In this essay I will argue that the developments in the law
surrounding an action for breach of confidence have not drawn an
equitable and acceptable balance between the privacy of, and free
expression about, public figures due to the evolutionary nature of
common law. Furthermore, due to the unwillingness of the judiciary to
address an independent tort of privacy it may well be time for the
Government to legislate. I will address this by considering the
development of the laws of breach of confidence prior to the
introduction of the Human Rights Act in 2000, and by looking at how
they have addressed the balance between free expression and a right to
privacy in its aftermath.
Protection of Privacy through Breach of Confidence.
The existence of a right to privacy in English law has been a source
of judicial and academic debate for the past two centuries. The law of
breach of confidence has traditionally been cited as the foremost
guardian of any right to privacy. In Prince Albert v. Strange,
breach of confidence was applied successfully with Sir Knight Bruce
V.-C. referring to a "sordid spying into privacy of domestic life".
It was this case that formed the centrepiece of Warren and Brandeis'
affirmation of a right to privacy, which led to the development of the
law in America, yet in England there was still a preference to deal
with potential privacy cases through existing rights of action.
The law of breach of confidence was widened over the course of the 20th
Century to the point where Lord Keith stated in Attorney-General v.
... middle of paper ...
... Greenwood, W, ' McNae's Essential Law For
Journalists' (17th ed, LexisNexis UK) Page 433
 Douglas v. Hello!Ltd (No.1) Q.B. 967 (CA)
  2 W.L.R. 1038 (Fam Div)
  EWCA Civ 337;  Q.B. 195 (CA)
 Theakston v. MGN Ltd. QBD  EWHC 137 (QB)
  E.M.L.R. 41
 Unreported 2001 WL 676718
  EWHC 499; E.M.L.R. 30.
 [2002 EWCA Civ 1373;  2.W.L.R.80.
  EWHC 786; (2003) 153 N.L.J. (Ch D)
 (44647/98)  E.M.L.R. 15 (ECHR)
  EWCA Civ 2081;  Q.B. 1334 (CA)
 R.Singh "Privacy Postponed"  E.H.R.L.R. 12
 Home Office v. Wainwright  EWCA Civ 2081;  Q.B. 1334
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- If a breach of contract is both material and opportunistic, the injured promisee has a claim in restitution to the profit realized by the defaulting promisor as a result of the breach. Liability in restitution with disgorgement of profit is an alternative to liability for contract damages measured by injury to the promisee. Commentators have described section 39 's adoption as the equivalent of a "quiet revolution" that "is breathtaking in its potential transformation of the traditional contractual landscape.” Caprice L.... [tags: Contract, Common law, Breach of contract, Law]
731 words (2.1 pages)
- Legal Issues A legal discussion of the contractual breaches and their related legal elements will be examined in this section. Some of the legal issues surrounding the contractual breaches include, the legal implications of the Uniform Commercial Code (U.C.C.), the defendant’s engagement in and outputs contract while under a requirements contract with my company, the doctrine of estoppel, and the issues of good faith and fair dealing. The definitions and some of the legal implications of the implied and requirements contracts were discussed in the preceding sections.... [tags: Contract law, Contract, Breach of contract]
904 words (2.6 pages)
- Issue: The issue is whether Ms. Carver is liable for breach of contract with Mr. Anderson and GTF. Rule: A contract requires four key elements: agreement, consideration, capacity, and legality (Kubasek, 306). Not completing one element of the contract renders it void or voidable. Minors, or people under the age of 18 (41-1-101), are allowed to enter into contract in the same way that adults can; all contracts that minors enter into are voidable and can be disaffirmed by the minor (41-1-302). Also, a lawyer or guardian cannot disaffirm the contract.... [tags: Contract, Breach of contract, Contract law]
957 words (2.7 pages)
- The issue in this case is whether Big Board has breached contract and the damages available to Specialty and the reasoning behind them. Breach of contract is a situation that occurs if one or both of the parties do not perform their duties as specified in the contract. If a contract has not been discharged or excused, the contracting party owes an absolute duty (covenant) to perform the duty. There are 3 levels of performance of a contract, complete, substantial and inferior. Complete performances discharge the parties from the contract.... [tags: Breach of contract, Contract, Contract law]
865 words (2.5 pages)
- Jon Marunowski November 20, 2016 Liberty University TO: Alex Fairchild, Mediator FROM: Marshall Peterson DATE: November 19, 2016 SUBJECT: Resolution of dispute to the breach of contract from the producers of Muscadine Products I, Marshall Peterson, am seeking resolution and restitution of damages for breach of contract by the producers of the Muscadine product line. Such contracts that have been violated have been the Good Faith and Fair Dealings relationship developed over the years and also the Requirement Contract said company and I signed quite some time ago stating a guaranteed price schedule that has stayed consistent since the beginning of the business relationship.... [tags: Contract, Contract law, Breach of contract]
1014 words (2.9 pages)
- Breach and its Consequences Any director who breaches his/her of duty is liable to reimburse the business for any damage or loss, which the company has faced as a result of the breach. In the majority of circumstances, the actions of the directors will be considered the actions of the business itself, hence being in consistence of the principles of company law. Therefore, any failure committed under this principle, will be considered a failure of the company itself and not of the director. However, the protection from personal accountability is not an absolute, thus, any person performing as a director should be cognizant that there might be both civil and criminal consequences whenever they... [tags: Law, Common law, Corporation, English law]
1077 words (3.1 pages)
- Final Paper Business Law 201 Keith S. Ferguson This is a complex case, involving multiple parties and several variables that need to be examined thoroughly. The parties mentioned include Knarles operator of the facility maintenance company, his son Barkley, their employee, a licensed plumber, and Mr. Chetum. Although in the end Chetum is suing the facilities maintenance firm for a breach of contract, all factors must be examined to determine proper fault. Knarles’ company is based in Maryland and does business in DC, Maryland, and Virginia.... [tags: Contract, Law, Tort, Breach of contract]
2539 words (7.3 pages)
A Case Of Unauthorized Practice Of Law And A Breach Of The American Bar Association 's Paralegal Codes Of
- Alice and Amber both participated in a severe case of unauthorized practice of law and a breach of the American Bar Association’s Paralegal Codes of Ethics. They did this on more than one occasion while dealing with a case involving a car crash that they witnessed. Amber is a newly licensed practicing Paralegal with the law firm Penrod and Penrod. This means that Amber is bound by the American Bar Association’s (ABA) Paralegal Codes of Ethics as are all practicing and certified paralegals. Alice Penrod is one of the partners of the firm Penrod and Penrod.... [tags: Lawyer, Law, Practice of law, Ethics]
954 words (2.7 pages)
- Breach of contracts can have serious damages for businesses. An expected service or agreement that is no longer met or kept impacts everyone involved. A breach of contract can reduce earnings while also potentially harming future profits. It also puts a company’s value at risk if they cannot meet demands for products or meet deadlines. There are often damages that result from contract claims and breaches. Claims are made by both parties involved to argue over projected lost revenues, sales impacts, lost value, and added costs resulting from the breach.... [tags: Breach of contract, Contract, Mathematics]
728 words (2.1 pages)
- Introduction Jane, Jerry and Sam is attempting to launch proceedings against NAP for loss rising from cancellation of the competition outlined in the question. The plaintiffs’ actions would depend on whether there is a breach of contract by NAP. It is essential that key facts come under close scrutiny and are considered in relation to contract law. In order to advise Jane, Jerry and Sam the application of the common law of contract will determine if a contract exists, terms of the contract and whether a breach of contract has occurred.... [tags: Contract, Contract law, Breach of contract]
1805 words (5.2 pages)