view physician-assisted suicide as a humane solution to ending the suffering of a dying patient. On the other hand, many feel that it is unethical for a doctor to perform such an act because the very essence of their profession is founded on restoring life and health.... [tags: Death, Morality, Suicide, Patient]
1197 words (3.4 pages)
- Euthanasia and Physician Assisted Suicide Euthanasia and physician assisted suicide are topics which are debated everyday around the world. Different cultures view life differently and these differences cause debate over the morality of euthanasia and physician assisted suicide. Euthanasia is the act or practice of killing or permitting the death of hopelessly sick or injured individuals in a relatively painless way for reasons of mercy while Physician assisted suicide is suicide by a patient facilitated by means or by information provided by a physician aware of the patient's intent.... [tags: morality, ethics, death]
1192 words (3.4 pages)
- The central concern of this article is the ethical issue of patient’s autonomy when it comes to physician-assisted suicide. The author, Daniel E. Lee, opposes the idea of physician-assisted suicide agreeing that “it is for God and God alone to make an end of human life and that God gives life to us as an inalienable loan”. However, Daniel recognizes that there are compelling arguments in favor for the issue. He believes the best way to alleviate the situation is to respond “in a loving, caring manner,” in hopes that “suffering individuals” will rarely, if ever, choose physician-assisted suicide.... [tags: Suicide, Death, Assisted suicide]
1342 words (3.8 pages)
- Assisted Suicide Looking at this kind of situation through the perspective of deontology. Which means finding the right thing to do via duty and obligations. But there is also the idea that deontology can be made either religiously or secularly. It is also important that you do the right thing because it is right even if it causes pain or does not gift you happiness. So the situation of Dumbledore 's assisted suicide would be seen through secular deontology because we don 't hear about either wizards (Snape or Dumbledore) religious perspectives.... [tags: Ethics, Morality, Moral absolutism, Immanuel Kant]
935 words (2.7 pages)
- 1. The slippery slope argument for assisted suicide is a straightforward one to see and prove. In essence, it says that if assisted suicide is allowed without any principled lines or divisions, then we must allow for assisted suicide is clearly bad cases like that of “a sixteen-year-old suffering from a severe case of unrequited love.” First we must acknowledge the assumption that the Supreme Court has made, which is, there are no principled lines they can draw between the different cases of assisted suicide.... [tags: Supreme Court, modus tollens, morality]
1341 words (3.8 pages)