The Crisis of Development Discourse
The rise of development theory has been an interesting phenomenon. In the latter half of the 20th century, many theorists have tried to explain the origins of "under-development." The debate over the idea of development has been intense, and has led to the emergence of two contending paradigms: Modernization theory and dependency theory. Upon close investigation, one realizes that both theories are problematic. This paper is based on readings of Escobar, Martinussen, Cruise O'Brien, and Pieterse. The purpose of this paper is to chronicle the origins and growth of development discourse, and to show how both paradigms share three flaws: an economist approach to social change, and an ethnocentric and teleological worldview of development, and the perceived universal application of the West's development experience throughout the developing world.
As Escobar points out in The Problematization of Poverty, one of the many changes in the post-WW2 era was the "discovery" of mass poverty throughout the world. This "discovery" had massive implications for development discourse. Prior to WW2, development discourse was limited to the colonial experience. But with the end of colonial rule lurking on the horizon, western academics began to formulate theories of economic growth and "modernization." As a result, an entire genre of academic research emerged: the development discourse. The aim of development discourse was to chart out patterns of growth (which were based on the historical successes of the West) that newly independent countries could use, primarily to escape vicious cycles of poverty, famine, etc.
The birth of development discourse was inherently one-sid...
... middle of paper ...
...979
Pieterse, Jan. "Dilemmas of Development Discourse: The Crisis of Developmentalism and the Comparative Method" in Development and Change 22 (1991)
Notes
1 Escobar, Arturo. Encountering Development. Princeton University Press, 1995. P. 24
2 Ibid. Pp. 23-24
3 Emphasis added by author
4 Ibid. Pp. 52-54
5 Martinussen, John. Society, State and Market. Zed Books, 1997. P. 57
6 Ibid. Pp. 59-60
7 Ibid. Pp. 61-65
8 Ibid. Pp. 88-91
9 Pieterse, Jan Nederveen. Dilemmas of Development Discourse: The Crisis of Developmentalism and the
Comparative Method. P. 15
10 Ibid. P. 15
11 Ibid. P. 15
12 Ibid. P. 17
13 Escobar, Arturo. Encountering Development. Princeton University Press, 1995. P. 25
14 Ibid. P. 44
15 Pieterse, Jan Nederveen. Dilemmas of Development Discourse. P. 18
and to deny that its meaning is not completely true in all senses is a
Both arguments concerning the obstacles to development make valid points. The neoliberalism position focuses on the misguided policies enforced by the developing states. They argue that excessive government control of the domestic and the international economy of the state prevents economic growth, while fiscal discipline and non-intervention by the state’s governments allows the economy to stimulate. On the other hand, the dependency theory perspective, which focuses on the global order between rich and poor nations, argues that the wealthy states exploit the weak states, therefore, producing underdevelopment and global inequality.
This report will explore the theoretical approach of Post-colonialism in economic development. The report with the help of India as a case study will aim to explain how the theory of Post-colonialism has shaped understanding and approaches to international development.
The simplistic and highly misleading view that depicts the poorer world as passive victims at the mercy of the powerful West has meant that postwar paradigms or in-arguments “for how to conceptualize and overcome development challenges” (City of Johannesburg, 2006) have failed to achieve long-term development outcomes. For example, modernization theory (MT) stated that with investment and planning from the Industrial West, all states could follow a liner process of development where traditional sectors of the economy and rigid social structures would be abandoned and replaced by modern social organisation (Nabudere, 1997; Jolly et. al., 2004; MacKinnon & Cumbers, 2011). In other words, it was believed that once Rostow’s ‘take-off’ stage was
...ization.'; (Jackson p.440) Dependency theory actually suggests that LDCs should not follow the Western route to development. It also suggests that forcing the undeveloped countries to compete globally will only increase the gap between Third World countries and developed states. In other word, it increases poverty in those Third World countries. The existence of these Third World countries is only to provide cheap labors for the benefit of richer states. In the above case (Indonesia), government growed crops that are for sale on the world market for cheap prices rather than to provide food for the poor. This is a good example of benefiting the Western states while giving up the whole interest of domestic people.
In world religion, gender inequality has always been a great concern. This inequality did not exist based on the concepts of original religion but through cultural influence and social manipulation. The essence of Buddhism originated from a human being (known as Buddha). And Buddha is the one who achieved the highest enlightenment. Often in Buddhism concept, there was confusion about how much devotion is required to achieve the great “Enlightenment” for monk or nun. Women in the Buddhism face much more challenges to become enlightened. Throughout the essay, I will be focusing on how in Buddhist woman needs to be reborn as a man to be fully enlightened. This means this essay will examine the difficulties women face as a nun and how they are never reached “bodhisattva”. My views will be justified through Buddha’s opinion about women, women in Theravada and Mahayana Buddhism and challenges Buddhist women faced due to culture and social context.
Modernisation theory has been a dominant theory since post-World War II (McMichael 2012:5) to describe development and social change. It is structured and outlined through five different stages of 'development ladder' proposed by Walt Whitman Rostow in The Stages of Economic Growth: A Non-Communist Manifesto. (1961:4) The first premise of modernisation theory reflected by 'development ladder' is that development happened in a sequential process through stage by stage while the second premise underpinned by ‘development ladder’ is conformity towards West's values and norms. However, these two premises are found to be problematic as they are neglecting the differences in societies and assuming that the 'development ladder' system is applicable to all societies. Thus, Rostow's 'development ladder' is highly challenged as it gathers a lot of critiques.
The Oxford Dictionary defines sexism as “Prejudice, stereotyping, or discrimination, typically against women, on the basis of sex”. While sexism has been present in most aspects of human life both today and in the past, religion remains one of the oldest sources and justifications of this behaviour. However, two religions, Christianity and Islam, present two views of the topic. Both the sexist and non-sexist aspects will be examined and compared in this text in order to prove whether or not these religions are inherently sexist. 85
The Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines development as the act or process of growing or causing something to grow larger or more advanced. We live in a world that is continuously developing, in ways that we cannot even begin to try to describe. Nonetheless, The World Bank measures indicators of development. To do this, they look at three-hundred and thirty-one different indicators which cover a vast number of areas, including agriculture, aid effectiveness, climate change, economic policy, education, energy and mining, environment, the financial sector, poverty, science and technology, social development, and urban development. The World Bank’s World Development Indicators data is has been used for over fifty years as the standard by which development is measured. While this list may seem like a comprehensive, all-inclusive list, it does not consider the idea of sustainable development. While development for the sake of advancement may seem like a good option for an undeveloped country, it can be argued that development that is not sustainable is not development at all, but merely the illusion of one.
In this book Ferguson aims to create an understanding of the workings of the concept of development through the case study of the Thaba-Tseka Development Project. To achieve this he gives detailed accounts of the setting and conditions of the project, as well as emphasize where and how development practitioners went wrong in this particular case.
Smith, R.K. (1996). Understanding third world politics: theories of political change and development. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
When looking through the topic of development, two drastically different ways to assess it arise. The majority of the western world looks at development in terms of per capita GNP. This means each country is evaluated on a level playing field, comparing the production of each country in economic value. Opposite this style of evaluation is that of the alternative view, which measures a country’s development on its ability to fulfill basic material and non-material needs. Cultural ties are strong in this case as most of the population does not produce for wealth but merely survival and tradition.
Gender Issues in Religion Amongst the world religions are many different attitudes towards gender issues and sexuality issues. A hundred years ago, or even a lot less. these different perspectives did not exist, as they were often. considered unimportant, as King noted until recently little attention.
Rodney’s argument is broken down into six chapters each consisting of several subdivisions and case studies supporting his principle argument. The first chapter works towards defining the terms of development and underdevelopment and argues the comparative nature of these terms; a country is only ‘underdeveloped’ by European standards. This chapter begins by tracing European development from its early stages of communalism through feudalism and finally capitalism. Then, he works towards developing an understanding of the term ‘underdevelopment’ and through an analysis of a variety of development indices what it constitutes in present day society: “In Niger, one doctor must do for 56, 140 people; in Tunisia one doctor for every 8,320 Tunisians”(18). The Marxist concept of inherent inequalities within the international capitalist system un...
This essay will argue for the importance of historical analysis in understanding development and social change. This essay will first provide an understanding of what historical analysis is, and from here look at the dominant theories comprising development and social change, and how these two entities are contrasted. Following this, an example of historical analysis will be used to demonstrate how historical analysis can provide depth and value when understanding development and social change. Finally, limitations to historical analysis will be considered. Throughout the course of this essay, references will be made to various theorists and scholars to support assertions.