Comparative Analysis of "The Spanish Inquisition" and "Trent 1475" Essay

Comparative Analysis of "The Spanish Inquisition" and "Trent 1475" Essay

Length: 1565 words (4.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


In his lengthy undertaking, The Spanish Inquisition: A Historical Revision Henry Kamen attempts to readjust his readers thinking about the infamous Spanish Inquisition. Thirty years of research brought him to the conclusion that there was less persecution and horror in the Inquisition than pop culture and historians have drawn. In Trent 1475: Stories of a Ritual Murder Trial, R. Po-Chia Hsia takes the reader on a dark journey to the wretched persecution of a small community of Jews in the Italian city of Trent. Both books tell stories of minority groups becoming scapegoats for society, Kamen taking on an entire era of a country, and Hsia illustrating a vivid example. The books have some similarities and differences, and some strengths and weaknesses in their approaches. While Kamen's goal and emphasis tends to somewhat distort his story, he valiantly maintains his effort. In deconstructing the methods used to write these two books, it is clearly understood that while Kamen and Hsia are writing vastly different books, they are both entirely good works of history.

The smaller of the two works is Trent 1475: Stories of A Ritual Murder Trial. It tells the story of a small Jewish community accused of ritual blood sacrifice in Trent, Italy. This book creates a micro history that tells a much larger story of politics and society interacting with culture. Using the documentation of the trial, called the Yeshiva Manuscript, literature of the period, letters and contemporary literature, Hsia illustrates how the persecution of the Jews in 1475 has impacted and still impacts attitudes toward Jewish people. The most important source, the Yeshiva manuscript was put together by people after the trial, using the trial r...


... middle of paper ...


...iles up and students feel the weight of the past bearing down on them. Taking both Kamen and Hsia's books into account, there is enough evidence and variation of categories of evidence that give each author a well rounded book. While Hsia was arguing that the persecution of the Jews was horrible and misrepresented, Kamen was arguing something slightly different. While he didn't deny that the persecution of minority religions was not terrible, he contested that it was in more isolated incidents and had many varying aspects and motivations. Although Kamen and Hsia wrote in very different styles, their stories flow together and make great companion readings.

Works Cited

Hsia, R. P-Chia, Trent 1475: Stories of A Ritual Murder Trial (Yale University, 1992)

Kamen Henry, The Spanish Inquisition: A Historical Revision. (Great Britain: Weidenfeld & Nicolson)

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Council Of Trent : Ayik Malual Essay

- The Council of Trent - Ayik Malual The Council of Trent played a significant role in determining the result of the reformation. It was a gathering of the Priests, Bishops and Cardinals to discuss our matters of faith and determined the changes. It was held between december 1545-1563 under the support of three different Popes. (Paul III, Julius IIII, and Pius IV) in Trento & Bologna (Italy). The council being formed was a response to the protestants reformation, so they read and listened to their propositions....   [tags: Catholic Church, Christianity, Council of Trent]

Powerful Essays
1134 words (3.2 pages)

Spanish Missionaries Served As Conquerors For The Spanish Empire Essay

- Spanish missionaries served as conquerors for the Spanish empire because they overpowered the natives through their brute force and superior technology to expand their empire territorially as well as increase their faith. The Spanish had one and only objective: to control the new world and take from it whatever number wealth as could be allowed with a distinctly less vital objective was to christianize the natives. The Spanish had various innovative preferences which permitted them to rapidly overpower the natives, despite the fact that the natives were prevalent in number....   [tags: Colonialism, Spanish colonization of the Americas]

Powerful Essays
714 words (2 pages)

The Council Of Trent, By Martin Luther And John Calvin Essay

- The Council of Trent was held between 1545 and 1563, mostly in the Italian city of Trent. Though lengthy and drawn-out, it is one of the most important councils ever held, as it set a variety of institutional norms. For example, the seven sacraments were defined, it “set a uniform seminary system for the training of priests... it made the Roman liturgy a standard for Catholic services, and it defended traditional teaching and practices,” (Flint 327). There were two main purposes for the convening of the Council of Trent, and they were to battle the ever-growing Protestant Reformation, as well as to address the wide-spread corruption lifelong, devout Catholics were noticing....   [tags: Catholic Church, Protestant Reformation]

Powerful Essays
1083 words (3.1 pages)

Spanish Colonization And The New World Essay example

- Starting in 1492 with Columbus and continuing for 350 years, Spain settled and conquered almost all of South America, the American Southwest, and the Caribbean. The Spanish empire grew to be the largest European empire since ancient Rome, and it used the wealth that it obtained from the Americas to support nearly endless warfare in Europe, which protected the Americas with a large navy and a very powerful army and brought Catholicism to the New World. At this time, Spain saw the New World as unruly and uncivilized because most of the people there were pagan....   [tags: Colonialism, Spanish colonization of the Americas]

Powerful Essays
1257 words (3.6 pages)

Spanish As A Culture Of The United States Essay

- Emerald Johnson Spanish 123 Professor Haynes MW 8am Spanish as a Culture in the USA Bilingualism, bilingual education and the Hispanic population in the United States have become a very relevant topic due to the rising population of Spanish speaking people in this country. I am not as informed as I would like to be on the topic but I do know that 1 in 12 Hispanic people do not speak English. About 60% of the Hispanic population was born here and that does make a difference in the bilingualism of their culture....   [tags: Spanish language, Hispanic, Mexico]

Powerful Essays
1838 words (5.3 pages)

Essay on The Spanish Inquisition

- The Spanish Inquisition was the longest and most ruthless inquiry of faith of all time. Jews, Muslims, Hindus, Christians, and all non-Catholic religions were besieged by persecution from the Spanish government. Although it was not intended, thousands of innocent Spaniards were tortured and killed once the king and queen of Spain established the Inquisition. An Inquisition is a very complex process, and at first, seemed innocuous. Inquisitions were designated to be a series of tribunals (courts) held to push non- Catholics to repent and turn to Catholicism....   [tags: Religion, Catholic Church, Spanish Government]

Powerful Essays
718 words (2.1 pages)

Speaking Spanish in the USA Essay

- As a child, I had to navigate from an English speaking classroom to a Spanish speaking home. From eight in the morning I was given instruction in English by my professors at school. After three in the afternoon at home I engaged in Spanish conversation with my mother, father, and siblings. When the summer vacation came around, it was back to speaking Spanish only, and then I regained the Mexican accent that had faded away during the school year. My experience learning English was different from what earlier Spanish speaking generations in the United States dealt with....   [tags: Speaking Spanish Essay]

Powerful Essays
1401 words (4 pages)

Utilization Of Spanish Speech Testing

- Utilization of Spanish Speech Testing Flores, Martin, and Champlin (1996) moved into studying the application of Spanish speech tests in a clinical setting. Their study involved audiologists from across five states with the highest reported Spanish speaking population at that time: New Mexico, Arizona, California, Texas, and Colorado (Flores, 1996). 35% of audiologists from each of the aforementioned states were chosen randomly to participate in the 26-question survey that requested information about current clinical approaches to providing audiological services to their respective Spanish populations (Flores, 1996)....   [tags: Spanish language, Language, Multilingualism]

Powerful Essays
808 words (2.3 pages)

The Taino and the Spanish Essay

- The Taino and the Spanish Cristóbal Colón landed on an unknown island in the Caribbean on October 10, 1492. He planted banners in the beach claiming the land for the Spanish throne. Colón’s perceptions and interactions with the indigenous people, the Taino, sparked the events that lead to the colonization of the Americas. Colón’s perceptions of the Taino were misinterpreted by him. His misconceptions about the Taino were built from a compilation of his own expectations, readings of other explorers, and strong religious influence in Western Europe....   [tags: History Spanish Historical Papers]

Powerful Essays
1223 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on The Importance Of Learning Spanish

- As we approach the 21st century and as the idea of a "global village" is fast becoming a reality, it is vital that we enlarge our worldview and reach an understanding of, and appreciation for, the cultures of the other peoples who share the planet with us. As cultural beings, we are raised with an certain way of giving order to the world around us. Very soon, these "cultural filters," which allow us to make sense of reality and shape it, become fixed, invisible and unconscious; they are part of our worldview which - as unique as we might think it is - rests on the shared values of a particular linguistic community....   [tags: Learning Spanish]

Free Essays
599 words (1.7 pages)