Essay on A Comparison of "Creating the Myth" and "Beauty and the Beast"

Essay on A Comparison of "Creating the Myth" and "Beauty and the Beast"

Length: 742 words (2.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Linda Seger's hero myth from her publication "Creating the Myth" is very thorough in the steps involved in creating a hero of a story. All ten steps are very common to a typical hero story. However, there are some gaps in her theory. An example of a story that does not fit Seger's theory is the Disney version of the fairy tale Beauty and the Beast. This popular cultural phenomenon has within it an atypical hero, one who pokes holes in Seger's hero myth theory. This atypical hero, simply named Beast, does not fit all ten of the steps in a typical hero story.

It is obvious that Beast does not fit Seger's theory the moment he is introduced in the story. He described as a "spoiled, selfish, and unkind prince [with] no love in his heart." He lives in a great castle and has everything he could ever want, and is cursed to be a beast until he learns to love. Not only this, but within the first few minutes of the movie, Beast imprisons the damsel's father, Maurice, then the damsel, Belle, for simply entering his castle without his personal permission. This is far from what Seger describes as the introduction of the hero in a story. In the first step of her hero myth theory, she writes that that a hero "begins as a nonhero; innocent, young, simple, or humble" who is in "ordinary surroundings, in a mundane world, doing mundane things" (Seger 172). These two hero introductions are incredibly contradictory. While Seger explains that a hero is introduced as a modest, pure, and uncomplicated character, the character of Beast is actually quite complicated. He comes off as pretentious, carrying with him a complex curse, as well as a lack of compassion and guilt. His character establishment displays no likeness to the hero Seger ...


... middle of paper ...


...tangible release from his awful curse. Beast ultimately breaks the curse as well as getting the girl, but Belle's love was not a premeditated desire. It was merely an effect of his transformation and a reward for completing his goal. Steps sixth through eight of Seger's theory do not exist in the classic cultural phenomena of Beauty and the Beast.

Despite the very comprehensive hero myth theory Linda Seger created, it did not cover all hero stories. There are some stories, like the example of Beast from Beauty and the Beast, that do not fit her cut and dried examination of a hero's journey. Her theory, although very thought out and thorough, had some gaps in it that were not covered in her explanation of the steps in a hero myth.

WORK CITED

http://www.scifiscript.com/cartoon/beautyan/txt

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Comparing Mary Shelley's Frankenstein and the Prometheus Myth

- Comparing Mary Shelley's Frankenstein and the Prometheus Myth Mary Shelley's Frankenstein is subtitled "The Modern Prometheus", and rightfully so. Prometheus, the Titan of Greek mythology that created man and gave them fire, is a fitting symbol for Victor Frankenstein, the man who created a "monster" and gave him life. The most obvious aspect of the similarity between Frankenstein and the Prometheus myth is the underlying theme - both stories deal with ill-fated actions with tragic consequences....   [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]

Better Essays
2181 words (6.2 pages)

Origins of The Beauty Myth Essay examples

- Naomi Wolf's "The Beauty Myth," discusses the impact of our male-dominated society upon women. Wolf argues that women's most significant problems associated with societal pressures are a "fairly recent invention," dating back to the 1970s (6). She explains that women have "breached the power structure" by acquiring rights equal to men in areas such as, education, professional careers, and voting. As a result, Wolf suggests that the "beauty myth" is the "last one remaining of the old feminine ideologies that still has the power to control those women" (3)....   [tags: Naomi Wolf, The Beauty Myth]

Free Essays
1573 words (4.5 pages)

Analysis of The Beauty Myth by Naomi Wolf Essay

- Analysis of The Beauty Myth by Naomi Wolf The Beauty Myth, published by Doubleday in New York City, hit the shelves in 1992. Naomi Wolf wrote this 348-page book. Wolf attended Yale University and New College, Oxford University, where she was a Rhodes Scholar. Her essays have been printed in many well-known magazines and newspapers, including Esquire and the New York Times. The Beauty Myth was Wolf’s first book. She has also written two other books, Fire With Fire and Promiscuities. Wolf is a recognized feminist....   [tags: The Beauty Myth Feminism Naomi Wolf Essays]

Better Essays
589 words (1.7 pages)

The Beauty Myth Essay

- This essay is for women who believe their thighs are too big, their breasts are too small, their hair is boring, their skin is flawed, their body is shaped funny, or their clothes are outdated. This month's column is for women who believe their life would improve if they could lose 15 pounds; if they could afford contact lenses, that new perfume or anti-cellulite concoction; if they got a nose job, a face lift, a tummy tuck, etc. This month's column is for women who feel shame or unhappiness when they ponder some part (or all) of their body....   [tags: Beauty and the Media]

Better Essays
1967 words (5.6 pages)

The Beauty Myth Essay

- In today’s society it seems as though women are forced into being something that they are not. Women see pictures in magazines and they believe to be accepted by everyone else they need to look like an air-brushed image. I believe that some of the feelings from “The Beauty Myth” are still true in today’s society, but on the other hand I believe that it should not have to be this way. I believe that women’s feeling that they have to look like something they are not are brought on by advertisements like this one and many other things....   [tags: Beauty and the Media]

Free Essays
449 words (1.3 pages)

Comparing Hercules by Walt Disney and Creating the Myth by Linda Seger Essay

- One of the greatest Greek mythological stories portrayed in a movie would be Hercules. Hercules is a well-known hero; he displays a supernatural individual who has to overcome the villain and his bad monsters. In “Creating the Myth” by Linda Seger, she argues that the hero myth as many obstacles (the death experience, the road back, the reborn) that he or she need to overcome to be transformed into a hero. However, these obstacles play a very important role in the hero’s stage of initiation....   [tags: comparison]

Better Essays
849 words (2.4 pages)

Gender Stereotypes and the Beauty Myth Essay

- Dewing and Foster has proposed that a unisexual beauty myth may result in sexual equality. Therefore the purpose of this assignment is to investigate the impact beauty has on men and women. Thus, I look at how and why gender stereotypes and the beauty myth exist. Furthermore, I am also going to investigate how traditional beliefs of masculinity have changed. In addition, I also discuss the consequences that arise for men and women, because of the beauty myth. Lastly I will discuss the interrelation between gender and age and how double standards apply for ageing men and women in society....   [tags: sexual equality, femininity, masculinity]

Better Essays
1059 words (3 pages)

Essay about The Beauty Myth, by Naomi Wolf

- "Our culture is depicting sex as rape so that men and women will become interested in it." - Naomi Wolf, The Beauty Myth (1991) Feminists for decades have been battling against the media for depicting images of women that they consider to be demeaning and obscene for the sake of beauty. This quotation, taken from feminist best-seller, Naomi Wolf, puts into perspective the feminist views of the damage that media induces on its female consumers and the subliminal message it sends to both men and women....   [tags: feminist, rights, rape]

Better Essays
1268 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Beauty Pageants : The Beauty Pageant

- There are many different types of beauty pageants in today’s society, but a child beauty pageant consist of modeling sportswear, evening attire, dance and talent. The children are judged based on individuality in looks, capability, poise, perfection and confidence. As the judges call it, "the complete package". There are two main types of beauty pageant the natural pageant and the glitz pageant. Glitz pageants are the "glamour" pageants where girls are dressed in high fashion, evening gowns and swimsuit....   [tags: Beauty contest, Child beauty pageant, Beauty]

Better Essays
1743 words (5 pages)

The Beauty Myth Essay

- The Beauty Myth Rosa MacCauley began her phenomenal life on February 4, 1913 in Tuskegee, Alabama. Her mother was a schoolteacher and taught Rosa at home until age 11. Her father, who was a carpenter and a builder, left the family because he wanted to travel, but his wife wanted a permanent home. (Guest History Month 1) As a little girl, Rosa McCauley was afraid to go to sleep at night. She has several memories of white people who rode horses burning crosses and scaring black people. These people that Rosa described in her memories were members of the group known as the Ku Klux Klan (KKK)....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
832 words (2.4 pages)