Nature and Humanity, a Comparison of Poems Essay

Nature and Humanity, a Comparison of Poems Essay

Length: 1540 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

When humans and nature come together, they either coexist harmoniously because nature's inhabitants and humans share a mutual respect and understanding for each other, or they clash because humans attempt to control and force their ways of life on nature. The poems, "The Bull Moose" by Alden Nowlan, "The Panther" by Rainer Maria Rilke, "Walking the Dog" by Howard Nemerov, and "The Fish" by Elizabeth Bishop, describe what happens when humans and nature come together. I believe that when humans and nature come together they either clash and conflict because individuals destroy and attempt to control nature, which is a reflection of their powerful need to control themselves, or humans live peacefully with nature because not only do they admire and respect nature, but also they can see themselves in nature.

The poem "The Bull Moose" illustrates that when humans and nature come together, they clash and conflict because humans attempt to control nature in order fulfill their need to control themselves. In the poem, the moose is on his death march and searching for a place to die peacefully. During his search, after leaving his natural environment of "trees [and] mountain[s]," the moose approaches a "pole-fenced pasture." This "fenced pasture" symbolizes the division between the moose's natural free environment and the environment dominated and controlled by humans. When the moose reaches the environment dominated by humans, he approaches the cattle, and rather than greeting the moose in a friendly manner, the cattle symbolically move "to the other end of the field" because they realize that the moose is not like them and does not belong in their environment. This situation illustrates the clash between the human environment...


... middle of paper ...


...nizes the fish because, just like the fish, people fight daily battles to survive in life. This humanization of the fish enables the speaker to relate and respect him, and therefore, ultimately leads to his release.

The poems, "The Bull Moose" by Alden Nowlan, "The Panther" by Rainer Maria Rilke, "Walking the Dog" by Howard Nemerov, and "The Fish" by Elizabeth Bishop, illustrate what happens when people and nature come together, but the way in which the people react to these encounters in these poems is very different. I believe that when humans and nature come together either they clash and conflict because individuals destroy and attempt to control nature, which is a reflection of their powerful need to control themselves, or humans live peacefully with nature because they not only respect and admire nature, but also they can see themselves in the nature.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Understanding Lyric Poems through Tone and Metaphor Essay

- Lyric poetry is a form of poetry where the author expresses his/her feelings and thoughts in a brief, compressed manner (Stanford). It is the most popular and common type of poetry today, conveying the authors emotions to the readers (Grimes). Although these poems allow the author to personally express him or herself, they should not be confused with stories like narrative poems (Grimes). Lyric poems can easily be compared to one another based on certain criteria. It is useful to compare these poems so that one can identify and become familiar with the different styles in lyric poetry....   [tags: Lyric Poems, poetry, Tone, Metaphor, ]

Powerful Essays
969 words (2.8 pages)

Herbert's Metaphysical Poems Essay

- Herbert's Metaphysical Poems In the first portion of The Temple, specifically Perirrhanterium, Herbert prescribes the didactics necessary for the instruction of the catechumen in a simple, straightforward manner. As the reader moves into the main section of The Church, the author’s poetic wit becomes more complex in both its style and depth of topic. Although the starkness of the messages in Herbert’s metaphysical poems is not as palpable as those of the Church Porch, their ability to teach both abstractly and visually affords them a didactic nature much like the parables of Christ....   [tags: Herbert Metaphysical Poems Essays]

Powerful Essays
3456 words (9.9 pages)

Robert Frost 's Poems About Nature Essay

- Robert Frost, famous for his poems about nature, was a New England poet and farmer. Frost was born in 1879, in the state of California. At the age of eleven, Frost’s father died and subsequently the family moved to New England. Although Frost was born in California, he identified with the working farmers of New England. Frost bought his first farm in Derry, New Hampshire. Living and owning his own farm gave Frost firsthand experience with agriculture and living with nature. From harvesting the crops to staying warm in the winter, Frost knew the hardships of being a farmer in New England....   [tags: Robert Frost, Life]

Powerful Essays
2012 words (5.7 pages)

Essay about Comparison of Snakecharmer and In the Snake Park

- Comparison of Snakecharmer and In the Snake Park    There are many methods available for poets to utilize in creating a desired effect. They may take a number of different approaches to enhance an aspect of their poetry. Both Snakecharmer, by Sylvia Plath and In the Snake Park, by William Plomer show how the poets take advantage of different techniques to illustrate the world of the snake, and draw us into it. Plath using diction and Plomer using imagery, both describe the snake in order to establish a mood for their poems....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
825 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on The Epic Poems Of Gilgamesh And Ovid

- The epic poems of Gilgamesh and Ovid’s Metamorphoses contain an almost uncanny resemblance in terms of certain events that take place within both works of literature. Within the poems, one may compare both interpretations of the flood in such a way that could make it difficult to discern their differences. However, despite how comparable the poems may seem, they do pose specific differences that separate them from one another. Although these poems are extremely similar in context, they share differences in terms of cause and effect....   [tags: Epic poetry, Epic of Gilgamesh, Noah's Ark]

Powerful Essays
768 words (2.2 pages)

The Recreation of Nature Essay

- Can words be art. A part of nature. For centuries, people have written stories, poems, and drawn pictures to represent the world around them. However, the question occurs: Is art a form of nature. One possibility, as suggested through symbolism in Wallace Steven’s “The Poem That Took the Place of a Mountain” is that mankind can recreate nature through art. An alternative, as suggested through personification in “The World is too much With Us“ by Williams Wordsworth is that humans cannot recreate nature through art, and mankind is disconnected from the natural world....   [tags: Literature]

Powerful Essays
915 words (2.6 pages)

A Comparison of Second Coming and World Is Too Much with Us Essay

- Ability to Foresee The Future in Second Coming and World Is Too Much with Us The world is changing and evolving at an astounding rate. Within the last one hundred years, the Western community has seen advances in technology and medicine that has improved the lifestyles and longevity of almost every individual. Within the last two hundred years, we have seen two World Wars, and countless disputes over false borders created by colonialists, slavery, and every horrid form of human suffering imaginable....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
1444 words (4.1 pages)

Comparing Nature in Wordsworth’s Ruined Cottage, and Coleridge’s Rime of the Ancient Mariner

- Comparing the Representation of Nature in Wordsworth’s Ruined Cottage, and Coleridge’s Rime of the Ancient Mariner For most poets of the Romantic Age, nature played an invaluable role in their works. Man’s existence could be affected and explained by the presence and portrayal of the external nature surrounding it. William Wordsworth and Samuel Taylor Coleridge are no different from the other Romantic poets, and their works abound with references to nature and its correlation to humanity....   [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]

Powerful Essays
2910 words (8.3 pages)

Nature in Robert Frost's Poems Essay

- Under the stars of the sky, fifteen-year old Robert Frost explored the heavens through a telescope. He was seeking affirmation of the proverbial question that has plagued mankind for centuries—the proof and existence of God. While surveying the cosmos, Frost‘s interest was stirred, so he visited a library and obtained books that had illustrated star charts. Within these pages, his knowledge of the stars was edified and a poet was born. Frost‘s first poems were ―astronomical‖ and invoked a kinship of ―cosmology and theology‖ (Haas 255)....   [tags: Nature in Poems of Robert Frost 2014]

Powerful Essays
1636 words (4.7 pages)

Comparison of The Lamb and The Tyger by William Blake Essay

- When do we change. When do we change from being the innocent children God sent into the world, to the corrupted ones that leave the earth. William Blake’s ‘Songs of Innocence and Experience examine these different states. Blake wanted to show the two contrary states in the human mind. The Lamb and the Tyger are just vehicles for Blake to express what he feels happens to people as they grow, develop and eventually become perverted by the world around them. Blake’s background and occupation greatly influenced the style and content of his poems....   [tags: The Lamb The Tyger William Blake Essays]

Powerful Essays
2188 words (6.3 pages)