Essay Comparison of "Persuasion" and "The Magic Toyshop"

Essay Comparison of "Persuasion" and "The Magic Toyshop"

Length: 2032 words (5.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Both The Magic Toyshop by Angela Carter and Persuasion by Jane Austen are constructed as love stories, although not conventional love stories. Austen's novel is part of the cultural movement of Romanticism as, although in earlier novels she satires Romanticism, Persuasion does bear some of the hallmarks of the Romantic period. Carter's novel however, can be seen as an ironic look at the Romantic novel. Therefore both novels provide an interesting viewpoint on their male characters, due not only to their style of writing but also to the novelists' gender and their obvious ideologies.

Jane Austen was an early standpoint feminist1 and so it is perhaps surprising to find her writing in the Romantic genre as it was "historically a male phenomenon"2 which not only objectified women but also "subjected them... in order to appropiate the feminine for male subjectivity"3. Female Romantic writers such as Austen "critique the dominant gender ideology of their time... present(ing) a more complex concept of female experience and capacities"4. In other words Austen's feminist viewpoint allows us to see a more realistic view of the world allowing Austen to provide a less sympathetic view of males and male behaviour then her male counterparts. Carter, however, uses a post-feminist view and so allows an ironical viewpoint on female Romantic writers' feminism, while taking further the critical look at the patriarchal male and the cycle of dominance and subsequent repression of women by males in general within the novel.

The main way in which the feminist standpoint is shown within both novels is through the use of free indirect style, a technique of narrating a character's thoughts, decisions and feelings through a combination of first- and t...


... middle of paper ...


...(London, Routledge (2nd ed.), 1997)
  • Jane Austen, Emma, (Norton, 1993)
  • Jane Austen, Persuasion, (Penguin, 1998)
  • Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice, (Oxford University Press, 1987)
  • Jane Austen, Sense and Sensibility, (Oxford University Press, 1933)
  • Angela Carter, Black Venus, (Vintage Press, 1995)
  • Angela Carter, The Bloody Chamber, (Vintage Press, 1995)
  • Angela Carter, The Magic Toyshop, (Virago Press, 2000)
  • Angela Carter, Wise Children, (Vintage Press, 1992)
  • J. Cowely, Persuasion, (York Press, 1999)
  • Sarah Gamble (ed.), The Fiction of Angela Carter, (Icon Books LTD., 2001)
  • C.L. Johnson, Jane Austen: Women, Politics and the Novel, (University of Chicago Press, 1988)
  • A.K. Mellor (ed.), Romanticism and Feminism, (Indiana Press, 1988)
  • A.K. Mellor, Romanticism and Gender, (Routledge, 1993)


  • Need Writing Help?

    Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

    Check your paper »

    The Magic Toyshop by Angela Carter Essay

    - Angela Carter wrote in various forms, she wrote novels, poetry, film scripts and she also translated the fairy tales of Charles Perrault and edited the Virago Book of Fairy Tales1. The Magic Toyshop is Angela Carter's second novel and winner of the John Llewellyn Rhys Prize (1969)2. The Magic Toyshop is a Bildungsroman, it follows the coming of age of Melanie, as she becomes aware of herself, her environment, and her own sexuality. The Magic Toyshop can in many ways be seen as following the conventions of a fairy tale and has been categorised as some as 'Magic Realism'....   [tags: fairy tales, charles perault]

    Strong Essays
    1948 words (5.6 pages)

    Modern Writers Writing in Gothic Tradition Essay

    - Modern Writers Writing in Gothic Tradition; Surfacing Transgression of Boundaries Via Gothic Elements in Angela Carter’s The Magic Toyshop & Fay Weldon’s The Bvlgari Connection Gothic as a literary term, most often brings to mind a type of novel – as well as a group of writers for a long time considered marginal - written between the second half of the eighteenth century and first half of the nineteenth. The contemporary use of the term Gothic retains an even larger number of meanings today....   [tags: The Magic Toyshop, The Bulgari Connection]

    Strong Essays
    2302 words (6.6 pages)

    Essay on The Magician Behind the Magic

    - Do you remember how David Copperfield makes the Statue of Liberty disappeared. Do you remember how he penetrated the Great Wall of China. And do you remember how a famous street magician David Blaine stayed in an ice tank without eating and drinking for seven days in the street of London. These famous magicians are great. However, we all know that magic is false, why the magicians are so successful. People might think that is because they are so fraudulent when they do a trick, they have a pair of extremely nimble and sensitive hand that even faster than our eyes....   [tags: magic, ]

    Strong Essays
    902 words (2.6 pages)

    The Outsider in Hamlet, by William Shakespeare and Persuasion, by Jane Austen

    - In today’s social environment a person can be distinguished as being either an insider or an outsider to their surroundings. An insider being defined as a person who is recognized and welcomed in to the social environment. In contrast an outsider is a person who finds themselves distinguished from the rest, commonly unaccepted into the norms of society. The idea of an outsider versus an insider is a modern idea that writers have described in many literary works; such as in Hamlet and Persuasion....   [tags: Hamlet, Persuasion]

    Strong Essays
    2229 words (6.4 pages)

    The Principles Of Persuasion By Robert Cialdini Essay

    - Principles of Persuasion When presenting a speech that is geared mainly at persuading your audience, there are principles that can be utilized to enhance the effectiveness of the speech. What does it mean to persuade. We need to understand what persuasion is before we can aim to persuade anyone. According to Mclean, 2010, “persuasion is an act or process of presenting arguments to move, motivate or change your audience”. There is not a single way of achieving this goal when giving a speech to persuade but the principles of persuasion can certainly enhance the likelihood at achieving this goal....   [tags: Persuasion, Regulatory Focus Theory]

    Strong Essays
    816 words (2.3 pages)

    The Magic Within Essay

    - Magic tricks have fascinated people of all ages for centuries. From David Copperfield to Chris Angel, many performers use magic to amaze and astound. One of the least elaborate types of magic tricks is the card trick. There are two main types of card tricks: there are mathematical card tricks and sleight of hand card tricks. The former are simple to learn, but do not impress audiences. To really attract attention, an aspiring magician should learn sleight of hand card tricks. Sleight of hand card tricks are tricks that use misdirection and special manipulations of a deck of cards to do something seemingly impossible....   [tags: How-To Essay, Magic Tricks]

    Strong Essays
    1398 words (4 pages)

    Essay on Discussing Six Principles Of Persuasion

    - Discussing Six Principles of Persuasion Anonymous University of the People Discussing Six Principles of Persuasion Whether in business or casual communication, there are times when it is the goal of one or both parties to convince the other of a specific viewpoint. In such instances, one must be effective in presenting the view and why it should be valued over others. Robert Cialdini tells us that by following six principles attempts at persuasion can be made more effective (as cited by McLean, 2010)....   [tags: Persuasion, Regulatory Focus Theory]

    Strong Essays
    997 words (2.8 pages)

    A Comparison of Runes and Magic in Beowulf and in Anglo-Saxon England Essay

    - Runes and Magic in Beowulf and in Anglo-Saxon England        In the Old English poem Beowulf we see the mention of runes, which were used with connotations of magic or charms. Examining evidence from historic times, we find that early Englishmen were fully conversant with the Germanic runic alphabet and that runes did have special connotations.   In Beowulf the hero is in deadly combat with Grendel’s mother in the mere. He is at the point of being killed by the monster when suddenly God shows to him the presence of a special sword nearby on the wall....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

    Free Essays
    1434 words (4.1 pages)

    Subversion of Class and Gender Roles in Jane Austen's Persuasion Essay

    - Subversion of Class and Gender Roles in Jane Austen's Persuasion         In Jane Austen's Persuasion, Mrs. Croft makes but few appearances and delivers little dialogue.  Nevertheless, Austen gives her significant narrative and thematic importance.  Mrs. Croft provides a foil for several of the Elliots, while developing a commonality with the frequently ostracized Anne.  This bond between Mrs. Croft and Austen's heroine valorizes Mrs. Croft's radical views concerning feminism and marriage.  Beyond signifying a paradigm shift in such social morals, though, the roles of Admiral and Mrs....   [tags: Austen Persuasion Essays]

    Strong Essays
    1960 words (5.6 pages)

    A Comparison of the Runes and Magic in Beowulf and The Saga of King Hrolf Kraki

    - Comparing Runes and Magic in Beowulf and The Saga of King Hrolf Kraki             There are runes and magic in the narratives of the poem Beowulf and The Saga of King Hrolf Kraki, an Iceland saga representing 1000 years of oral traditions prior to the 1300’s when it was written.   Beowulf is an Anglo-Saxon narrative poem whose oral traditions date back to the sixth century (Ward v1,ch3,s3,n11). Beowulf opens with a short account of the victorious Danish king Scyld Scefing, whose pagan ship-burial is described....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

    Free Essays
    3409 words (9.7 pages)