Reliable Historical Sources Essay example

Reliable Historical Sources Essay example

Length: 2758 words (7.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Reliable Historical Sources History is the study of the past, of what had really happened and who
were involved. To study history itself, it is essential that the
source from which the information were taken is factual as well as
reliable. It is not acceptable if it contains errors and flaws or
mixing the truth with some fictions. This essay will investigate and
evaluate a piece of historical evidence, the Hollywood movie The
Patriot starred by Mel Gibson and Heath Ledger in order to determine
whether or not it is reliable and could be used to determine the
events that really had happened during the American fight for

A way to determine the reliability of The Patriot as an accurate
historical source is by knowing whether it is a primary or a secondary
source of information. A primary source of historical information came
from a person who was directly involved during the period of time or a
document written during that period, such as diaries or the
Declaration of Independence. In this case, this movie is considered as
a secondary source. Some of the advantages of a primary source is that
it brings the researcher as close as possible to what actually
happened in the history and it is almost one hundred percent true. It
helps to know what the people involved think and their individual
viewpoints on certain events. However, the problem with primary source
is that want it or not, historians will have to believe what was
written on the source, since there will be not eyewitness three
hundred years after the event. This is quite challenging...

... middle of paper ...

... and mix the facts with fiction. There were a few events that really
did exist, but almost all parts of the movie are joined with made-up
events to add the spice in the action. However, the filmmakers did try
to make the movie as close as it was to the real events of the
American Revolution, basing the characters on real-life people and
bringing the scenes to life by breathtaking special effects and
costumes. What was lacking was probably only the essence of the
reliability of its facts and the truthfulness of all the events found
inside the movie. Therefore, although providing a fantastic movie with
great acting and special effects, it is concluded that The Patriot is
not an accurate historical source and could not be used as a reliable
documentation on the history of the Revolutionary War for Independence
of America.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Are the Stories from the Holocaust Survivors with PTSD Reliable as Historical Sources?

- ... (Barel, Efrat, 2010) There was a lot of psychological denial. There was not much help for the Jews once they were liberated, since doctors were scarce. Diseases were easy to catch, and life was still hard for the Jewish people. (Bettelheim, Bruno, 1979) Survivor’s Evidence Holocaust survivors can be defined as “any persecuted Jew who lived under Nazi occupation during the 2nd World War and who was thus threatened by the policy of the ‘final solution’ but managed to stay alive.” (Kellermann, Natan P.F., 2009) Survivor and Psychologist Viktor Frankl often stops throughout his novel, attempting to save the reader from the horror....   [tags: nazi occupation, jews, historians]

Powerful Essays
1852 words (5.3 pages)

Essay about Are Memoirs Reliable Sources?

- Are Memoirs Reliable Sources. Memoirs are a type of primary source, yet many historians do not believe they are as reliable as other primary sources. One of the reasons they do not think memoirs should be used as reliable sources is because of the amount of emotion and personal opinions shared through memoirs. Throughout this blog post I am going to dispute this by talking about how memoirs give an inside look into the thoughts and ideas of a person during a period of time. I am going to be specifically talking about Memoirs of a Jewish Extremist: The Story of a Transformation by Yossi Klein Halevi....   [tags: The Holocaust, Jews, Soviet Union, Nazi Germany]

Powerful Essays
927 words (2.6 pages)

Examining the Validity of Holocaust Sources Essay

- There are multiple sources with divergent advantages and strategies, which allow humanity to have a clearer understanding of the holocaust; when compared, the resources’ limitations become apparent. The graphic novel Maus appears less valid compared to the diary, Night with its heinous detailed experience of life in a concentration camp. Conversely, Maus exhibits a strong expression of themes throughout the novel; comparably, this is a restriction in the textbook, Europe in the Contemporary world....   [tags: Literature Review]

Powerful Essays
1602 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on The Debate Over Historical Information and Scientific Information

- To what extent is historical information more reliable than scientific information or vice versa. History is a collection of important events mostly written by the victors. Whereas, Natural or human sciences are information about the universe as well as the human mind and body. But, to what extent is one reliable more than the other. History is an interesting Area of Knowledge and relies on many Ways of Knowing in order to function and to be understood. By understanding how these Ways of Knowing are used in History one can determine how reliable historical information is....   [tags: Past, Future, Comparative Essay]

Powerful Essays
1187 words (3.4 pages)

The Use of Oral Sources Essay

- I, like many others, learnt about the history of my family through chatting with those who remembered them, hearing the stories of the good old days, and discovering the significant events that shaped my families’ lives. I caught the gossip and even learnt the songs they sang as they shared in jollification and other family customs, all from the memories of those who were there. This provided answers, gave me a sense of belonging and anecdotes I can pass down for generations. Family history gives a strong sense of a much longer lifespan and will survive beyond death....   [tags: Reliability of Oral History]

Powerful Essays
1674 words (4.8 pages)

Hadith Reports as a Historical Source Essay

- There are many controversies surrounding the first century of Islamic history. Historians often have trouble agreeing on whether or not it is reliable to use hadith literature as a source for the origins of Islam considering a large amount of hadiths surfaced well after the time of Muhammad. Many historians find issue with the isnad and matn of hadith. Historians argue that these can be easily forged given the nature of how hadith is transmitted by word of mouth. Another problem with using hadith as a historical source for the origins of Islam is that many hadith collections contain anachronisms, which, again raises questions about the reliability of such collections....   [tags: Origins of Islam, Controvery, History, Islam]

Powerful Essays
1012 words (2.9 pages)

The Fires of Jubilee: How Reliable is It? Essay

- The Fires of Jubilee, by Stephen B. Oates, tells an account of Nat Turner’s rebellion. Beginning with Nat’s early life and finally ending with the legacy his execution left the world, Oates paints a historical rending of those fateful days. The Confessions of Nat Turner by Thomas R. Gray and approved by Nat himself is among Oates’ chief sources. Oates is known as a reputable historian through his other works, and has strong credentials however, in the case of The Fires of Jubilee there are some limitations....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Powerful Essays
1472 words (4.2 pages)

Historical Anyalysis Essay

- There is a common mistake that people make when concerning history. They make the mistake of assuming that history is what happened in the past, but history is much more than what happened in the past. History is formed from analyzing evidence from the past and making a connection. Many historians have different personal perspectives on history, and by using the historical method they can all draw conclusions as to what happened and advocate a theory. We find that history is much more than what happened in the past from reading, "The Strange Death of Silas Deane." This is a good example of applying the historical methods and producing a new theory based on reliable evidence....   [tags: American History]

Powerful Essays
2121 words (6.1 pages)

Historical Methodology Essays

- Historical Methodology The Strange Career of Jim Crow, by C. Van Woodward, traces the history of race relations in the United States from the mid and late nineteenth century through the twentieth century. In doing so Woodward brings to light significant aspects of Reconstruction that remain unknown to many today. He argues that the races were not as separate many people believe until the Jim Crow laws. To set up such an argument, Woodward first outlines the relationship between Southern and Northern whites, and African Americans during the nineteenth century....   [tags: Racism Literature Books Papers]

Powerful Essays
2024 words (5.8 pages)

Essay on Albert Speer - Differing Historical Interpretations

- They are many factors influencing the different historical interpretations of Albert Speer. The most influential was Speer’s own character construction of himself in his defence at the Nuremberg trials. This view was held by a majority of historians until Matthias Schmidt found holes in Speer’s story. A large blow was dealt to Speer’s own construction of his role in Nazi Germany when the Walters’ chronicles were released containing various incriminating evidence. There are still a number of historians who prefer to view Albert Speer as the Good Nazi, even though most historians now believe that the image created by Speer of himself was self-serving and false....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
894 words (2.6 pages)