Life in the trenches was horrific; the frontline soldiers dreaded
having to return to them. During their tour of duty there, they lived
in considerable tension. The trenches were far from safe; possibly one
third of all casualties on the Weston front were killed or wounded in
the trenches, mostly from artillery fire.
In this essay I will be discussing and comparing the accuracy and
differences between the soldiers' accounts of the trenches and
official accounts composed by the government. I will use my own
knowledge as well as many sources from the booklet provided. The
sources that I shall use will come from many categories including
primary accounts of soldiers in the trenches, photographs, paintings,
propaganda and official government accounts. I will note the uses of
the sources including their strengths and weaknesses, their
provenance, reliability the importance and usefulness as well as the
limitations of their usefulness.
In section A, I will look at sources from history textbooks describing
what life was like in the trenches. Most of the sources in this
section are official accounts produced by the government and are
therefore probably reliable however there is evidence to suggest that
these are used for propaganda or censored.
Section B sources are also official accounts describing life in the
trenches but these sources are photographs and drawings, these may be
useful, but not very reliable as some of the photographers and artists
were appointed by the government and may be censored, exaggerated or
used for propaganda. So we have to compare and contrast to rely on the ...
... middle of paper ...
...- an idealistic picture of war, to keep everyone happy.
The soldier's accounts however, were completely different and
contradicted the official accounts in almost every way. There is a
possibility (although unlikely as so many soldiers accounts
complimented each other) that soldiers exaggerated the truth to make
themselves look more heroic. The reliability of some soldiers accounts
could be unbalanced due to emotions running too high, and then saying
something in spite or hatred towards Germany, the British government,
rats, lice etc.
In conclusion, I find that generally, the soldier's accounts were more
accurate than the governments as, at the end of the day, it was the
soldiers who lived and fought in the trenches and would clearly be
able to give a more accurate picture of trench life than official
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Robert Graves author of Good-Bye to All That, wrote about his life, particularly his time fighting in World War One. In his narrative one can see the experiences of the war and the influence that it had on him. He bore witness to and was victim to the advancements in military technology, like gas, machine guns, and tanks. He would write about his experiences in his trenches, as well as the cultural and social aspects that he saw in the military units and the areas he visited. However when comparing his narrative to the works of Jeremy Black, author of Warfare in the Western World 1882-1975 one can see the changes in warfare brought on by World War One.... [tags: World War I, Trench warfare, World War II]
1203 words (3.4 pages)
- Peter Weir 's Gallipoli is a tale of World War I and the Aussie involvement that portrays an account based on true events. Frank and Archy are brought to deliver a story of bravery that is fueled with the naivety of propaganda and ignorance. Weir gives us a deep tale of the hearts of the people and soldiers during the time of war. However, a series of grand realizations makes it apparent that Frank and Archy have been forcibly ripped from their youth in an endeavor that was doomed from the start. A duo who was fated for trouble from the start, Frank and Archy nearly spat in rejection to each others opinions: Archy wanted to be brave and a heroic figure that did something worthwhile for his... [tags: World War I, World War II, Trench warfare]
1201 words (3.4 pages)
- Trench Life According to Soldiers Rather than Official Accounts Trench warfare was a viscous and violent way to fight a war. In World War 1 there were over 600 kilometres of trenches that separated East and West Europe between Belgium and France. They were started by the Germans who dug them for protection after their defeat at Marne by Britain and France. Both sides kept on digging and digging their trenches to stop the other side form outflanking them. The trenches grew and the western front was formed.... [tags: Papers]
5618 words (16.1 pages)
- The first world war was defined by the heavy use of trench warfare, as the decorated soldier and writer Segfried Sassoon observed, “the war was mainly a matter of holes and ditches” (the great war, modern memory). Trench warfare was primarily utilized due for protection from opponent small arms fire and shelter from artillery, they kept soldiers on both sides safer and reduced casualties. Despite these benefits and many more, various primary and secondary sources can be used to question their efficacy.... [tags: World War I, Trench warfare, World War II]
734 words (2.1 pages)
- By late autumn of 1914, the western front had become the main battle ground splitting Europe in half extending from France to Belgium. This is the view that many soldiers like Franz Franke had seen until it became their eventual resting place. Franz Franke was a, “medical student from Berlin,” (Lualdi, 227) whose letter written in the first months of battle discusses the horrors of trench warfare as a, “living hell of shells and corpses,” (Lauldi, 227). The defining feature of the first world war in the West was this prison of immobility and stalemate.... [tags: World War I, Trench warfare, World War II]
787 words (2.2 pages)
- World War I: Trench Warfare In the early twentieth century, Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria-Hungary was assassinated by a Serbian nationalist, which in turned pulled in several countries into dispute, thus igniting the beginning of World War I. There were two parties involved, one which was the Triple Alliance, consisting of Germany, Austria-Hungary, and Italy, and the other was the Triple Entente, made up of Britain, France, and Russia. This war was one that was never fought before due to great advances in weaponry and war strategies that were utilized, on a scale that was never seen before.... [tags: World War I, Trench warfare, World War II]
1461 words (4.2 pages)
- Trench Life The idea of trenches first started in the battle of Marne in September 1914. The Schlieffen Plan had just failed and the Germans were forced to retreat back to Germany. The German commander, General Erich von Falkenhayn, was unhappy with this and decided that his troops should keep the parts in Belgium and France that they had gained at all costs. He ordered the Germans to build trenches to provide protection from the advancing French and British troops. The British and French troops found it impossible to break through, and to protect themselves, built trenches to counter attack the Germans.... [tags: Papers]
1163 words (3.3 pages)
- The Great War, fueled by the excessive pride of each country, devastated the world. Each side felt superior to the other and would not stop until it emerged as the victor. These countries altered the style of fighting from a primitive face-to-face combat to systematic style of battle through trenches. To adapt to this style, countries developed new weapons and tactics to prevail over their enemies. But, the war simply remained a draw. Trench warfare prolonged World War I by a causing a bloody stalemate where millions died from modern weapons and horrid living conditions.... [tags: Military History ]
1150 words (3.3 pages)
- We Were Soldiers The Vietnam War was a nightmare for many soldiers. It re-defined the meaning of war to an entire generation. As the conflict grew it became known around the world that this was a war that could not be won. After this was realized by America the main focus became to "get out" instead of "getting a victory". In the 2002 film We Were Soldiers, directed by Randall Wallace, a true account of the first major battle in Vietnam is given. At the beginning of the film he introduces to us many of the soldiers and their families.... [tags: Vietnam War We Were Soldiers Movies Essays]
1090 words (3.1 pages)
- Trench Warfare May 30, 1918 Dear Mother and Father, I am lying here in our trench, reflecting on how I miss the warmth of home and our family. The Battle of Cantigny broke out two days ago, and has been a living hell on Earth ever since. Cantigny is 60 miles north of Paris and was actually quite nice before the battle started. Now, it is smoke filled, muddy, and horrifying. As I am sure you have already heard, the United States made allies with England, France, Russia, Serbia, Romania, and Japan.... [tags: Papers]
547 words (1.6 pages)