Comparing Robert Frost's Out Out and Seamus Heany's Mid Term Break Essay

Comparing Robert Frost's Out Out and Seamus Heany's Mid Term Break Essay

Length: 1583 words (4.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Comparing Robert Frost's Out Out and Seamus Heany's Mid Term Break
Works Cited Missing

The subject of both poems is the untimely death of young people in
tragic accidents rather than sickness. Strangely both boys are killed
by machinery, the boy in "Out, Out-' by a mechanical saw and the boy
in "Mid-Term Break" by a car. Both poems describe the reactions of the
families to the deaths each of the families reacting quite
differently. Both poems talk about the deaths of young boys who have
older or younger siblings; one has at least one sister, while the
other has an elder brother and a younger sibling.

"Mid-Term Break" is written in the first person and is a far more
personal poem consequently the emotions expressed in it are much
easier observe and appreciate than in "Out, Out-' which is written in
the third person, distancing the reader and giving a much colder
perspective of the events.

"Mid-Term Break" is set in Northern Irelandwhile "Out, Out-' is set
"far into Vermont".

"Mid-Term Break" tells the tale of an older brother summoned home from
college because of the death of his young brother who has been run
over by a car. The main part of the poem is set in the family home,
prepared for the brother's funeral. The family is traumatized by the
event the parents suffering mostly the "father crying' - the mother
"coughed out angry tearless sighs". "Out, Out-' presents a different
death scene - far more sudden and unanticipated during the poem. A boy
working in a family's saw house is out helping by sawing down trees.
His sister calls him for food, shouting "supper" and as a result, he
slips and the saw cuts his hand. Surprisi...


... middle of paper ...


...ferent religions with the Protestants either keeping their grief to
themselves or merely accepting God's hand in the tragedy while the
Catholics find solace in an open display of grief and the comfort of
ritual such as the flowers and candles and lying in state of the
corpse in an open coffin for people to pay their last respects.
Alternatively it may hint at a completely different lifestyle; while
the family in 'Mid Term Break' seem to be quite well off, the family
in 'Out, Out-' may have to concentrate on survival and therefore have
to carry on eking out a living and do not have the time nor the energy
to mourn. I cannot truthfully say that I enjoyed either of the two
poems, but they both dealt with the subject of the sudden death of a
child in ways that remain with you long after you have finished
reading the poems.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparing Robert Frost's Out Out and Seamus Heany's Mid Term Break Essay

- Comparing Robert Frost's Out Out and Seamus Heany's Mid Term Break Works Cited Missing The subject of both poems is the untimely death of young people in tragic accidents rather than sickness. Strangely both boys are killed by machinery, the boy in "Out, Out-' by a mechanical saw and the boy in "Mid-Term Break" by a car. Both poems describe the reactions of the families to the deaths each of the families reacting quite differently. Both poems talk about the deaths of young boys who have older or younger siblings; one has at least one sister, while the other has an elder brother and a younger sibling....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1583 words (4.5 pages)

Comparison of Robert Frost's and Seamus Heaney’s poetry, Essay

- In Seamus Heaney’s poetry, there is a recurring theme of his talking of the past, and more predominantly about significant moments in time, where he came to realisations that brought him to adulthood. In “Death of a Naturalist” Heaney describes a moment in his childhood where he learnt that nature was not as beautiful as seem to be when he was just a naive child. Heaney does this on a deeper level in “Midterm Break” describes his experience of his younger brothers funeral and the mixed, confusing feelings he encountered, consequently learning that he no longer was a child, and had no choice but to be exposed to reality....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Poetry]

Strong Essays
983 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about Compare “Out, Out” and Mid-Term Break

- In this essay I am going to compare two poems. “Out, Out” by Robert Frost a rural-American poet and Mid-Term Break by Seamus Heaney, an Irish poet. Both of these poems are based on child deaths. The title “Out, Out” is part of Shakespeare’s Macbeth. “Out, Out Brief Candle”. This coincides with the storyline of the poem, Child Deaths, because ‘brief candle’ implies that the candle went out nearly straight away. So this coincides with the poem because there is a death of a child, therefore the death is like a ‘brief candle’....   [tags: Poetry Analysis]

Strong Essays
1861 words (5.3 pages)

The Life of Seamus Heaney Essay

- Seamus Heaney described himself as person who “emerged from a hidden, a buried life and entered the realm of education” (“Seamus”). This quotation shows him transforming from a poor child living in a depressed farm town in Northern Ireland to turning into a Nobel Peace Prize poet and professor. He was a postmodern and contemporary poet who changed the Catholic and Protestant conflict into a literary debate. Without influential unorthodox poets like Heaney, the revolution would have ended extremely altered....   [tags: Editing suggestions are included in the essay.]

Strong Essays
1529 words (4.4 pages)

Seamus Heaney: A Brief Biography and Analysis Essay

- Seamus Heaney described himself as person who “emerged from a hidden, a buried life and entered the realm of education” (“Seamus Heaney”). This quotation showed him transforming from a poor child living in a depressed farm town in Northern Ireland to turning into a Nobel Peace Prize poet and professor. He was a postmodern and contemporary poet who changed the Catholic and Protestant conflict into a literary debate. Without influential unorthodox poets like Heaney, the revolution would have ended extremely changed....   [tags: Irish poets and playwrights]

Strong Essays
3132 words (8.9 pages)

Free Essay on Frost’s Out, out and Mid Term Break

- The Fragility of Life in Frost’s Out, out and Mid Term Break   The poem “Out, out” by Robert Frost is a poem about a young boy who uses a buzz saw.  When fate decides the boy’s time is up, the saw cuts the boy’s hand, and the boy slowly dies. The theme of “Out, out”, as well as “Mid Term Break”, is the fragility of life.   “Out, out”, like “Mid-Term Break” focuses on the issue of God’s randomness in choosing who lives and who doesn’t. This fragility is emphasized, as the title of the poem is a line from the play Macbeth, “Out, out brief candle, life is but a walking shadow.” This way of portraying life as a candle, gives the impression that whoever guards this candle could just as easil...   [tags: term out]

Free Essays
1841 words (5.3 pages)

A Comparison of Seamus Heaney's Mid-Term Break and Digging Essay

- A Comparison of Seamus Heaney's Mid-Term Break and Digging I am comparing two poems by Seamus Heaney- `Mid-Term Break` and `Digging`. Both of the poems are written about his childhood and his family. The first poem I analysed was `Mid-Term Break`, where the simple and straight forward title `Break` caught my attention suggesting to me that this poem is going to be a positive experience, a break from work, a time to relax. The commencing stanza, the first line reads, ?I sat all morning in the college sick bay?, which has connotation of depression, illness and suffering suggested from the word `sick`....   [tags: Seamus Heaney Break Digging Poems Essays]

Strong Essays
2070 words (5.9 pages)

Analysis of Birches by Robert Frost Essay

- Analysis of Birches by Robert Frost In the poem Birches by Robert Frost, Frost portrays the images of a child growing to adulthood through the symbolism of aging birch trees. Through these images readers are able to see the reality of the real world compared to their carefree childhood. The image of life through tribulation is the main focal point of the poem and the second point of the poem is if one could revert back to the simpler times of childhood. The language of the poem is entirely arranged through images, although it contains some diction it lacks sound devices, metaphors, and similes compared to other published works by Frost....   [tags: Birches Robert Frost Poetry Analysis]

Strong Essays
808 words (2.3 pages)

Robert Frost's The Oven Bird Essay example

- Robert Frost's The Oven Bird In his 1916 poem "The Oven Bird" (Baym, Vol. D 1188), Robert Frost chooses a title that presents a single, natural image of a particular species of bird. The title not only identifies this "mid-summer and...mid-wood" bird as the "singer everyone has heard" in the first line, it also establishes the "nature image" as a main theme in the poem. The bird's song presents images of "solid tree trunks," "flowers," and "pear and cherry bloom," while imposing its individual voice on the landscape....   [tags: Robert Frost]

Strong Essays
1728 words (4.9 pages)

Robert Frost Essay

- Robert Frost      Robert Frost, an Americian poet of the late 19th century, used nature in many of his writings. This paper will discuss the thought process of Frost during his writings, the many tools which he used, and provide two examples of his works.      Robert Frost was born in San Franciso on March 26, 1874, but later moved to Lawrence, Massachuschusetts (after his father died) where he did most of his writing. He was a simple man who taught, worked in a mill, was a reporter, was a New England farmer, and wrote....   [tags: Robert Frost Poet Poems Essays]

Strong Essays
1232 words (3.5 pages)