Essay on Comparing A Case of Identity and The Stolen Cigar Case

Essay on Comparing A Case of Identity and The Stolen Cigar Case

Length: 1099 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Comparing A Case of Identity and The Stolen Cigar Case

There are two forms of detective story: there is the 'who dunnit' idea
in which gentlemen detectives are called upon in all sorts of
impossible situations, but always manage to solve the crime. In this
type, the reader has a good idea of who committed the 'crime';
however, the characters in the story don't. The other type of story is
a mystery, in which neither reader nor investigators know who is
responsible for the crime; together with the characters, the reader
too is invited to figure out the sequence of events.

In the Sherlock Holmes stories the focus is on the character of the
detective himself (Sherlock Holmes) and follows the story of him
solving a mystery. Sherlock Holmes (S.H) was a legendary figure as he
was the very first fictional detective; his stories were written in
the Victorian times by the writer Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.

The S.H stories have many common features. For example S.H is seen to
be very well organised and by the end, his efforts have concluded in
solving the mystery/crime. This has made it easier for Bret Harte to
parody Conan Doyle's style; he uses many similar features like the
same old fashioned language and also in having Sherlock Holmes or
Hemlock Jones (as he is called in the parody), portrayed as a very
precise, eccentric detective.

In the original story, we are told of how Miss Mary Sunderland goes to
S.H to find Mr Hosmer Angel-her missing bridegroom-who disappeared on
the day of their wedding. S.H manages to find this man, so uncovering
the fact that it is her step-father in disguise!

In the parody; 'The Stolen Cigar Case', Hemloc...


... middle of paper ...


...ered your honour for it-that stolen cigar
case was the purchaser of the sealskin coat". This left Watson
stunned. However by the time H.J has finished his long speech about
how Watson must have taken it, Watson was left doubting his own
sanity, Even though he knew deep down he hadn't stolen the cigar case.
When Hemlock realised that it had been in his draw all along he was
"vexed" and in shock as he said slowly "I have been mistaken", despite
this he still didn't apologise to Watson for accusing him.

I think Bret Harte did an effective parody of the Sherlock Holmes
stories as they are already over the top to start with, so it must
have been difficult to compete with that. I think he achieved a comic
affect within his version of the story and was good at enlarging the
ridiculousness of it for the humour of the reader.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Shattered Dreams in Stolen Party Essay

- Shattered Dreams in Stolen Party In the story "Stolen Party" written by Liliana Heker, a girl’s dreams are shattered by the bitter reality of her destiny. Rosaura spends most of her time trying to convince her mother, as well as everyone at the birthday party, that being an educated girl makes her an equal to everyone at the party. She feels great determination to become a part of her friend Luciana’s lifestyle even though it would be rebelling against her mother’s wishes. Rosaura almost believes she has accomplished this feat until she is harshly brought back to reality and faced with her position in life once again....   [tags: stolen]

Free Essays
590 words (1.7 pages)

The Stolen Bacillus by H.G. Wells Essay

- The Stolen Bacillus by H.G. Wells This is a story set in the 19th century people had dress codes which reflected your status in society. The dress code was formal and quite severe it was almost as if the longer your top hat the higher up the rank you are in importance in society. In this story we meet a man who wants to help the society and quality of living whereas the other wants to destroy order as he is what’s known as an anarchist. This is someone who is feels that people should be responsible for there own actions and decisions meaning they govern their own lives....   [tags: Stolen Bacillus Wells Essays]

Strong Essays
819 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on Analysis of W.B.Yeats' The Stolen Child

- Analysis of W.B.Yeats' The Stolen Child       The Stolen Child was written by W.B.Yeats in 1886.  The Victorian Era of literature was in full swing, while upstart new poets, dissatisfied with the 'airy' nature of earlier poetic works, began demanding more concrete, realistic, and hard-hitting literature that avoided the metaphorical distancing that the Romantics were prone to.  They scoffed at Yeats, at his romantic views, at his out-dated style of writing.  Frustrated, perhaps even angered, by the scorn of his upcoming peers, Yeats would soon find himself wavering between the more fantastical style of his youth, and the harder-edged stuff that would come to be found in Easter 191...   [tags: Yeats Stolen Child Essays]

Strong Essays
1009 words (2.9 pages)

An Individual 's Sense Of Identity Essay

- An individual’s sense of identity is remarkably complex and quite knowingly influenced by many factors throughout their lifetime. The traumatic and challenging experiences that these children had to endure, such as rape and abuse have had an immense impact upon their sense of identity during their lifespan. Taking children away from their homes and land was considered a charitable deed, but only to the people who were taking or sending them away. These children had no way of preparing for what was to come ahead and how much their simple lives would change....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Stolen Generations]

Strong Essays
1604 words (4.6 pages)

The Stolen Child by W.B. Yeats Essay

- The Stolen Child by W.B. Yeats      “The Stolen Child”, a poem by W.B. Yeats, can be analyzed on several levels. The poem is about a group of faeries that lure a child away from his home “to the waters and the wild”(chorus). On a more primary level the reader can see connections made between the faery world and freedom as well as a societal return to innocence. On a deeper and second level the reader can infer Yeats’ desire to see a unified Ireland of simpler times. The poem uses vivid imagery to establish both levels and leaves room for open interpretation especially with the contradictory last stanza....   [tags: Stolen Child Poem Yeats Essays]

Strong Essays
804 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on A Lesson About Life in The Stolen Party

- A Lesson About Life in The Stolen Party      In Liliana Heker’s story, "The Stolen Party," the young child Rosaura is hurt because she is a victim of a class structure which keeps the rich on the top and people like her and her mother at the bottom of society. By the end of the story Rosaura will have learned a very important lesson in class structure which, because it is so traumatic for her, she will carry with her for the rest of her life. The first evidence we see which supports the claim that this is a story of class structure comes when Rosaura’s mother says to her, "I don’t like you going, it’s a rich people’s party" (Heker 1133)....   [tags: Stolen Party Essays]

Strong Essays
890 words (2.5 pages)

Pettiness of the Wealthy Exposed in The Stolen Party Essay

- Pettiness of the Wealthy Exposed in The Stolen Party       In Liliana Heker’s short story, "The Stolen Party," Senora Ines invited Rosaura to the party for only one reason, to serve. Rosaura was a very smart girl in school, but she lacked people smarts. Senora Ines told Rosaura that she would be a guest there but tricked Rosaura into being a helper instead of a guest. Senora Ines needed Rosaura to help at the party so she mislead Rosaura by making her tasks seem as if they were privileges. Senora Ines’ deviousness ultimately devastated poor, innocent Rosaura....   [tags: Stolen Party Essays]

Strong Essays
668 words (1.9 pages)

Essay about Dissatisfaction with Society Revealed in Yeats’ Stolen Child

- Dissatisfaction with Society Revealed in Yeats’ Stolen Child The Stolen Child,"a poem by W.B. Yeats, relates the story of a child who is lured away by fairies to a fantasy world illustrated through rich descriptions of nature and the freedom it offers. The plot of the poem becomes a metaphor for the return to innocence that the author feels is necessary in a society that is attempting to lead children away from the mysticism and innocence that characterize childhood, toward a more mundane reality as an adult....   [tags: Yeats Stolen Child Essays]

Strong Essays
992 words (2.8 pages)

A Two-Class Society Exposed in The Stolen Party Essay

- A Two-Class Society Exposed in The Stolen Party   In a perfect world we would all live together in peace. But we don’t live in such a world. In Liliana Heker’s story "The Stolen Party" we are reminded of the real world and the thin line that separates the lower class from the upper class. In an instant we see all the discrimination and inhumane treatment some people feel they have a right to inflict on those whom they consider "not one of them." The story is about Rosaura, the nine-year-old daughter of a woman who does housecleaning for a wealthy family....   [tags: Stolen Party Essays]

Strong Essays
1288 words (3.7 pages)

Stolen Essay

- Jimmy and Ruby are the most obvious victims in Stolen, but all suffer in their different ways. Discuss The most obvious victims in a tragedy like the Stolen generation are those in whom the pain and suffering endured is visible to all. Jane Harrison’s ‘Stolen’ presents Ruby and Jimmy as the most obvious victims but not necessarily the greatest, as may be naively assumed. The remaining characters, Anne, Shirley and Sandy all suffer huge depths of despair, yet their suffering appears to lessen to some degree in the eyes of the viewer/reader due to their hope, determination and stability which in some ways assist them in attempting to resolve their problems and become reunited with their lov...   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
906 words (2.6 pages)