What View Do You Think Calderon Is Inviting His Audience to Take of Gutierre's Actions and How?

What View Do You Think Calderon Is Inviting His Audience to Take of Gutierre's Actions and How?

Length: 1085 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Good Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

As a dramatist, Calderon was not in a position to express his personal opinion in such a direct manner, as perhaps a novelist is able to. Despite this, dramatists found other ways to manipulate their characters and therefore the reaction of their audience. The characterisation of the protagonist don Gutierre in `El Medico de su Honra' has created a multitude of disagreement amongst the critics concerning his culpability. It is through don Gutierre's actions that the audience is able to come to a conclusion about his character and for what reason he has decided to behave in such a way.

What I believe to be the most important characteristic of the whole play is the theme of honour, which evidently is the main motivation for all the characters. It is vital to consider the character of don Gutierre hand in hand with the `code of honour' which is the backdrop for the play. C. A Jones defines in his article "Spanish Honour as Historical Phenomenon, Convention and Artistic Motive" the honour code as a series of "demands made on the individual by the conventions of the society of which he is a member." The conventions of Fourteenth Century Castille in `El Medico de su Honra' made honour, meaning ones reputation and integrity, the primary concern. It is clear from an early stage in the play how high don Gutierre esteems his honour when he refers to `el honor que hoy ha ganado/ nuestra casa' (Act 1, lines 510-511) which is solely due to the prince's injury. Moreover, don Gutierre is prepared to sacrifice his own feelings in order to protect his honour. On the one hand, he is prepared to spy on Mencia as he did to Leonor. Yet on the other, he fulfils the characteristics of a `hombre de bien' who is unwilling to jeopardise the hon...


... middle of paper ...


...t that this could relieve don Gutierre of some of the responsibility. However, I am still of the opinion that this does not excuse don Gutierre's guilt. His crimes are far too extreme to be excused, especially when they were executed in such a cold and calculated manner.

In conclusion, Calderon has created a multi dimensional character which allows the audience to come to their own conclusion. He has a developed psychological background, and his motives are clearly outlined from the outset. In addition to this, the honour code is also a heavy influence, and these aspects evoke sympathy from the audience. Yet at the same time, don Gutierre reacts in such a barbaric manner, which clearly indicates that he is an irrational human being, even if the circumstances which surround his make him simply a victim of a cruel social code and unfortunate circumstances.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Feminism : The Most Inviting Term Essay

- Feminism: the most inviting term, with the most backlash and the most hate. Feminism is the ideology that all humans, of all genders and races, of all sexual orientations and religions, should be treated and viewed equally. Feminism is the fight for equality and the fight against the mental mindsets society has built, yet somehow feminism has become a bitter term that people find offensive. Offensive… yes that is correct. How has someone’s fight for equality offended someone else. I personally can vouch for this statement....   [tags: Gender, White people, Sexism, Discrimination]

Good Essays
1731 words (4.9 pages)

Audience And Audience 's Speech

- Audience Analysis While giving a speech one must take in consideration of what will capture the audience’s attention, and what will not. There are also certain factors that may affect the audience’s reception of one’s speech. Some factors include audience size, the location of where the speech is going to be, how much time one has and gender composition. These are some examples of situational characteristics and audience demographics that can take a toll on one’s speech. Many will say that size does not matter, but in reality it does....   [tags: Gender, Sex, Audience, Male]

Good Essays
781 words (2.2 pages)

The Gender Of The Audience Essay

- • Gender- the gender of the audience to whom I’ll be presenting in front of will consist of both male and female genders. At the University of Michigan students here are considered equal no matter if they are male or female. The audience is made up of 11 female students and 6 male students. The topic I need to consider should be not be specifically gender linked for an audience that has mixed gender. • Age- The audience will consist of younger adults between the ages of 18 and 21 years old. I do in fact fall into this age range, so I could include a topic that I am interested in....   [tags: Audience theory, Audience, Education, Gender]

Good Essays
1099 words (3.1 pages)

Essay about Documentation Of Ephemeral Work As An Audience Member

- Documentation of ephemeral work as an audience member: I document my experience as an audience member by writing reviews of shows I see. These are then posted onto my blog. My initial notes develop into a review by considering the strengths and weaknesses of each performer. The format of a theatrical review is useful to me because I can learn lessons to apply to my own practice. Considering the processes of professional performers also allows me to engage at deeper levels as an audience member. Initial notes: Brooke sounded soft at some points....   [tags: Theatre, Actor, Performance, Audience]

Good Essays
1502 words (4.3 pages)

The Audience and Writing Essay

- The Audience and Writing Audience. Just one word yet it stirs frighteningly confusing images of perplexing thoughts in my mind. The word alone is strange, but when put in context of an essay it leaves me baffled and frustrated[d1] . The questions; “What is Audience?” “Why do I need it?” and, “What purpose does it serve?” are important to my finally some day understanding the concept of Audience, but at this point I can’t answer them fully[d2] . I can grasp the understanding of all the other aspects of writing an essay, although I may not incorporate them well in my paper at least I see why they are important....   [tags: Audience Definition Essays]

Good Essays
1045 words (3 pages)

Essay on Inviting Destruction in Duchess of Malfi

- Inviting Destruction in Duchess of Malfi It has been asserted that, through her willfulness, the Duchess invites her own destruction.  However the assertion has to be looked at from a 17th century point-of-view, as well as a modern one. The assertion is firmly rooted in the issue of human rights, and that issue has changed and evolved an enormous amount over the past few centuries, since Duchess of Malfi was written. Society in the early 17th century was very different from ours today; then, women were far below men in stature and respect - they had no rights, and husbands and other male family members treated them more like possessions than human beings....   [tags: Duchess of Malfi Essays]

Good Essays
917 words (2.6 pages)

The Audience Unveiled Essay example

- The Audience Unveiled The value of a book depends on the audience. The audience values in a book what is useful. But what is useful to a writer may be junk to those who don’t care to write. I am a writer. I can use a book that gives lessons in writing, a book that helps me write better. I don’t find a book on dry-wall installation useful; it may be entertaining, but entertaining is not useful....   [tags: Book Audience Audiences Essays]

Free Essays
1212 words (3.5 pages)

The Film Audience Essay

- It can be said that from the 1980s until now, there is been a great change in the manner in which films are processed by the film audience. What used to be a simple one-format escapism has now developed into whole worlds that audiences can delve into, with many different avenues to pursue. One of the most iconic films to have done this is the Harry Potter franchise. Spanning a generation, the franchise has settled into the hearts of the viewers and become a part of their history, rather than just a distanced picture on a screen....   [tags: Harry Potter, Film Industry, Audiences]

Good Essays
1368 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on Life is a Dream by Calderon

- Growing Up All Locked Up A person's ability to develop is due to two factors, maturation and learning. Although maturation, or the biological development of genes, is important, it is the learning - the process through which we develop through our experiences, which make us who we are (Shaffer, 8). In pre-modern times, a child was not treated like they are today. The child was dressed like and worked along side adults, in hope that they would become them, yet more modern times the child's need to play and be treated differently than adults has become recognized....   [tags: essays papers]

Free Essays
1163 words (3.3 pages)

You Are What You Think by David Stoop Essay examples

- You Are What You Think by David Stoop The Book I Choose is called, You Are What You Think by David Stoop. I picked this book because I could relate to the topic. During the time of the assignment I was faced with some life differencing changes, which were affecting my perception on myself....   [tags: David Stoop You What Think]

Free Essays
950 words (2.7 pages)