Comparing Weber's and Durkheim's Methodological Contributions to Sociology

Comparing Weber's and Durkheim's Methodological Contributions to Sociology

Length: 1739 words (5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Comparing Weber's and Durkheim's Methodological Contributions to Sociology

This essay will be examining the methodological contributions both
Durkheim and Weber have provided to sociology. It will briefly observe
what Positivists are and how their methodologies influence and affect
their research. It will also consider what interpretative sociology
is, and why their type of methodology is used when carrying out
research. It will analyse both Durkheim's study of Suicide and also
Webers study of The Protestant work ethic, and hopefully establish how
each methodology was used for each particular piece of research, and

Emile Durkhiem, in sociology terminology is considered to be a
Functionalist, in addition to also being a Positivist, however,
strictly speaking, Durkheim was not a Positivist. This is because he
did not follow the positivist rule that states that sociological study
should be confined to observable or directly measurable phenomena.

Functionalists believe that in order for society to function
correctly, there need to be shared values to help maintain social
order. Society is viewed as a stable, orderly system. This stable
system is in equilibrium and reflects societal consensus where the
majority of members share a common set of values, beliefs, and social
expectations. Functionalists also believe that society consists of
interrelated parts; each part serves a function and contributes to the
stability of the society.

Positivists believe that as a science, sociology can be objective and
value-free. Disinterested scientific observers shouldn't and don't
necessarily introduce bias into the research process. ...

... middle of paper ...

...our different types of suicide, and
that most suicides can fall into one of those categories. Although
sociologists like J.D. Douglas would question the reliability of the
statistics, due to the coroners decision being final, most
sociologists would agree that Durkheim's study into suicide was
successful, and indeed many have tried to develop and improve on his
theory. Overall, this essay has shown that one type of methodology may
not always be suitable for the particular research carried out. Both
Interpretative sociology and the Positivist approach equally show that
they are valid methods for carrying out research, but like everything,
nothing is one hundred percent accurate. Therefore, there is always
room for flaw, but in the study of Sociology, there is always room for
more ways of obtaining and interpreting data.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Contributions of Emile Durkheim Essay

- Sociology is the study of the structure of groups, organizations, and societies, and how individuals interact within these environments. Sociology at one time was not a respectable or well-known field of study until Emile Durkheim, a college professor, made sociology a part of the French college curriculum. Durkheim is regarded as one of the founders of sociology. He introduced sociology as a branch of learning separate from other sciences by declaring that sociologists must examine specific characteristics of group life....   [tags: Sociology]

Powerful Essays
2391 words (6.8 pages)

Emile Durkheim and The Science of Sociology Essays

- Introduction Emile Durkheim was born in France in April of 1858 and died in November of 1917. He was from a close Jewish community that he continued to be close to even after breaking with the Jewish church. Having come from a long family line of rabbis, he had planned to follow in that profession. Durkheim was known as the Father of Sociology. He was a liberal, a modernist, and a nationalist. He was a very ambitious man; this ambition was illustrated by the accomplishments he made over the course of his life....   [tags: Sociology Essays]

Powerful Essays
1278 words (3.7 pages)

Essay about Marx, Durkheim, Weber and Sociology

- The theoretical works of Karl Marx, Emile Durkheim and Max Weber still influence sociological theory. Though their works are decades old they still are a major part of what sociology is today. Though their theories can seem very different, there are some similarities. To become a great sociologist one most learn and understands how to use all sociological perspectives. To do this one must understand and use the different theoretical perspectives created by Marx, Durkheim, and Weber. Karl Marx theoretical perspective on conflict is by far one the most interesting theories in sociology....   [tags: Sociology Essays]

Powerful Essays
1667 words (4.8 pages)

Emile Durkheim, the Father of Sociology Essay

- All great things in life start off with people whom we would never have guessed imaginable. Who would have thought the study of society would have amounted to anything or become a significant part of people's lives. In the late 1800s people had a very small mindset which involved not knowing or even caring about what the outside world was like. The people knew things occurred in their society, but they never knew why nor did they care to find out. The society was run by religion and they did not question it....   [tags: Suicide, Social Issues]

Powerful Essays
2017 words (5.8 pages)

Durkheim's Work in Sociology Essay

- Durkheim's Work in Sociology "Some studies maybe more recent, but Durkheim's work remains the most significant Sociological analysis of Suicide in modern societies" Assess the extent to which Sociological arguments and evidence support this claim. In regards to Suicide it would seem perhaps more realistic to consider the subject as an individual and personal act, a job which might seem more suitable for Psychologists to explain, it may not seem an obvious subject for a Sociologist to study....   [tags: Sociology Essays]

Powerful Essays
1485 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about The Social Causes of Suicide and Durkheim's Theory

- Durkheim was a functionalist, and theorised that a holistic social narrative could be identified which would explain individual behaviour. He argued that, whilst society was made up of its members, it was greater than the sum of its parts, and was an external pressure that determined the behaviour of the individuals within it. At that time, suicide rates in Europe were rising, and so the causes of suicide were on the agenda. Since suicide is seen as an intrinsically personal and individual action, establishing it as having societal causes would be a strong defence for Durkheim’s functionalist perspective....   [tags: Sociology, Suicide, Durkheim, ]

Powerful Essays
1907 words (5.4 pages)

The Fathers of Sociology Essay

- With reference to examples of their published works assess respectively the work of Marx, Durkheim and Weber. Write one thousand words on each. In the final section, critically assess which of the three theorists has the most contemporary relevance. The fathers of sociology are known as Karl Marx, Emilen Durkheim and Karl Weber they made profound contributions towards study of sociology. This essay will explore the key theoretical concepts for each theorist beginning with Marx thoughts on capitalism, class struggle, materialism, then followed by Weber’s ……………………………… and Finally Durkheim ideas on ………………....   [tags: Karl Marx, Emilen Durkheim, Karl Weber]

Powerful Essays
1539 words (4.4 pages)

Comparing and Contrasting Sociological Theorists Max Weber, Emile Durkheim and Karl Marx

- Emile Durkheim, Karl Marx, and Max Weber are all important characters to be studied in the field of Sociology. Each one of these Sociological theorists, help in the separation of Sociology into its own field of study. The works of these three theorists is very complex and can be considered hard to understand but their intentions were not. They have their similarities along with just as many of their differences. The first theorist to consider is Karl Marx. Marx has a uniqueness all of his own. His attention was normally directed towards capitalism in society....   [tags: sociology]

Powerful Essays
1584 words (4.5 pages)

Perspectives of Sociology Essay

- 1. Compare and Contrast the three perspectives in Sociology. Functionalism- A theoretical perspective, associated with Emile Durkheim, based on an analogy between social systems and organic systems. The character of a society's various institutions must be understood in terms of the function each performs in enabling the smooth running of society as a whole. Stable and made of intellectual social structures that work in harmony. Against change and believes changes reinforces the death of society....   [tags: Sociology Essays]

Free Essays
1858 words (5.3 pages)

Sociology Essays

- Sociology Miss Rowbotham Education Using material from Item A and elsewhere, assess the contribution of functionalist sociology to an understanding of the role of education in society A) Explain what is meant by ‘streaming’. (2 marks) Streaming is when you organise children into different classes in school depending on their ability. B) Give two examples of ways in which the school curriculum may be seen as ethnocentric. (4 marks) The school curriculum may be seen as ethnocentric as they only teach main culture/religion subjects and they do not give children a broad education....   [tags: Sociology Essays]

Powerful Essays
641 words (1.8 pages)