Essay about Compare and Contrast - Story of an Hour and Astronomer's Wife

Essay about Compare and Contrast - Story of an Hour and Astronomer's Wife

Length: 635 words (1.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Good Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Compare and Contrast

Story of an Hour and Astronomer's Wife

It is a very difficult task for women to live a content life while in a despondent marriage. Though it has been done, it is simply no easy task. In the short stories "Story of an hour", and "Astronomers Wife" Kate Chopin and Kay Boyle both suggests to their readers that a woman needs a man to connect with her physically to be happy. The two stories both share the thesis that women are being held back by their husbands and there is plenty of evidence to prove this. With Chopin's story taking place in the 50's, and Boyle's story taking place at the turn of the century, they encounter parallel situations with a time difference of almost 50 years.

If we compare the wives in the two stories, we can see that they are quite similar. Mrs. Mallard in "Story of an Hour" dislikes her husband. She's despondent with her marriage and has no children. She wants to be free from her marriage and she does not want another marriage. She wants to live her own happy and private life but she's stuck with her husband. In "Astronomers Wife", Mrs. Ames also dislikes her husband, also is unhappy with her marriage, and also wants freedom from her current marriage. The difference however, is that unlike Mrs. Mallard, she does want another marriage; she wants a different man. She just doesn't want the husband she has now. She feels that she doesn't receive enough attention from him because he is always so captivated by his work. As you can see, these two characters are so similar in two different stories as well

as two different points in time. This shows the readers that this unhappy marriage issue is not a very unusual problem. It happens to many people in many diffe...


... middle of paper ...


...o start a new life. The freedom that she desired has been achieved and there is hope for a happier marriage after all.

As you can see, the two short stories both evidently share the same thesis that women are being held back by their husbands. Mrs. Mallard and Mrs. Ames are those women. Unfortunately, Mrs. Mallard wasn't too successful with her goal and she has a tragic death. Mrs. Ames however, got what she had desired, a new man, new relationship, and a new start. It was more difficult for women to make a standing point or just to be heard during Mrs. Mallard and Mrs. Ames times. They didn't have as much of

a voice as they do today. For Mrs. Mallard in "Story of an Hour", it seems that it may be better to die, then to live in chains. For Mrs. Ames on the other hand, she found the man that a woman needs to connect with her physically to be happy.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Analysis of The Astronomers Wife by Kay Boyle Essays

- Analysis of The Astronomer's Wife by Kay Boyle In the "Astronomer's Wife" by Kay Boyle, something as simple as a conversation with a plumber about a stopped elbow is enough to trigger an awakening in Mrs. Katherine Ames. When Mrs. Ames realized that the plumber was talking about something she understood (the stopped elbow), she realized that her marital problems were not the result of a division betwwen the sexes; instead, she realized that some men, like the plumber, are as practical as she is, and that some other men, like her husband, scorn people like her because they are intellectually inclined....   [tags: Astronomers Wife Kay Boyle Essays Papers]

Free Essays
778 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Astronomers Wife – Just a Simple Complex Tale

- Astronomers Wife – Just a Simple Complex Tale      Kay Boyle's literary piece titled "Astronomers Wife", is a mental exercise. Every word and every line has an important meaning to it. Interpretation is a critical skill in understanding everything Boyle's story has to offer. Although this piece has a lot of sophistication to it, the story line is rather simple. The time period is the early 1900's and the story is regarding a rather young husband and a wife, in there late twenties to mid thirties....   [tags: Astronomers Wife Essays]

Free Essays
2694 words (7.7 pages)

The Story Of An Hour By Kate Chopin Essay

- The Story of An Hour is an emotional rollercoaster that portrays social sanctions, struggles of women in the late 1800’s, and even death. During the 18th century women had very little education. Schooling and work was left to the men; any intention of a woman attending school or earning an income was looked down upon. Such restraints forced women to take care of the house, children, and any religious obligations while men were absent working to provide for the household. Kate Chopin’s thesis is throughout the late 18 hundreds women were stuck in controlling and emotionally detached relationships....   [tags: Woman, Wife, The Story of an Hour]

Good Essays
1073 words (3.1 pages)

The Story Of An Hour By Kate Chopin Essay

- In Kate Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour”, the struggle for freedom is dominant. The main character, Mrs. Mallard, stands for a woman who is struggling internally and externally for freedom. After the sudden loss of her husband, Mrs. Mallard gets a taste of the freedom she was lacking in her marriage. Like Mrs. Mallard, women throughout history have struggled to find freedom and success away from their husbands. Chopin herself only became successful after the loss of her husband. In “The Story of an Hour”, Chopin shows women’s struggle for freedom during the Victorian period through Mrs....   [tags: Woman, Wife, The Story of an Hour]

Good Essays
1003 words (2.9 pages)

Compare and Contrast Women in The Yellow Wallpaper and Story of an Hour

- Compare and Contrast Women Characters in The Yellow Wallpaper and Story of an Hour       Women have traditionally been known as the less dominant sex.  Through history women have fought for equal rights and freedom.  They have been stereotyped as being housewives, and bearers and nurturers of the children.  Only recently with the push of the Equal Rights Amendment have women had a strong hold on the workplace alongside men.  Many interesting characters in literature are conceived from the tension women have faced with men.  This tension is derived from men; society, in general; and within a woman herself.  Two interesting short stories, “The  Yellow Wall-paper and “The Story of an Hour, “...   [tags: Yellow Wallpaper Story of an Hour]

Free Essays
1712 words (4.9 pages)

The Life Of An Hour By Kate Chopin Essay

- Rest in Peace One of the uttermost remarkable transformations to women throughout the world took place during the 19th century. Moreover, this renovations led to notable changes in women’s roles. During this period of time the portrayal of females was to follow their chores in their homes and to take care of the children. In contrast, the role of men during this phase was to regulate the laws in their family. Kate Chopin was a writer that described precisely the reality of women in her vast number of stories....   [tags: Fiction, Marriage, The Story of an Hour, Wife]

Good Essays
819 words (2.3 pages)

The Story Of An Hour By Kate Chopin Essay

- Like many authors, much of the inspiration for the characters and setting in Kate Chopin’s stories (in this case “The Story of an Hour”) are drawn directly from her own family, experiences and various homes. Thomas Dillingham quotes Emily Toth in an article saying that “[Chopin was] a writer committed to exploring problems and championing causes she had encountered during her life” (1). For instance, Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour” share not only the similarities between the physical conditions and fate of the characters similar to herself and her family members, but also the themes of being trapped within marriage and society that she and her mother shared, and also the idea that only death...   [tags: Family, Marriage, Wife, The Story of an Hour]

Good Essays
723 words (2.1 pages)

Quest for Love in Astronomer's Wife, The Life You Save, and When I consider how my light is spent

- Every human being is entitled to his or her own personal way of life, making that person his or her own individual. The idea of an unbalanced role in life between the sexes is ongoing, and is beautifully described in Kay Boyle's short story, "The Astronomer's Wife." It is here where the author states, in order "to survive women cling to the floating debris on the tide" (59). No longer would the astronomer's wife need to hold on to something to survive, for she has found her identity because of the plumber's clarity and truthfulness, something she has been denied by the astronomer....   [tags: Comparison Compare contrast Essays]

Good Essays
1615 words (4.6 pages)

Epiphany in Astronomer’s Wife, When I consider how my light is spent and Everything That Rises Must

- Epiphany in Astronomer’s Wife, When I consider how my light is spent and Everything That Rises Must Converge The short story, “Astronomer’s Wife,” by Kay Boyle is one of perseverance and change. Mrs. Ames, because of neglect from her husband, becomes an emotionless and almost childlike woman. As a result, Mrs. Ames, much like John Milton in his poem, “When I consider how my light is spent” (974), is in darkness, unaware of the reality and truth of the outside world. However, the plumber who is trying to repair leaking pipes in her house, starts by repairing the leaking pipes in her heart....   [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]

Free Essays
1783 words (5.1 pages)

Kate Chopin's The Story of an Hour Essay

- In the era in which this short story was written, marriage was viewed differently as people view it today. Chopin is probably expressing her view on marriage through the character of Mrs. Mallard and her actions upon discovering that her husband had just past away. This was a time where woman were considered second hand citizens compared to men and where men may have voiced their authority and influence on their wife, not really giving them a chance to have their own opinion. Where in Mrs. Mallard's case may have caused her to bottle up her negative feelings of her husband....   [tags: The Story of an Hour 2014]

Good Essays
691 words (2 pages)